Quote:
Originally Posted by Allahs_slave  can anyone tell me how bukhari and muslim used to work when they collected the hadiths? |
http://www.islamic-awareness.org/Hadith/Ulum/ Quote:
|
why do we consider both sahihs accurate and reliable?
|
Because they have been verified, authenticated, and unanimously confirmed by Muslim Hadith scholars for over a millenium.
Quote:
|
i heard they are the second most accurate sources after the holy qoran... but allah protected qoran from any change ... but did not say he'd protect hadiths of the prophet
|
He has protected the message of the Prophet Muhammad pbuh as well, and the Muslim scholars have accurately preserved the narrations from the Prophet.
Quote:
|
... wouldn't it be wiser for us to compare this huge number of hadiths with qoran before we follow what they say?
|
Already done. One of the conditions for a hadith to be authentic is that it must be in agreement with the Qur'an. So when the scholars declare a hadith to be authentic it means that it has satisifed all of these conditions. If you have a misunderstanding about a specific hadith and think it may conflict with the Qur'an, please bring it forward and we can discuss it inshaa'Allah.
Quote:
|
don't you think most of these hadiths described what muslims were asked to do AT THE PROPHETS TIME and not now, ....
|
No. The Message of Islam is not bound by time or place.
Quote:
|
one more thing... in what time did bukhari and muslim live ?
|
Aprox. 200 years after Hijrah.
