View Single Post
Old
  (#5 (permalink))
Z.AL-Rashid
Truth+Justice=Islam
 
Z.AL-Rashid's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 1,008
Reputation: 8062
Rep Power: 25
Z.AL-Rashid has a reputation beyond reputeZ.AL-Rashid has a reputation beyond reputeZ.AL-Rashid has a reputation beyond reputeZ.AL-Rashid has a reputation beyond reputeZ.AL-Rashid has a reputation beyond reputeZ.AL-Rashid has a reputation beyond reputeZ.AL-Rashid has a reputation beyond reputeZ.AL-Rashid has a reputation beyond reputeZ.AL-Rashid has a reputation beyond reputeZ.AL-Rashid has a reputation beyond reputeZ.AL-Rashid has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: the soul created by Allah within a body sustained by Allah in his domain
Gender:Brother In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Re: is this hadith sahih (authentic) - 08-18-2007



Your intentions are well but you are asking the wrong people this question. You need to refer to the Ulema for this. Even if we knew the Isnaad we cannot derive it's authenticity as the character of those in the Isnaad is put to question etc You need to ask a Muhaddith this question;

As for the hadith scholar (al-muhaddith), he is the one who [1] knows the masters of hadith in his homeland as well as other lands; [2] has a precise knowledge of their date and place of birth and death, their ranking in the Sciences, and the various types of narratives they have in their possession; [3] differentiates those with longer chains of transmission from those with shorter ones; [4] is able to spot the hadith masters (al-huffâz) in the layers and the chains; [5] records them in writing; [6] recognizes the handwritings of the masters even if the same person's handwriting varies; [7] examines critically the narratives of the masters and extracts what he considers good from their narratives as well as his own, keeping aware of such qualities of chains as badal, muwâfaqât, musâwât, and the like (types of sound grades); [8] keeps a record of the names of his auditors even if their number is one thousand; [9] is an expert in the names of narrators, particularly those apt to be confused for one another, and obtains this discernment from the leaders in the discipline; [10] knows with precision the unusual words or names one comes across within the texts of hadith, or at least most of them, to avoid misspelling; [11] knows enough Arabic grammar to protect himself from language mistakes in most cases; [12] masters the terminology of experts in such way as is sufficient for teaching and explanation, and [13] keeps the proper terminology with respect to this and other disciplines.


If anyone in this forum fulfills the criteria for a Muhaddith given above you can ask them that question Insha'allah.
__________________

Ther R those who have knowledge and Kno they have it, The Teacher
Ther R those who have knowledge but do not kno they have it, The Gifted
Ther R those who do not have knowledge BUT kno they don't have it, The Seeker
There R those who don't have knowledge and don't kno that they don't, The Loser
   
Reply With Quote
 
Page generated in 0.09142 seconds with 9 queries