questions on Ali's desendance

[noorahmad]

ive got a question, where i'm asked to name the two righteous caliph to whom Ali married two of his daughters, one i know is Umar was married to Umm Kulthum, what about the other one???

Anybody knows about the year of the death of Umar and Abu Bakr, the two sons of Ali?

[ardianto]

I dont know who was the other one. And, which daughter ?.
Ali ibn Abu Thalib (r.a) had 18 daughters including umm khultum, and had 18 sons.

Year of the death.
Umar ibn Khattab (r.a): Dzulhijjah, (date ?). Year : 23 Hijiriah (or 644).
Abu bakr (r.a) : year : 643.

Two sons of Ali ? Hasan and Husain ?
Hasan bin Ali : 669
Husain bin Ali : 680

[noorahmad]

jazakAllah khair brother,
but i was asking about two sons of Ali named Umar and Abu Bakr

[ardianto]

jazakAllah khair brother,
but i was asking about two sons of Ali named Umar and Abu Bakr

Umar who ? Sayeedna Ali ibn Abu Thalib (ra) had two sons named Umar. But I think they were not Umar in your question. Those Umar were not sons of Fatimah az Zahra (ra).
Abu Bakr who ? There's no Ali's son named Abu Bakr.

Do you mean Umar bin Khattab and Abu Bakr as Shidiq ? they were caliphs.
This is a list of Khulafaur Rashideen (Four Righteous Caliphs)
1. Abu Bakr as Shidiq (ra).
2. Umar in Khattab (ra).
3. Ustman ibn Affan (ra).
4. Ali ibn Abu Thalib (ra).

And I am sure, two sons of Ali that you heard is Hasan and Husain.

Brother, I think you heard an inaccurate or wrong story. If you want to know further about Ali's desendance (from his marriage with Fatimah az Zahra (ra)) you must seek a reference about Ahlul Bayt. But I suggest you, for a better and rightest reference you must ask the scholar. :)

Hey there! Looks like you're enjoying the discussion, but you're not signed up for an account.

When you create an account, you can participate in the discussions and share your thoughts. You also get notifications, here and via email, whenever new posts are made. And you can like posts and make new friends.
Sign Up

[noorahmad]

nah, Ali married 8 other women after the death of fatima, but we people know only about hasan and husein.
and yes, there was a son of ali named abu bakr, and another one named umar.
i think we are some kind of shi'a biased on concerning the ahul bayt.
go and do some research about it brother, it so interesting.

[noorahmad]

go to alburhan, fnoor, ansaar.org

[ardianto]

That interesting.
OK, I will do some research.
Jazak Allah khair.

[Al-Hanbali]

....also www.AhlelBayt.com <--- excellent site!!