| An usual muslim
Status: Offline Posts: 603 Join Date: May 2006 Location: Allahumma inni as'alukal jannah!!! Amin Gender:  Way of Life: Muslim |  Re: QUIZ: How much SUNNAH do U KNOW?!?!? -
07-07-2006
Quote:
Originally Posted by amirah_87  ass salaamu alaykum
BRO' DHUL...this hadeeth .."movin' the finger up and down" is da3eef min qism as-shaad!!...
shadda bihi "Zaaida Ibn Qudaama" wa khaalafa 13 min ar-ruwaah 
but al-Albaany rahimahullah says it's saheeh!....but i go with the qawl of it being da3eef!! That's what my teachers and most of Ulamaah al-Yemen have come to a conclusion with and i agree with it too...
and the right way is to just keep your finger pointed upwards and straight, without any movement!!...i can't remember the hadeeth it's in though...if any1 can remember it than plz post it in..
wa alaykum ass salaam | 
I know theres ikhtilaf about this matter sis, and the opinions of sheikh Muqbil and syaikh Albani is there masha Allah. And syaikh Muqbil said its hadith Shaad, but my teacher had explained its because the understanding of hadith between Syaikh Muqbil and syaikh Albani a little bit differents about this Hadith shaad. I mean syaikh Albani and syaikh Muqbil -rahimahumullah- have a different view about what is hadith shaad, and all suyukh in Saudi go along with syaikh Albanis opinions masha Allah walhamdulillah. Cause most of the masyhur ulama such as syaikh Uthaymeen, syaikh Bin Baz and all moving their fingers while tashahuud. But CANI tell you all that the opinion of syaikh Muqbil is wrong? NO...its free to choose wether you wanna move it or not moving it :brother: . Cause its ikhtilaf and each imam have daleel about it.
So sis amirah...you cant say "the right way"is not moving the finger, but say it " I choose" the opinion of shaikh Muqbil bin Hadee, So I think its not correct if you say its "the right way", right?
As for me, I always moving my finger, cause I remember, althought the rawi of hadith Wail bin Hujr (if Im not mistaken) is just alone narated the hadith about moving the finger, still syaikh said " no one said the rawi is dhaif". So...isnt it that we have to bring hadith thats the meaning still mujmal to hadith that means khusus?  So...they said the hadith about Rasulullah didnt move his finger is hadith thats still Amm, and the hadith about moving the finger is hadith thats khusus (more specific)...Allahu A'lam. And I think syaikh Albani is more 'alim and masyhur in hadiths knowledge Allahu A'lam.
So we are free to choose what to do, wether moving it or not moving it :brother: . Its ikhtilaf insha Allah.
Then which of the favours of your Lord will ye deny? Woe unto the repudiators on that day! |
| |  |