Is this possible?

swanlake · **Is this possible? -** 04-20-2005

Salaam aleykum

Is it possible a Medinan surah to have Meccan verses in it? In anywhere in the quran? I heard from those devaint sects that there are 2 Meccan verses in Medinin surah (surah 9). I know they cant discard whole verses out of the quran just suit their mathematical calculations. But It got me wondered if there were other places in the Quran where meccan verses were included in medinin surah or vice versa.

**Al-Mu'minah** · **Re: Is this possible? -** 04-20-2005

No idea sis

Anyone?

**Khaldun** · **Re: Is this possible? -** 04-20-2005

are you trying to say that some verses where revealed twice dear sister? once in makkah and once in medinah?

swanlake · **Re: Is this possible? -** 04-20-2005

No. I am saying for instance surah nisa was revealed in mecca, but not the whole sura, Just 2 verses out of surah nisaa were revealed in medina. Is this possible? So it is not twice but once.

**aamirsaab** · **Re: Is this possible? -** 04-20-2005

you mean like half and half? i.e. half of the surah is in one lang. and the other half is another lang?

Far7an · **Re: Is this possible? -** 04-20-2005

I think what she means is, that is it possible for a makhan surah to have some verses which were revealed in medinah

swanlake · **Re: Is this possible? -** 04-20-2005

Ah..Thank you farhan..

time for me to go to English classes...

amani · **Re: Is this possible? -** 04-20-2005

yh it is possible

umm say sure Nahl
it is a late makkan surah except the ayah 110 which was revealed in madinah around the first 2 yrs AH and also possibly many other ayahs towards the end

is that what you mean like?

zAk · **Re: Is this possible? -** 04-20-2005

no farhan, but she meant otherwise

read tht first post again,

she asked Is it possible a Medinan surah to have Meccan verses in it ?
n not : is it possible for a makhan surah to have some verses which were revealed in medinah

wat u said is possible, but wat she asked is.........??? not sure !

Far7an · **Re: Is this possible? -** 04-20-2005

Quote:

Originally Posted by zAk

no farhan, but she meant otherwise

read tht first post again,

she asked Is it possible a Medinan surah to have Meccan verses in it ?
n not : is it possible for a makhan surah to have some verses which were revealed in medinah

wat u said is possible, but wat she asked is.........??? not sure !

Well true, but I think she was just trying to find out whether it is possible or not. A makhan surah with verses revealed in medinah or vice versa.

zAk · **Re: Is this possible? -** 04-20-2005

as i said first is surely possible, there may be many examples,
but for the second one.......... *doubts*, **unsure** :brother:

swanlake · **Re: Is this possible? -** 04-20-2005

Quote:

Originally Posted by amani

yh it is possible

umm say sure Nahl
it is a late makkan surah except the ayah 110 which was revealed in madinah around the first 2 yrs AH and also possibly many other ayahs towards the end

is that what you mean like?

amani

This is what i mean. But could you clarify again which verses were revealed in Madinah and which verses were revealed in Makkah? and could you think of other Makkah/Medina verses which are included in Medina/Makkah surahs??

swanlake · **Re: Is this possible? -** 04-20-2005

Quote:

Originally Posted by farhan247

Well true, but I think she was just trying to find out whether it is possible or not. A makhan surah with verses revealed in medinah or vice versa.

Farhan..spot on again brother. Also if it is possible, could one tell me where i can find those verses and in which surahs.

swanlake · **Re: Is this possible? -** 04-20-2005

Quote:

Originally Posted by zAk

as i said first is surely possible, there may be many examples,
but for the second one.......... *doubts*, **unsure** :brother:

Zak..could you pls tell me the ones you know? It doesnt matter whether they were Makkah/Medina verses in Medina/Makkah surahs.

zAk · **Re: Is this possible? -** 04-20-2005

currently i know none

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

	(#1 (permalink))
swanlake Allah's slave Status: Offline Posts: 389 Reputation: 470 Rep Power: 22 Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: London Gender: Way of Life: Muslim	Is this possible? - 04-20-2005 Salaam aleykum Is it possible a Medinan surah to have Meccan verses in it? In anywhere in the quran? I heard from those devaint sects that there are 2 Meccan verses in Medinin surah (surah 9). I know they cant discard whole verses out of the quran just suit their mathematical calculations. But It got me wondered if there were other places in the Quran where meccan verses were included in medinin surah or vice versa.

	(#2 (permalink))
Al-Mu'minah Super Moderator Status: Offline Posts: 5,175 Reputation: 22050 Rep Power: 54 Join Date: Jan 2005 Gender: Way of Life: Muslim	Re: Is this possible? - 04-20-2005 No idea sis Anyone? __________________

	(#3 (permalink))
Khaldun Alif Lam Mim. Status: Offline Posts: 1,628 Reputation: 6241 Rep Power: 30 Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Student at the Madeenah University Gender: Way of Life: Muslim	Re: Is this possible? - 04-20-2005 are you trying to say that some verses where revealed twice dear sister? once in makkah and once in medinah?

	(#4 (permalink))
swanlake Allah's slave Status: Offline Posts: 389 Reputation: 470 Rep Power: 22 Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: London Gender: Way of Life: Muslim	Re: Is this possible? - 04-20-2005 No. I am saying for instance surah nisa was revealed in mecca, but not the whole sura, Just 2 verses out of surah nisaa were revealed in medina. Is this possible? So it is not twice but once.

	(#6 (permalink))
Far7an . Status: Offline Posts: 4,340 Reputation: 15085 Rep Power: 44 Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: UK Gender: Way of Life: Muslim	Re: Is this possible? - 04-20-2005 I think what she means is, that is it possible for a makhan surah to have some verses which were revealed in medinah

	(#7 (permalink))
swanlake Allah's slave Status: Offline Posts: 389 Reputation: 470 Rep Power: 22 Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: London Gender: Way of Life: Muslim	Re: Is this possible? - 04-20-2005 Ah..Thank you farhan.. time for me to go to English classes...

	(#8 (permalink))
amani . Status: Offline Posts: 6,700 Reputation: 21915 Rep Power: 54 Join Date: Mar 2005 Gender: Way of Life: Muslim	Re: Is this possible? - 04-20-2005 yh it is possible umm say sure Nahl it is a late makkan surah except the ayah 110 which was revealed in madinah around the first 2 yrs AH and also possibly many other ayahs towards the end is that what you mean like?

	(#9 (permalink))
zAk LI's Weirdest Status: Offline Posts: 20,075 Reputation: 38278 Rep Power: 89 Join Date: Jan 2005 Gender: Way of Life: Muslim	Re: Is this possible? - 04-20-2005 no farhan, but she meant otherwise read tht first post again, she asked Is it possible a Medinan surah to have Meccan verses in it ? n not : is it possible for a makhan surah to have some verses which were revealed in medinah wat u said is possible, but wat she asked is.........??? not sure ! __________________ My advice to you is get married: if you find a good wife you'll be happy; if not, you'll become a philosopher. -Socrates

	(#11 (permalink))
zAk LI's Weirdest Status: Offline Posts: 20,075 Reputation: 38278 Rep Power: 89 Join Date: Jan 2005 Gender: Way of Life: Muslim	Re: Is this possible? - 04-20-2005 as i said first is surely possible, there may be many examples, *but for the second one.......... doubts, unsure* :brother:** __________________ My advice to you is get married: if you find a good wife you'll be happy; if not, you'll become a philosopher. -Socrates

	(#15 (permalink))
zAk LI's Weirdest Status: Offline Posts: 20,075 Reputation: 38278 Rep Power: 89 Join Date: Jan 2005 Gender: Way of Life: Muslim	Re: Is this possible? - 04-20-2005 currently i know none __________________ My advice to you is get married: if you find a good wife you'll be happy; if not, you'll become a philosopher. -Socrates