Salam again Brother Ansar and thanks for the link that led me to this really interesting thread. Here I have discovered too much that can be discuessed with U.

Its good to see U giving ur reasons in support of capital punishment and amputation. Plz permit me to share my views with U on them.

Brother U are forgetting that ALLAH knows very well that to whom he is giving his commands. Offcourse at the time of revealaion it was the Holy Prophet, but ALLAH knew very well that how the coming generations,who are going to implement his commands, will be able to do justice. A human is made to commit mistakes, no one can be like the holy prophet, he wasnt made like ordinary human being by ALLAH himself. To expect from the judge and witnesses that the justice done will be 100%? No way!!! than I have serious doubts. The laws of failed democracies of the world are made upon a principal that even if 10 culprits get away...but one innocent must not be punished. Coz that will be the greatest injustice in guise of justice.

Let me tell U about an incident which hit the national headlines in India recently. One Indian man who was working at a petrol station in Saudi Arabia had a spat with someone on a trivial issue. That Arab was having some screw driver in his hands which accidently pricked his eye and the eyesight was lost consequently afterwards. The shariyah court ruled that eye of the accused should be popped out. The company which employed the accused offered some money to victim which he initially refused but after the Indian government intervened than the victim pardoned the accused just a week back. Thanks GOD.......so this is shariyah justice.....and saying that it is prescribed by ALLAH seems blasphamous to me at least. Had the poor accused lost his eye than would U have called a justice? From the all merciful ALLAH? For ALLAH sake plz think again.

Brother I have read all that Dr.Dawalbi had to say, but how to testify it? Saudi society is one of the most secret kind of society. U can know about them as much as they want to let U know. In lack of freedome of press which Islam doesnt allows, what option U have to confirm the sincerety of what they say? And even if all that he says is true than how we know that what price had been paid to ensure no theft. And is that price worth paying?

Brother can ALLAH give this kind of laws to the ppls who are sinner by nature given from ALLAH himself? Dont he knows that how his laws will be misused against his innocent creations? I know Ur answer and that U must be having some justification with U too, but do u have a gaurantee that no innocent will be punished or killed by Islamic State?

There is more to come but next time Inshallah.

Thanks