View Single Post
Old
  (#16 (permalink))
Allahs_slave
LI Senior Member
 
Allahs_slave's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 32
Reputation: 20
Rep Power: 0
Allahs_slave is on a distinguished road
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Amman, Jordan
Gender:Brother In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Re: How Reliable Is Saheeh Bukhari? - 05-19-2006

Assalamo alaykom brothers n sistas
Thanx for everybody who replied ur all very nice ..... i have read some of the links, and now i have no problem with the authenticity of the hadiths he wrote ... tho im still not convinced about whether we shud follow all these hadiths or not .... u see ... hadiths are 3 types ( or so ive read, words said by the prophet, things he used to do, and things he saw muslimeen do and did not stop them, how can the last two be explaination to qoran? this is exactly what i meant, alot of hadiths do not explain things said in qoran, i know all of sunna does not CONTRADICT with qoran but it surely does add obligations and rules not even mentioned in qoran...grownin a beard is a good example, allah says nothing about growing beards, but the prophet told muslemeen to grow beards to be different from mushrikeen, well alot of mushrikeen have beards now ... maybe back then where they lived mushrikeen did not have beards so the prophets ordered muslims to grow their beards in order to look different :S ... also the prophets clothes, alot of ppl try to copy the way the prophet dressed, but it wsa a cultural thing, we can't just consider everything the prophet used to do is sunna and imitate it, the prephet pbuh married aisha when she was very young .. does this mean we shoud marry a 9 year old because its sunna !? please explain to me im very confused

salamo alaykom
ahmad
   
 
Page generated in 0.08741 seconds with 9 queries