| An usual muslim
Status: Offline Posts: 603 Join Date: May 2006 Location: Allahumma inni as'alukal jannah!!! Amin Gender:  Way of Life: Muslim |  Re: QUIZ: How much SUNNAH do U KNOW?!?!? -
01-29-2007
Quote:
Originally Posted by umm-sulaim  The hadeeth that says we move our fingers up and down is weak in it's chain of narration, in it is zaa'id bin qodaamah who opposed 13 other narrators. So what seems to be apparent from this is that we point our finger in tashahod and we don't move it, and Allah knows best.
wassalaam | 
How are you guys? Masha Allah, Masha Allah, I hope everyone are fine insha Allah.  where are you guys?
And about moving the fingers, ukhtil karimah, I think its best to tell hmi that theres ikhtilaf about moving the finger  Its only sheikh Muqbil - rahimahullah- and maybe some shuyukh in yemen who said this hadith is shaad, but how about sheikhul kabeer, Al Imamul hadith Al mujadid Shaikh albani rahimahullah, how about sheikh Ibn Uthaymeen, How about sheikh Bin Baz and most of shuyukh in saudi? They said YES we move the finger. Even sheikh Uthaymeen said we move it in every sit. My ustadh evplained that theres a different opinion in explaining what is hadith shaad between those shuyukh and syaikh muqbil, thats the problem. Eventhough the hadith of Wail bin Hujr shaad, but still its sahih and no imam ever said its dhaif, we should remember that. But about this, then its wise if we tell them theres ikhtilaf, and we may choose both of them, Allahu Alam.
Then which of the favours of your Lord will ye deny? Woe unto the repudiators on that day! |
| |  |