IB Islamic Forum  
 

 


Notices
Clarifications about Islam Clarifying misconceptions about Islam and addressing allegations levelled against it.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
Old
  (#1 (permalink))
Quasi Muslim
 
wth1257's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 630
Reputation: 3930
Rep Power: 16
wth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enough
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Somewhere between Atheism and Islam
Gender:Brother In Humanity
Way of Life: Agnostic
Default Surah 9:29 - 07-20-2008

Hello

I haven't been around much but I'm still very interested in Islam. I am concerned about that verse. I have heard that the "fighting" need not be physical. Is that the only explination?
   
Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
Old
  (#2 (permalink))
On vacation.
 
aamirsaab's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 4,281
Reputation: 35665
Rep Power: 80
aamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really nice
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Leicester
Gender:Brother In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Re: Surah 9:29 - 07-20-2008


I'll have an answer up for this fairly soon.
__________________
Book on sharia law
Mosque-a-mania!
Mongesh!
Quote:
Someone said to the Prophet, "Pray to God against the idolaters and curse them." The Prophet replied, "I have been sent to show mercy and have not been sent to curse." (Muslim)
''Become the change''
   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#3 (permalink))
Quasi Muslim
 
wth1257's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 630
Reputation: 3930
Rep Power: 16
wth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enough
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Somewhere between Atheism and Islam
Gender:Brother In Humanity
Way of Life: Agnostic
Default Re: Surah 9:29 - 07-20-2008

Quote:
Originally Posted by aamirsaab View Post

I'll have an answer up for this fairly soon.
Thank you
   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#4 (permalink))
Account Disabled
 
------'s Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 0
Reputation: 0
Rep Power: 0
------ is an unknown quantity at this point
Join Date: Mar 2006
Way of Life: Undisclosed
Default Re: Surah 9:29 - 07-20-2008



An explanation can be found here

http://tafsir.com/default.asp?sid=9&tid=20980
   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#5 (permalink))
On vacation.
 
aamirsaab's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 4,281
Reputation: 35665
Rep Power: 80
aamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really nice
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Leicester
Gender:Brother In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Re: Surah 9:29 - 07-20-2008


My arabic isn't that good, but from what I know Qital means fighting. Surah 9 verse 29 begins with the word Qutilal. The translation reads: fight those. In which case, in verse 29 fighting relates to physical fighting.

However the importance lies in who this is aimed at and what the relevance of this ayat is. Now one of the scholar's notes states that the reason to fight is to put an end to the suzeranity of the unbelievers. Basically, what this ayat is trying to say is: you have two options: a system based on ignorance and a system based on the divine law. In this particular occasion, a muslim should fight for the system on divine law (aka Islamic law). However, the context relates to the time of the pagans (as shown in the tafsir link serene has provided). In other words, that ayat is for a specific time and place.
__________________
Book on sharia law
Mosque-a-mania!
Mongesh!
Quote:
Someone said to the Prophet, "Pray to God against the idolaters and curse them." The Prophet replied, "I have been sent to show mercy and have not been sent to curse." (Muslim)
''Become the change''
   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#6 (permalink))
Quasi Muslim
 
wth1257's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 630
Reputation: 3930
Rep Power: 16
wth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enough
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Somewhere between Atheism and Islam
Gender:Brother In Humanity
Way of Life: Agnostic
Default Re: Surah 9:29 - 07-21-2008

Quote:
Originally Posted by aamirsaab View Post

My arabic isn't that good, but from what I know Qital means fighting. Surah 9 verse 29 begins with the word Qutilal. The translation reads: fight those. In which case, in verse 29 fighting relates to physical fighting.

However the importance lies in who this is aimed at and what the relevance of this ayat is. Now one of the scholar's notes states that the reason to fight is to put an end to the suzeranity of the unbelievers. Basically, what this ayat is trying to say is: you have two options: a system based on ignorance and a system based on the divine law. In this particular occasion, a muslim should fight for the system on divine law (aka Islamic law). However, the context relates to the time of the pagans (as shown in the tafsir link serene has provided). In other words, that ayat is for a specific time and place.

So it is only in refrence to fighting the Roman Empire?
   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#7 (permalink))
IB Senior Member
 
Shakoor15's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 693
Reputation: 3162
Rep Power: 19
Shakoor15 will become famous soon enoughShakoor15 will become famous soon enoughShakoor15 will become famous soon enoughShakoor15 will become famous soon enoughShakoor15 will become famous soon enoughShakoor15 will become famous soon enoughShakoor15 will become famous soon enoughShakoor15 will become famous soon enoughShakoor15 will become famous soon enoughShakoor15 will become famous soon enoughShakoor15 will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: America
Gender:Brother In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Re: Surah 9:29 - 07-21-2008

This verse deals with the Jihad and it is only permitted to fight those who fight you. The verse below shows that you should fight when it is time to fight. BUT do not transgress the limits. wa laa ta'tadoo.
Fight in the way of Allah against those who fight against you, but begin not hostilities. Lo! Allah loveth not aggressors. (2:190)
__________________
   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#8 (permalink))
On vacation.
 
aamirsaab's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 4,281
Reputation: 35665
Rep Power: 80
aamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really niceaamirsaab is just really nice
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Leicester
Gender:Brother In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Re: Surah 9:29 - 07-21-2008

Quote:
Originally Posted by wth1257 View Post
So it is only in refrence to fighting the Roman Empire?
Pretty much. It's not for every muslim to carry out - only to those it was revealed to initially. What we can take from the ayat is the principle; divine law is better that the other laws. But that's really as far as that ayat is relevant to the muslims of today (in terms of what we have to take from it) - the rest is important but not relevant to what muslims are to follow.

Alternatively, just use the tafsir link.
__________________
Book on sharia law
Mosque-a-mania!
Mongesh!
Quote:
Someone said to the Prophet, "Pray to God against the idolaters and curse them." The Prophet replied, "I have been sent to show mercy and have not been sent to curse." (Muslim)
''Become the change''

Last edited by aamirsaab; 07-23-2008 at 08:31 AM..
   
Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
Old
  (#9 (permalink))
LI News Service
 
Uthmān's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 5,784
Reputation: 48997
Rep Power: 98
Uthmān is a glorious beacon of lightUthmān is a glorious beacon of lightUthmān is a glorious beacon of lightUthmān is a glorious beacon of lightUthmān is a glorious beacon of lightUthmān is a glorious beacon of lightUthmān is a glorious beacon of lightUthmān is a glorious beacon of lightUthmān is a glorious beacon of lightUthmān is a glorious beacon of lightUthmān is a glorious beacon of light
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Warrington, England
Gender:Brother In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Re: Surah 9:29 - 07-21-2008

A detailed answer can be found here.
__________________

"I spent thirty years learning manners, and I spent twenty years learning knowledge."

~ 'Abdullāh bin al-Mubārak (rahimahullah)
   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#10 (permalink))
Qaghan of LI
 
Fishman's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 3,730
Reputation: 19039
Rep Power: 50
Fishman has a spectacular aura aboutFishman has a spectacular aura aboutFishman has a spectacular aura aboutFishman has a spectacular aura aboutFishman has a spectacular aura aboutFishman has a spectacular aura aboutFishman has a spectacular aura aboutFishman has a spectacular aura aboutFishman has a spectacular aura aboutFishman has a spectacular aura aboutFishman has a spectacular aura about
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Airstrip One.
Gender:Brother In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Post Re: Surah 9:29 - 07-22-2008


Quote:
So it is only in refrence to fighting the Roman Empire?
Uh, the Prophet (peace be upon him) didn't fight Rome much, if at all...
__________________
   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#11 (permalink))
IB Oldskool
 
Keltoi's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 5,376
Reputation: 9281
Rep Power: 39
Keltoi will become famous soon enoughKeltoi will become famous soon enoughKeltoi will become famous soon enoughKeltoi will become famous soon enoughKeltoi will become famous soon enoughKeltoi will become famous soon enoughKeltoi will become famous soon enoughKeltoi will become famous soon enoughKeltoi will become famous soon enoughKeltoi will become famous soon enoughKeltoi will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Oklahoma, USA
Gender:Brother In Humanity
Way of Life: Christian
Default Re: Surah 9:29 - 07-22-2008

Quote:
Originally Posted by Fishman View Post


Uh, the Prophet (peace be upon him) didn't fight Rome much, if at all...
From my knowledge I can't think of any Muslim country that was in military conflict with any part of the shattered Roman Empire except for the Turks and Byzantines. Which is what we are talking about here, not the true Roman Empire.
__________________
"Imagination was given to man to compensate him for what he is not, and a sense of humor was provided to console him for what he is."
   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#12 (permalink))
Qaghan of LI
 
Fishman's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 3,730
Reputation: 19039
Rep Power: 50
Fishman has a spectacular aura aboutFishman has a spectacular aura aboutFishman has a spectacular aura aboutFishman has a spectacular aura aboutFishman has a spectacular aura aboutFishman has a spectacular aura aboutFishman has a spectacular aura aboutFishman has a spectacular aura aboutFishman has a spectacular aura aboutFishman has a spectacular aura aboutFishman has a spectacular aura about
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Airstrip One.
Gender:Brother In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Post Re: Surah 9:29 - 07-22-2008

Quote:
Originally Posted by Keltoi View Post
From my knowledge I can't think of any Muslim country that was in military conflict with any part of the shattered Roman Empire except for the Turks and Byzantines. Which is what we are talking about here, not the true Roman Empire.

The word 'Byzantine' is a modern invention, they never called themselves that, they were known as Romans to the people of the time. When Islamic sources talk about Romans, the usually mean Byzantines, rather than the western Empire, which was defunct long before Islam.
__________________
   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#13 (permalink))
Quasi Muslim
 
wth1257's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 630
Reputation: 3930
Rep Power: 16
wth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enoughwth1257 will become famous soon enough
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Somewhere between Atheism and Islam
Gender:Brother In Humanity
Way of Life: Agnostic
Default Re: Surah 9:29 - 07-24-2008

Quote:
Originally Posted by Fishman View Post


Uh, the Prophet (peace be upon him) didn't fight Rome much, if at all...
then what is Surah 9:29 talking about?

Is it a universal imperative to fight non-Muslims untill they pay the tax?
   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#14 (permalink))
IB Senior Member
 
Shakoor15's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 693
Reputation: 3162
Rep Power: 19
Shakoor15 will become famous soon enoughShakoor15 will become famous soon enoughShakoor15 will become famous soon enoughShakoor15 will become famous soon enoughShakoor15 will become famous soon enoughShakoor15 will become famous soon enoughShakoor15 will become famous soon enoughShakoor15 will become famous soon enoughShakoor15 will become famous soon enoughShakoor15 will become famous soon enoughShakoor15 will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: America
Gender:Brother In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Re: Surah 9:29 - 07-24-2008

When Ameer ul Mu'mineen declares a Jihad, then it is permissible to fight. You should fight those who fight you. But if they seize then you should seize fighting as well. If they ask for terms we should accept.
"Fight in the way of Allah against those who fight against you, but begin not hostilities. Lo! Allah loveth not aggressors." (2:190)
__________________
   
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On




Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.3
Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SEO by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC2
vBulletin Skin developed by: vBStyles.com

Road to Jannah| Diaries of a Hafiz| Jannah Network| Muslim Forum| Islamic Resources and Articles| Nasheeds| Rhymes Of Praise| Jannah Bookstore| Halal Records| Jannah Network: Serving the On-Line Muslim Community|
Page generated in 0.23687 seconds with 9 queries