Raising the hands in Du'aa after the 5 daily Prayers - Page 2

Fighting4Iman · **Re: Raising the hands in Du'aa after the 5 daily Prayers -** 08-23-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by Umma Wasat

Dnt put ur hands up einstein,

but all the rap artists always tell us to put our hands up

neway seriously, i'll research into this properly. but i really doubt this is bid'a... seriously..

amani · **Re: Raising the hands in Du'aa after the 5 daily Prayers -** 08-23-2007

in addition to this one of the best times for dua is when one is prostrating as narrated in sahih muslim and before salam

Pk_#2 · **Re: Raising the hands in Du'aa after the 5 daily Prayers -** 08-23-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by IbnAbdulHakim

but all the rap artists always tell us to put our hands up

neway seriously, i'll research into this properly. but i really doubt this is bid'a... seriously..

Y'all put cho hands up, c'mon ma wiggah put cho hands up

okay yeah i agree bhai,

before salaams @ Amani

Faizah · **Re: Raising the hands in Du'aa after the 5 daily Prayers -** 08-23-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by IbnAbdulHakim

but i really doubt this is bid'a... seriously..

From the fatwa committee:

Quote:

It is not established from the Prophet (sal Allaahu alaiyhi wa sallam) as far as we know that he raised his hands in duaa after the salaam in the obligatory prayers.

So does this mean you have something from the Prophet salAllaahu 'alayhi wa sallam to support this act then? Otherwise akhee, you are simply following your 'aql/hawwaa. And Islam is not based upon that.

Pk_#2 · **Re: Raising the hands in Du'aa after the 5 daily Prayers -** 08-23-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by Al Muwahhidah

Otherwise akhee, you are simply following your 'aql/hawwaa. And Islam is not based upon that.

Ahhhhhhh.

Faizah · **Re: Raising the hands in Du'aa after the 5 daily Prayers -** 08-23-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by Umma Wasat

Ahhhhhhh.

What? Sorry was I being harsh?

amani · **Re: Raising the hands in Du'aa after the 5 daily Prayers -** 08-23-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by Umma Wasat

Ahhhhhhh.

whats wrong sister/

Fighting4Iman · **Re: Raising the hands in Du'aa after the 5 daily Prayers -** 08-23-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by Al Muwahhidah

From the fatwa committee:

So does this mean you have something from the Prophet salAllaahu 'alayhi wa sallam to support this act then? Otherwise akhee, you are simply following your 'aql/hawwaa. And Islam is not based upon that.

lol im not gonna lie, but my parents have ulama who ive learned to trust and throughout our whole life they've taught us its sunnah to make dua' after every salaah but never have they said after fard because when we pray we make dua' after all the rakaah's (including sunnah rakaah's).

so to be honest i never had a habit of making dua' after fard anyway, i normally read ayatul kursi and then get up... but i said let me research into it because i wanted to ask those teachers for their opinion (which for all i know could agree with this) and if in opposition to provide their view with proof

**Alpha Dude™** · **Re: Raising the hands in Du'aa after the 5 daily Prayers -** 08-23-2007

Muhammad Al Shareef makes a good point on this subject, here.

Quote:

Bismillah.
What we studied in Madinah was that the Prophet, sal Allahu alayhi wa sallam, did not command it, nor did he forbid it. This latter point is something people forget, HE DID NOT FORBID IT as much as he did not command it, sal Allahu alayhi wa sallam.

So, in conclusion, if it is institutionalized to the point where people think it is a MUST and that it is part of the Salah to make dua immediately after ... that's when it becomes bid'ah.

But if you are just sitting in the Masjid, you pray and then you wish to make dua ... it's alright in sha Allah.

And Allah knows best

PS: One should not make the mistake of thinking 'DUA' is bid'ah. I know a lot of people when they hear this fiqh issue, they abandon Dua altogether. Instead, one need only check themselves to make sure they are not institutionalizing dua at a specific non-Sunnah time, but keep on with their strong and consistent dua to Allah. Allah ta'ala loves to hear his servants when they raise their hands to him and ask of the goodness of this life and the next.

Faizah · **Re: Raising the hands in Du'aa after the 5 daily Prayers -** 08-23-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by IbnAbdulHakim

lol im not gonna lie, but my parents have ulama who ive learned to trust and throughout our whole life they've taught us its sunnah to make dua' after every salaah but never have they said after fard because when we pray we make dua' after all the rakaah's (including sunnah rakaah's).

so to be honest i never had a habit of making dua' after fard anyway, i normally read ayatul kursi and then get up... but i said let me research into it because i wanted to ask those teachers for their opinion (which for all i know could agree with this) and if in opposition to provide their view with proof

Ok inshaAllah. If they provide you with something from the authentic Sunnah, then khayr. I was commenting on the 'I seriously doubt it's a bid'ah'. That seemed like to me, that you had some proof to suggest it was something established in the deen. But keep on researching inshaAllah.

Pk_#2 · **Re: Raising the hands in Du'aa after the 5 daily Prayers -** 08-23-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by Al Muwahhidah

What? Sorry was I being harsh?

no not you

I just getting confused i just do dua all the time after my prayers

I never heard of this before

Faizah · **Re: Raising the hands in Du'aa after the 5 daily Prayers -** 08-23-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alpha Dude

Muhammad Al Shareef makes a good point on this subject, here.

But how can we do any act of worship that the Prophet did not do, or agreed to? Did he provide a hadeeth where a companion did it infront of the Prophet and the Prophet did not object? If not, I would abstain from it, since Muhammad Al Shareef is a student of Knowledge, whilst this fatwa is from a committee of major Scholars.

Fighting4Iman · **Re: Raising the hands in Du'aa after the 5 daily Prayers -** 08-23-2007

jazakALlah khair bro alpha dude, my own bro says the same,

he says dont do somethin so excessively that it seems obligatory, but do it moderately and its all good and in this case it WONT be bid'a coz its got place in "SHARIAH LAW" and its somethin ur doing to please Allah!

sis muwahhidah may Allah reward you

sis UMMA WASAT< dont get all confused, KNOWLEDGE IS THE CURE TO DOUBT

Faizah · **Re: Raising the hands in Du'aa after the 5 daily Prayers -** 08-23-2007

Quote:

KNOWLEDGE IS THE CURE TO DOUBT

Very true.

**Alpha Dude™** · **Re: Raising the hands in Du'aa after the 5 daily Prayers -** 08-23-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by Al Muwahhidah

But how can we do any act of worship that the Prophet did not do, or agreed to? Did he provide a hadeeth where a companion did it infront of the Prophet and the Prophet did not object? If not, I would abstain from it, since Muhammad Al Shareef is a student of Knowledge, whilst this fatwa is from a committee of major Scholars.

I agree with IAH's post on this matter.

Quote:

he says dont do somethin so excessively that it seems obligatory, but do it moderately and its all good and in this case it WONT be bid'a coz its got place in "SHARIAH LAW" and its somethin ur doing to please Allah!

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

	(#17 (permalink))
amani :) for my piXie Status: Offline Posts: 7,253 Reputation: 27030 Rep Power: 63 Join Date: Mar 2005 Gender: Way of Life: Muslim	Re: Raising the hands in Du'aa after the 5 daily Prayers - 08-23-2007 in addition to this one of the best times for dua is when one is prostrating as narrated in sahih muslim and before salam

	(#28 (permalink))
Fighting4Iman Fighting4Emaan Status: Online Posts: 16,092 Reputation: 48905 Rep Power: 94 Join Date: Feb 2006 Location: Fighting4Emaan Gender: Way of Life: Muslim	Re: Raising the hands in Du'aa after the 5 daily Prayers - 08-23-2007 jazakALlah khair bro alpha dude, my own bro says the same, he says dont do somethin so excessively that it seems obligatory, but do it moderately and its all good and in this case it WONT be bid'a coz its got place in "SHARIAH LAW" and its somethin ur doing to please Allah! sis muwahhidah may Allah reward you sis UMMA WASAT< dont get all confused, KNOWLEDGE IS THE CURE TO DOUBT __________________ -Fighting for my Emaan- I Will Not Lose - Never - No Way - Not Ever