A question about Qiyamah? - Page 2

Abdul-Raouf · **Re: A question about Qiyamah? -** 10-18-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by abbas_ali

However, i've been doing a bit of reading and now the impression i am getting is that Every human, Muslim and non-Muslim alike, is held accountable for his or her deeds and are judged by Allah (which i already thought) but also i've read things like The dead rise from their graves and gather, waiting to be judged for their actions.

Only the muslims are questioned for their deeds...bro..

For non-muslims no questions regarding their deeds...

Hope im correct

?

___________________________________

First we are put in grave... then only on judgement day we move to Mahshar field...

(Its similar to the world situation... we are put in prison then we move to court...)

Ramlah · **Re: A question about Qiyamah? -** 10-18-2007

why/what makes you say that brother?

lmaestro · **Re: A question about Qiyamah? -** 10-18-2007

Salam
Im going off-topic here,my question is before Islam,were the people of the book told that there is such a thing as "barzakh" or life in grave by Allah?

Abdul-Raouf · 10:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by maryam11

why/what makes you say that brother?

Bro Abbas said....

Quote:

Originally Posted by abbas_ali

However, i've been doing a bit of reading and now the impression i am getting is that Every human, Muslim and non-Muslim alike, is held accountable for his or her deeds and are judged by Allah.

Only the muslims are questioned for their deeds...bro..

For non-muslims no questions regarding their deeds...

3 things happen dependin on the human

Being a non-muslim and doing good deeds doesnt count in ALLAH's court...Thats why they are directly put in hell...
And only the muslim is asked about his deeds... and if he fails he is put in Hell for some duration(long duration - unimaginable)... then he is transfered to heaven...
If the muslim passes the trail... he is directly put in heaven....

Hope im correct

IceQueen~ · **Re: A question about Qiyamah? -** 10-18-2007

INDIVIDUAL (personal) Judgement begins as soon as an individual dies and returns to Allah (that is when he encounters rewards or punishments for his own personal actions)

The Day of Judgement (a set date only Allah knows) is when EVERYONE will be judged TOGETHER and they will be shown all their deeds in the books that the angels recorded them in etc

hope that makes sense

Ramlah · **Re: A question about Qiyamah? -** 10-18-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by Abdul-Raouf

Bro Abbas said....

Only the muslims are questioned for their deeds...bro..

For non-muslims no questions regarding their deeds...

3 things happen dependin on the human

Being a non-muslim and doing good deeds doesnt count in ALLAH's court...Thats why they are directly put in hell...
And only the muslim is asked about his deeds... and if he fails he is put in Hell for some duration(long duration - unimaginable)... then he is transfered to heaven...
If the muslim passes the trail... he is directly put in heaven....

Hope im correct

I'll research this further, inshallah. i have never heard of this. but thats not to say that it isn't true.

Nabooly · **Re: A question about Qiyamah? -** 10-18-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by Abdul-Raouf

Bro Abbas said....

Only the muslims are questioned for their deeds...bro..

For non-muslims no questions regarding their deeds...

3 things happen dependin on the human

Being a non-muslim and doing good deeds doesnt count in ALLAH's court...Thats why they are directly put in hell...
And only the muslim is asked about his deeds... and if he fails he is put in Hell for some duration(long duration - unimaginable)... then he is transfered to heaven...
If the muslim passes the trail... he is directly put in heaven....

Hope im correct

Hmm...ive actually never heard that. But it doesn't go along with what ive heard and know...(not saying your wrong though

)

SAlam.

Ramlah · **Re: A question about Qiyamah? -** 10-19-2007

I found this. And it seems as if there is a scholary difference over whether the kaafir will be tested in his grave.

Quote:

(2) Will the kaafir be tested in his grave?
The ahaadeeth that we have quoted indicate that the kuffaar will be tested in their graves. But AI-Hakeem at-Tirmidhi, Ibn 'Abd aI-Barr and Suyooti13 held a different view. AI-Hakeem at-Tirmidhi quoted as evidence, that they will not be questioned, the fact that when previous nations refused to respond to their Messengers, the punishment was hastened upon them, unlike this ummah from whom the punishment is withheld. The Messenger (صلىالله عليه وسلم) has been sent with the sword, so whoever enters Islam for fear of being killed, then becomes a hypocrite, will be punished in his grave. But what he says is subject to further discussion, because Allah did not destroy the disbelievers of other nations after He had sent down the Tawraat. 14 Ibn 'Abd aI-Barr quoted as evidence the sahih hadith in which the Prophet (صلىالله عليه وسلم) said: "This ummah will be tested in their graves"; some versions say, "will be questioned”15 The saheeh ahaadeeth refute this understanding, and indicate that this is not limited to the believers or to this ummah.
'Abd al-Haqq al-Ishbeeli, Ibn al-Qayyim, Qurtubi, As-Safaareeni and others were of the view that the questioning (in the grave) includes all people. 16
----------------------------------------
13 Lawaami' al-Anwaar al-Bahiyyah, 2/10
14 See Lawaami' al-Anwaar al-Bahiyyah by As-Safaareeni, 2/10
15 Lawaami' al-Anwaar dl-Bahiyyah by As-Safaareeni, 2/10; Tadhkirat al-Qurrubi,
16Lawaami' al-Anwaar al-Bahiyyah by As-Safaareeni, 2/10; Tadhkirat al-Qurtubi,

Source:The Minor Resurrection (What Happens After Death) In the Light of the Qur'an and Sunnah : The Final Day Book 1: Islamic Creed Series Volume 5. By: Umar S. al-Ashqar

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

	(#17 (permalink))
Ramlah La illaha illa-llah Status: Offline Posts: 2,847 Reputation: 13906 Rep Power: 33 Join Date: Jul 2006 Location: Under the sun Gender: Way of Life: Muslim	Re: A question about Qiyamah? - 10-18-2007 why/what makes you say that brother? __________________ "يا أخي صوت أنين القدس فينا قد أهابة. أخوة في كل قطر يتشون المصابة. دمعهم بلى الثرى قطر وسفحا وانسكابا " ~~ "اللهم أعد مسجد الأقصى الى بلاد المسلمين" O Allah, return Masjid al-Aqsa to the Lands of the Muslims ~~A blog!~*~

	(#18 (permalink))
lmaestro Limited Member Status: Offline Posts: 42 Reputation: 48 Rep Power: 0 Join Date: Sep 2007 Location: Singapore Gender: Way of Life: Muslim	Re: A question about Qiyamah? - 10-18-2007 Salam Im going off-topic here,my question is before Islam,were the people of the book told that there is such a thing as "barzakh" or life in grave by Allah?

	(#20 (permalink))
IceQueen~ seaprincess~ Status: Offline Posts: 2,314 Reputation: 6503 Rep Power: 26 Join Date: Mar 2006 Gender: Way of Life: Muslim	Re: A question about Qiyamah? - 10-18-2007 INDIVIDUAL (personal) Judgement begins as soon as an individual dies and returns to Allah (that is when he encounters rewards or punishments for his own personal actions) The Day of Judgement (a set date only Allah knows) is when EVERYONE will be judged TOGETHER and they will be shown all their deeds in the books that the angels recorded them in etc hope that makes sense __________________ How's the odd nights going? -Anyone notice how peaceful the 21st was? "Indeed in the remembrance of Allah do hearts find rest" ~piXie's goodbye~