I had qada asr to read and reached the mosque at maghrib time where maghrib salat was already going on. I joined the jamaat and prayed Maghrib and then prayed my qada Asr.
Is this ok? As i know normally the Qada takes priority.
Also if it is the case i should pray the maghrib anyway, is it okm for me go read the 2 sunnah of maghrib and then finally pray the outstanding qaza?
You cannot pray maghrib before asr because prayers are prayed in sequence. If you arrive at the mosque when the time of asr has finished and the imam has already began the maghrib prayer, you must join the imam with the intention of praying asr. And when the imam concludes the prayer, you stand up and pray the final rak'ah for asr and then pray maghrib.
The intention of the prayer that the imam prays does not affect your intention.
format_quote Originally Posted by abbas_ali
Salaam all,
I had qada asr to read and reached the mosque at maghrib time where maghrib salat was already going on. I joined the jamaat and prayed Maghrib and then prayed my qada Asr.
Is this ok? As i know normally the Qada takes priority.
Also if it is the case i should pray the maghrib anyway, is it okm for me go read the 2 sunnah of maghrib and then finally pray the outstanding qaza?
You cannot pray maghrib before asr because prayers are prayed in sequence. If you arrive at the mosque when the time of asr has finished and the imam has already began the maghrib prayer, you must join the imam with the intention of praying asr. And when the imam concludes the prayer, you stand up and pray the final rak'ah for asr and then pray maghrib.
The intention of the prayer that the imam prays does not affect your intention.
format_quote Originally Posted by 'Abd-al Latif
:wasalamext
You cannot pray maghrib before asr because prayers are prayed in sequence. If you arrive at the mosque when the time of asr has finished and the imam has already began the maghrib prayer, you must join the imam with the intention of praying asr. And when the imam concludes the prayer, you stand up and pray the final rak'ah for asr and then pray maghrib.
The intention of the prayer that the imam prays does not affect your intention.
Thanks but what about this information:
Missed ‘asr and reaches masjid when maghrib prayer has started
If a person has missed ‘asr prayer and arrives at the masjid to find that maghrib prayer has started, what should he do?
Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyah (may Allaah have mercy on him) said: He should pray maghrib with the imaam, then pray ‘asr, as is agreed upon by all leading scholars. As to whether he should repeat maghrib, there are two opinions. The first is that he should repeat it; this is the view of Ibn ‘Umar, Maalik and Abu Haneefah, and the most well known view of Ahmad. The second opinion is that he does not have to repeat it; this is the view of Ibn ‘Abbaas and al-Shaafi’i, and the second view of Ahmad. The second view is more correct, because Allaah did not make it obligatory for a person to pray a salaah twice if he has feared Allaah as much as he can. And Allaah knows best. (Majmoo’ Fataawa Ibn Taymiyah, 22/106).
Hey there! Looks like you're enjoying the discussion, but you're not signed up for an account.
When you create an account, you can participate in the discussions and share your thoughts. You also get notifications, here and via email, whenever new posts are made. And you can like posts and make new friends.
Sign Up