format_quote Originally Posted by
Ramadhan
:sl:
Walekum Assalam and thanks for your reply.
It's as fabrication as holy trinity.
Yup,i know its a fabrication but i dont know the details.
And please be aware that wikipedia and similar pages are not very fond of Islam, and there's so much lies, fabrications and deceits about Islam in that site.
Wikipedia pointed that out them selves and asked the people not to believe it just because it was posted on wiki.Here..
The neutrality of this article is disputed. Please see the discussion on the talk page.
wikipedia.
Even the page in wiki from where you cited this does not provide any hadith source. Anything pertaining to deen must have the basis in the Qur'an and Sunnah, and there's no hadith that says Ali was born inside the wall of Ka'bah.
That is indeed a very good point.I did'nt think about this before.I'll keep this in my mind strictly next time and ask for hadith sources while talking about such incidents :)
I think we shouldn't put anything here that we know it's not the truth.
So where we should go to ask about things like that ^o)
Indeed that looks fabricated to me but to tell this to anyone who ask me about that matter,i need to know the whole case correctly and i thought i can get correct information from here Inshallah that will help me make my brother understand.
I read another topic in the forum which was about sects and someone locked the thread.Atleast bring the correct information to people and then lock it,dont leave such questions unanswered as we all are learners here and we dont know plenty of things like above.
Salam.