Quote:
Originally Posted by Salah ad-din  Can your highly respected scholars proove music to be haram? Whne Muhammad(saw) enter the gates of Mecca the women and men greeted him with music and singing, and he mentioned nothing about what they were doing to be haram. |
i never heard anything about them greeting him with music. They played the duff when he entered Medina
Theres a time when Aisha RA was singing and abu bakr RA said
"THE INSTRUMENTS OF THE SHAYTAAN, in front of rasullulah saws", implying that it is the instruments of the DEVIL! But rasullulah saws said to leave them, why? "IT WAS EID!". So if done it should be on an extremely rare basis with "DUFF" only.
anymore daleel?
