LI Islamic Forum  
 
Powered by: MuslimPages
Add your business
 


Notices

Closed Thread
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
Old
  (#1 (permalink))
north_malaysian
LI Addict
 
north_malaysian's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 7,081
Reputation: 14402
Rep Power: 43
north_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Penang Island, Malaysia
Gender:Brother In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Can a Sunni pray in Shia congregation? - 09-12-2007

Can a Sunni pray in a Shia congregation/mosque being lead by a Shia Imam?
__________________


عيد سعيد!!! كل عام و انتم بالخير

سلامت هاري راي عيدالاضحى

   
Old
  (#2 (permalink))
north_malaysian
LI Addict
 
north_malaysian's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 7,081
Reputation: 14402
Rep Power: 43
north_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Penang Island, Malaysia
Gender:Brother In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Re: Can a Sunni pray in Shia congregation? - 09-14-2007

Let say that it's prayer time... and suddenly a Sunni see everybody went to a mosque... he joined the crowd and pray in the congregation... when he went off the mosque .. suddenly someone tell him that it's a Shia mosque.

Does that prayer valid?
__________________


عيد سعيد!!! كل عام و انتم بالخير

سلامت هاري راي عيدالاضحى

   
Old
  (#3 (permalink))
Skye Ephémérine
Yes I am Grouchy!
 
Skye Ephémérine's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 7,996
Reputation: 54283
Rep Power: 89
Skye Ephémérine has a reputation beyond reputeSkye Ephémérine has a reputation beyond reputeSkye Ephémérine has a reputation beyond reputeSkye Ephémérine has a reputation beyond reputeSkye Ephémérine has a reputation beyond reputeSkye Ephémérine has a reputation beyond reputeSkye Ephémérine has a reputation beyond reputeSkye Ephémérine has a reputation beyond reputeSkye Ephémérine has a reputation beyond reputeSkye Ephémérine has a reputation beyond reputeSkye Ephémérine has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: In the Rictus of Revenge
Gender:Sister In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Re: Can a Sunni pray in Shia congregation? - 09-14-2007

I believe they only pray 3 times rather than the 5 required otherwise the prayer is similar.. but I don't know..
__________________
For the skeptic, no amount of proof will be enough, and for the believer, no amount of proof is necessary.
Tous articles prohibés sont sujets à saisie
   
Old
  (#4 (permalink))
north_malaysian
LI Addict
 
north_malaysian's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 7,081
Reputation: 14402
Rep Power: 43
north_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond reputenorth_malaysian has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Penang Island, Malaysia
Gender:Brother In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Re: Can a Sunni pray in Shia congregation? - 09-14-2007

Quote:
Originally Posted by PurestAmbrosia View Post
I believe they only pray 3 times rather than the 5 required otherwise the prayer is similar.. but I don't know..
3 prayers?

I never seen how Shiites pray...

But can we go to their mosque and do individual prayer?
__________________


عيد سعيد!!! كل عام و انتم بالخير

سلامت هاري راي عيدالاضحى

   
Old
  (#5 (permalink))
Skye Ephémérine
Yes I am Grouchy!
 
Skye Ephémérine's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 7,996
Reputation: 54283
Rep Power: 89
Skye Ephémérine has a reputation beyond reputeSkye Ephémérine has a reputation beyond reputeSkye Ephémérine has a reputation beyond reputeSkye Ephémérine has a reputation beyond reputeSkye Ephémérine has a reputation beyond reputeSkye Ephémérine has a reputation beyond reputeSkye Ephémérine has a reputation beyond reputeSkye Ephémérine has a reputation beyond reputeSkye Ephémérine has a reputation beyond reputeSkye Ephémérine has a reputation beyond reputeSkye Ephémérine has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: In the Rictus of Revenge
Gender:Sister In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Re: Can a Sunni pray in Shia congregation? - 09-14-2007

Quote:
Originally Posted by north_malaysian View Post
3 prayers?

I never seen how Shiites pray...

But can we go to their mosque and do individual prayer?
akhi.. I really don't know ( I am sorry).. I had a friend in under-grad who was/is lebanese, for the longest time I didn't know she was a shiite...I notice only by the prayers missed one day.. the other thing that was stricking is the males always take their belt off when praying.. when I asked her about this, she stated they are not allowed to wear anything made from animals.. of course i was hot and fervent then to change people... I spoke to her about what she was doing, she said I was in no position to tell her anything when there are so many Muslims who don't pray all together... sadest part is she was from a sunni family.. and I know exactly the member that got her to be a shiite... either way it is her business.. just wish I knew then what I know now..

__________________
For the skeptic, no amount of proof will be enough, and for the believer, no amount of proof is necessary.
Tous articles prohibés sont sujets à saisie
   
Old
  (#6 (permalink))
Al-Mu'minah
LI Kindest
 
Al-Mu'minah's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 5,165
Reputation: 22526
Rep Power: 57
Al-Mu'minah has a reputation beyond reputeAl-Mu'minah has a reputation beyond reputeAl-Mu'minah has a reputation beyond reputeAl-Mu'minah has a reputation beyond reputeAl-Mu'minah has a reputation beyond reputeAl-Mu'minah has a reputation beyond reputeAl-Mu'minah has a reputation beyond reputeAl-Mu'minah has a reputation beyond reputeAl-Mu'minah has a reputation beyond reputeAl-Mu'minah has a reputation beyond reputeAl-Mu'minah has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Jan 2005
Gender:Sister In Islam
Way of Life: Muslim
Default Re: Can a Sunni pray in Shia congregation? - 09-14-2007

Assalaamu Alaikum Wa Rahmatulaahi Wa Barakatuh

Quote:
Question:
Can we pray behind a Shia?

Answer:

Praise be to Allaah.

We need to describe the beliefs (‘aqeedah) of the Shi’a so as to know the ruling on praying behind them.

For details on their beliefs, please see the answer to Question no. 4569.

With regard to preying behind one who is of this nature, Shaykh Ibn Baaz (may Allaah have mercy on him) said:

“It is not permissible to pray behind any of the mushrikeen, including those who seek the help of anyone other than Allaah and seek support from him, because seeking help through anyone other then Allaah, such as the dead, idols, the jinn, etc. is shirk, the association of others with Allaah, glorified be He.”

Fataawa al-Shaykh Ibn Baaz (vol. 2, p. 396)

And he said: one should not pray behind any imaam who is known to exaggerate concerning the Ahl al-Bayt (members of the Prophet’s household). If no such thing is known about him or any other Muslim, then it is OK to pray behind them.

Fataawa al-Shaykh Ibn Baaz, vol. 12, p. 107

Islam Q&A
Sheikh Muhammed Salih Al-Munajjid
Upon that thread closed.
__________________

Last edited by Al-Mu'minah; 09-14-2007 at 04:44 AM..
   
Closed Thread

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On




Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
LinkBacks Enabled by vBSEO 3.0.0
vBulletin Skin developed by: vBStyles.com

Page generated in 0.18030 seconds with 10 queries