I did say at the beginning of that article that you should click on the above link before reading the article. Anyway, this is what the brother mentioned in the article:

One may also ask, what is the wisdom behind abrogating the recitation of a verse but upholding its injunction? (e.g. verse on stoning)

This is because the Sunnah is just like the Quran, both are revelations. The Sunnah is also the actual law, and this being a test to those who claim to believe in Allah: they must believe in the Sunnah too and that it takes place of the Quran in many areas. See this article for proof of following Sunnah.

http://www.load-islam.com/artical_de...tion=myarticle

This then proves the importance of the Sunnah, and how important it is in our religion. We can ask countlessly why the recitation was removed, and why the ruling remained - however, this is through the wisdom of Allah.

But why?

The punishment for adultery in your religion is death. There was once a verse about it in the qu'ran too. But for some reason, it was taken out.. Like the author did not want it in there. According to you, there were others also.

So why? I mean why not just leave it in there?

Sorry sis, where do you read this?
Thanks

Could you please read the posts 27 & 28? You will get answer to all your questions, if not ask me and I'll answer you. But only after you read my posts 27 & 28.
Thanks

but everything about alcohol can still be found in the Quraan. not the same about stoning! do you think Allah is so powerless that when he says he will protect Quraan from alteration then does not?

or when he says when he abrogates something or causes it it be forgotten, replaces it with something better (when He makes you forget you don't remember, if you do then it is very odd indeed!)


Islam is continuation of religion of hazrat Aadam Alahisalam., if this site was not populated by ignorants and run largely by illiterates, I would tell you more but since it is, they'll just delete any Muslim post that looks better than theirs

Insha Allah you can refer to these posts for more info on abrogation:


http://www.islamicboard.com/quran/49...brogation.html ([Uloom Al-Qur'an] Naskh (Abrogation))

http://www.islamicboard.com/quran/13...brogation.html (Qur'an and Abrogation)

http://www.islamicboard.com/quran/53...brogation.html (Concerning Abrogation)