LI Islamic Forum  

Fiqh Islamic Jurisprudence

Reply

 

LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
Old
  (#1 (permalink))
Ramlah
Laa ilaaha ilallah
 
Ramlah's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 2,706
Reputation: 11431
Rep Power: 29
Ramlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Under the sun
Gender:Sister In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Question on Da3eef Hadiths - 10-18-2007


i am wondering about the topic of da3eef hadith, and want to know, what evicence there is for schalors not using it. I, myself always ask for authentic evidence, and logically, i wouldn't take evidence from a liar, but its just nice to base your actions upon something.
I heard, aswell, that the only time the ulema (scholars) use da3eef hadiths are under certain conditions. is this true, and if so, what are these conditions?
__________________
"واشمخي مؤمنة وثيقة بهدى الله ولا تستسلمي"
"Be a firm believer, and trust the guidance of Allah and do not give up."

"Far away is our aid, whilst our Aqeedah (creed) is lost, when it is The Weapon in war which makes us powerful."

   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#2 (permalink))
Ramlah
Laa ilaaha ilallah
 
Ramlah's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 2,706
Reputation: 11431
Rep Power: 29
Ramlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Under the sun
Gender:Sister In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Re: Question on Da3eef Hadiths - 11-07-2007


bump....
__________________
"واشمخي مؤمنة وثيقة بهدى الله ولا تستسلمي"
"Be a firm believer, and trust the guidance of Allah and do not give up."

"Far away is our aid, whilst our Aqeedah (creed) is lost, when it is The Weapon in war which makes us powerful."

   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#3 (permalink))
al-muslimah
Account Disabled
 
al-muslimah's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 337
Reputation: 364
Rep Power: 0
al-muslimah is just really niceal-muslimah is just really niceal-muslimah is just really niceal-muslimah is just really nice
Join Date: Jun 2007
Gender:Sister In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Re: Question on Da3eef Hadiths - 11-16-2007

Well the scholars have diffently agreed on the fact that one cannot use daeef ahadeeth as evidence and other ahadeeth like munkar, majhul, and mawdoo',etc.What exactly do you mean?
   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#4 (permalink))
Ramlah
Laa ilaaha ilallah
 
Ramlah's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 2,706
Reputation: 11431
Rep Power: 29
Ramlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Under the sun
Gender:Sister In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Re: Question on Da3eef Hadiths - 11-16-2007


im not sure. lol....i didnt even take the ones you mentioned into consideration.
__________________
"واشمخي مؤمنة وثيقة بهدى الله ولا تستسلمي"
"Be a firm believer, and trust the guidance of Allah and do not give up."

"Far away is our aid, whilst our Aqeedah (creed) is lost, when it is The Weapon in war which makes us powerful."

   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#5 (permalink))
Silver Pearl
Account Disabled
 
Silver Pearl's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 882
Reputation: 11219
Rep Power: 0
Silver Pearl has a reputation beyond reputeSilver Pearl has a reputation beyond reputeSilver Pearl has a reputation beyond reputeSilver Pearl has a reputation beyond reputeSilver Pearl has a reputation beyond reputeSilver Pearl has a reputation beyond reputeSilver Pearl has a reputation beyond reputeSilver Pearl has a reputation beyond reputeSilver Pearl has a reputation beyond reputeSilver Pearl has a reputation beyond reputeSilver Pearl has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Apr 2005
Gender:Sister In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Re: Question on Da3eef Hadiths - 11-16-2007



This might be of help:

Imaam Nawawi (rahimullaah) said in Kitaab-ul-Adhkaar:

"The ulama among the experts in hadeeth and the experts in law and others have said: it is permissible and (also) recommended that the religious practice concerning good deeds and good character, encouragement to good and discouragement from evil be based (even) on weak hadith as long as it is not forged (maudu).

As for ahkaam (legal rulings) such as what is permitted and what is forbidden, or the modalities of trade, marriage, divorce and other than that: one's practice is not based upon anything other than saheeh or hasan hadeeth, except as a precaution in some matter related to one of the above, for example, if a weak hadeeth was cited about the reprehensibility of certain kinds of sales or marriages. In such cases what is recommended is to avoid such sales and marriages, but it is not obligatory."

However, Sheikh-ul Islaam, Ibn Taymiya (rahimullaah) and Abu Al-Arabi Al-Maliki (rahimullaah) were of the opinion that you could not use weak narrations full stop. There are other scholars who adhered to this opinion. On the other hand there were other scholars who agreed with Imaam Nawawi (rahimullaah) such as Ibn Hajar Asqalani,Al-Khateeb Al-Baghdadi and generally the Hanafi school of thought.

Allaahu'3llaam.

Last edited by Silver Pearl; 11-16-2007 at 06:27 AM.
   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#6 (permalink))
Ramlah
Laa ilaaha ilallah
 
Ramlah's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 2,706
Reputation: 11431
Rep Power: 29
Ramlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Under the sun
Gender:Sister In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Re: Question on Da3eef Hadiths - 11-16-2007


interesting...jazakallahu khair
__________________
"واشمخي مؤمنة وثيقة بهدى الله ولا تستسلمي"
"Be a firm believer, and trust the guidance of Allah and do not give up."

"Far away is our aid, whilst our Aqeedah (creed) is lost, when it is The Weapon in war which makes us powerful."

   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#7 (permalink))
angelfuzion
Limited Member
 
angelfuzion's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 3
Reputation: 5
Rep Power: 0
angelfuzion is an unknown quantity at this point
Join Date: Jul 2007
Gender:Brother In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Re: Question on Da3eef Hadiths - 12-16-2007

do u guys know where can i ask about the authencity of narrations
   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#8 (permalink))
Abdul Baari
LI Lil' Mod
 
Abdul Baari's Avatar
 
Status: Online
Posts: 4,115
Reputation: 22192
Rep Power: 43
Abdul Baari has a reputation beyond reputeAbdul Baari has a reputation beyond reputeAbdul Baari has a reputation beyond reputeAbdul Baari has a reputation beyond reputeAbdul Baari has a reputation beyond reputeAbdul Baari has a reputation beyond reputeAbdul Baari has a reputation beyond reputeAbdul Baari has a reputation beyond reputeAbdul Baari has a reputation beyond reputeAbdul Baari has a reputation beyond reputeAbdul Baari has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Home Sweet Home
Gender:Brother In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Re: Question on Da3eef Hadiths - 12-16-2007



try asking here and Insha'Allah someone will help you, or point you in the write direction
__________________
“People are all the same in health and ease, but when hardship befalls them, true distinction is shown.”


Allahuma Baariklana fee Rajab wa Sha'aban, wa Balaghna Ramadhaan..Aameen!




   
Reply With Quote
Old
  (#9 (permalink))
Ramlah
Laa ilaaha ilallah
 
Ramlah's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 2,706
Reputation: 11431
Rep Power: 29
Ramlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond reputeRamlah has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Under the sun
Gender:Sister In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Re: Question on Da3eef Hadiths - 12-16-2007


for more info concerning my initial question, as well this one
Quote:
do u guys know where can i ask about the authencity of narrations
try these lectures, inshallah, by Yasir Qahdi. They're are called Usool al Hadith (the fundamentals of hadith). The latter question i think (if im understanding correctly) is mentioned in the later lectures. they're really good!
__________________
"واشمخي مؤمنة وثيقة بهدى الله ولا تستسلمي"
"Be a firm believer, and trust the guidance of Allah and do not give up."

"Far away is our aid, whilst our Aqeedah (creed) is lost, when it is The Weapon in war which makes us powerful."

   
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On




Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
LinkBacks Enabled by vBSEO 3.0.0
vBulletin Skin developed by: vBStyles.com

Page generated in 0.18344 seconds with 10 queries