Originally Posted by Iqram

Is it really a neccessity to follow taqleed?

I see the 4 madhabs as guides, if we are not within the rulings of any 4 imams, then we are surely in the wrong.

But If we do an action which atleast 1 or 2 imams agree [with sound evidence from Quraan+/-Sunnah]...Then how can it be wrong?

for example:

placement of hands in salaah....One may have it upon his chest, and another below the naval. Depending on which imam had the most authentic/reliable sources, you would follow the one which is right/more authentic regardless of which out of the 4[Madhabs] you follow....

I mean, if it was done by RasoolAllah [SAW], and it was acknowledged that it was done, then how can we put off an act of the prophet [saw]?

Also, I don't think the sahaabah [raa] picked and chose which action to follow...did they?

Well, that's the way I see it, and I am willing to give up this opinion if anyone can prove me wrong and guide me to the straight path inshallah

Jazakallah khair

brothers and sisters.
brother, it is allah who guides, firstly and formostly. i dont intend to attack you.

Originally Posted by kadafi

the madhhab of the layman is the madhhab of his mufti.

The Layman Has No Madhab

As for one who is not like that, then he cannot take the rulings directly from the evidences. And this is the predominant case amongst the people, especially in these latter times. So [in such a case] there is no harm in adopting one of the four madhhabs and making taqleed of one of them.

brother.

I no need to argue further on the issue of taqleed with you.
You have presented your article, I have presented mine.
Truth is Clear and Simple, false is complicated and is rather self-contradictory.
May Allah save us all from najdi fitnah and dajjali fitnah.

Originally Posted by kadafi

Why do you feel the need to post such misleading texts that goes against the view of the majority of the aa'immah.

No, I’m not. I am aware of those group of ppl. Who call the muqallid of “Imaam-e-Mujhtahideen” in Ijtihadi matter (differenes of opinions) to be “blind follower”, “biddati”, “mushrik” etc. I'm just trying at my level to remove this misguidance and ignorance in them, insha'Allah.

may Allah guide us all along to the right path.

Originally Posted by Iqram

lol I'm not 'deviating' from the deen if that's what you think LOL It's just a thought that came to mind.

Well it looks like it was a wrong concept....

Jazakallah for clearing up ;)

barikallaho fee.
i just wanted to inform u whats wrong in going into matter beyond priority. first thing first, a man who didnt give zakaah and busy in giving sadaqah is in deep error. his sadaqah is of no rewards. he should do fardh first, nafil come afterward. one pray all night nafil and sleep at fajir time or make fajir poorly is not an intelligent act.
I hope u understand what i'm trying to say. I, myself learning.

and yes there is leeway, but ask this to some authentic aalim. what can not come under talfeeq.
but we should learn deen first, all the thing which is compulsory is compulsory to learn first, and then if Allah will, move on to secondary things.

may Allah guide us along to the right path.