![]() | | ||||||||||
| |||||||||||
| Notices |
| | LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
| Sponsored Links |
| |
| 5 Years at LI Status: Offline Posts: 23,482 Reputation: 126933 Rep Power: 212 Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: Cyberabad Gender: Way of Life: Muslim | of course...
__________________par kahan ? Quote:
![]() | |
| | |
| → J e w e l ← Status: Offline Posts: 6,267 Reputation: 6787 Rep Power: 33 Join Date: Jan 2007 Location: LI Way of Life: Undisclosed | Plagiarism
__________________During 1960-1963, while Ibn-e-Safi was suffering from schizophrenia, many amateur writers started posing themselves as Ibn-e-Safi and produced third class copies of his work, distorting the character of not only Ali Imran, but also of Colonel Faridi and Captain Hameed (of the Jasoosi Dunya). These acts of vandalism were reported by Ibn-e-Safi himself in the paish-rus (preface) of Dairh Matwaalay (which was the novel he returned with after his recovery). Some writers and publishers still continued to write on Safi's characters, much to the annoyance of many fans. Safi used to mention fans' complaints sometimes in the prefaces, and mocked the fake publishers and writers in his own witty style. Additions by other writers Some writers who acquired fame by writing their own versions of Imran Series (specially after the death of Ibn-e-Safi) include Mazhar Kaleem, Safdar Shaheen, Ibn-e-Rahat and Mushtaq Ahmed Qureshi (among others). Mazhar Kaleem is still writing novels and enjoys enough fan-following, and has introduced many new characters in the series. Fans of Ibn-e-Safi, however, dismiss Kaleem's books, arguing that Kaleem distorted the original 'feel' of the series, and that he deformed the key characteristics of many characters, including Ali Imran. Nevertheless, his novels have a significant readership. Difference between Ibn-e-Safi's and Mazhar Kaleem's books Some of the differences between Ibn-e-Safi's and Mazhar Kaleem's books are as follows:
![]() |
| | |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | |
| |