Quote:
Originally Posted by Ansar Al-'Adl  Well, you could start by answering at least ONE of my points!! You've simply repeated here what I've just debunked. Is it that you simply do not understand what I've previously mentioned?
In fact, your entire allegation is constructed on the supposition that Dhul-Qarnayn IS Alexander the Great. But since this cannot be proven, the entire allegation collapses.
He's Dhul-Qarnayn. It has absolutely no relevance as to what he was known as by other nations.
And I already debunked this nonsensical claim in my posts which you ignored.
Such as? You were unable to refute EVEN A SINGLE POINT from the following article: http://www.islamic-awareness.org/Qur.../BBhorned.html
Relevant historical evidence has been examined in the above link.
You displayed a coin showing Alexander with horns coming out of his head. I could show you a similar picture of a devil, a cow, a goat or a child on halloween. I guess they all must be Dhul-Qarnayn too.
Most people?! The only names you've pulled are three - a modern translator, a classical historian, and a Muslim ascetic! The speculation on the part of a few individuals proves nothing in terms of his identity. |
You never debunked anything. You simply pointed me to an article, which isn't fair. I could do the same and ask you to read something and then claim "hah you're debunked". Please bring out some original facts IN YOU OWN WORDS. Don't just point me to huge articles and expect me to be impressed.
I repeat: I WILL NOT read any big "refutations" you point me towards. This is a typical tactic of religionists in that they seek to confuse their opponent by inundating them with huge irrelevant articles. Please bring me your own point and state them here ONE BY ONE.