LI Islamic Forum - View Single Post

amirah_87 · 01:12 PM

ass salaamu alaykum

BRO' DHUL...this hadeeth .."movin' the finger up and down" is da3eef min qism as-shaad!!...
shadda bihi "Zaaida Ibn Qudaama" wa khaalafa 13 min ar-ruwaah

but al-Albaany rahimahullah says it's saheeh!....but i go with the qawl of it being da3eef!! That's what my teachers and most of Ulamaah al-Yemen have come to a conclusion with and i agree with it too...
and the right way is to just keep your finger pointed upwards and straight, without any movement!!...i can't remember the hadeeth it's in though...if any1 can remember it than plz post it in..

wa alaykum ass salaam

	(#211 (permalink))
amirah_87 Account Disabled Status: Offline Posts: 7,321 Reputation: 18127 Rep Power: 0 Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: 16°53'39.06"N 43°48'5.35"E Gender: Way of Life: Muslim	Re: QUIZ: How much SUNNAH do U KNOW?!?!? - 07-05-2006 ass salaamu alaykum BRO' DHUL...this hadeeth .."movin' the finger up and down" is da3eef min qism as-shaad!!... shadda bihi "Zaaida Ibn Qudaama" wa khaalafa 13 min ar-ruwaah but al-Albaany rahimahullah says it's saheeh!....but i go with the qawl of it being da3eef!! That's what my teachers and most of Ulamaah al-Yemen have come to a conclusion with and i agree with it too... and the right way is to just keep your finger pointed upwards and straight, without any movement!!...i can't remember the hadeeth it's in though...if any1 can remember it than plz post it in.. wa alaykum ass salaam Last edited by amirah_87; 07-05-2006 at 01:12 PM..