format_quote Originally Posted by
noorahmad
jazakAllah khair brother,
but i was asking about two sons of Ali named Umar and Abu Bakr
Umar who ? Sayeedna Ali ibn Abu Thalib (ra) had two sons named Umar. But I think they were not Umar in your question. Those Umar were not sons of Fatimah az Zahra (ra).
Abu Bakr who ? There's no Ali's son named Abu Bakr.
Do you mean Umar bin Khattab and Abu Bakr as Shidiq ? they were caliphs.
This is a list of Khulafaur Rashideen (Four Righteous Caliphs)
1. Abu Bakr as Shidiq (ra).
2. Umar in Khattab (ra).
3. Ustman ibn Affan (ra).
4. Ali ibn Abu Thalib (ra).
And I am sure, two sons of Ali that you heard is Hasan and Husain.
Brother, I think you heard an inaccurate or wrong story. If you want to know further about Ali's desendance (from his marriage with Fatimah az Zahra (ra)) you must seek a reference about Ahlul Bayt. But I suggest you, for a better and rightest reference you must ask the scholar. :)