Originally Posted by FreedomStands
I understand what you mean.
Allah is the Lord, Creator of everything, evil, lust etc. BUT to attribute EVIL to Allah should be avoided.
Yes, Allah willed ibless etc. To disobey etc. BUT Allah never forced Iblees etc. It is still the fault of Ibless. The difference between Ibless and Adam AS is that Adam did NOT blame Allah, while yes, Allah willed Adam to disobey Him, but that is not to be attributed to Allah. Adam AS acknowledged that he, himself, was the wrong..
Whatever happens to us, of bad and good, is from Allah. But whatever happens of Bad is from Allah, but it is because of what our hands have put forth. Allah is NEVER a tyrant to His slaves.
BUT it is of proper verbal etiquette to NOT attribute filth, evil, etc. to Allah. Everyone OBEYS Allah's Universal will, as for His legslative will, the muslims do.
For example if I get waswass, that is from Shaytaan, not Allah. But indirectly, it IS from Allah, cause EVERYTHING is from Allah. But we attribute the waswass to shaytaan, and not Allah.
May Allah forgive me if I said anything wrong, but can I do something Allah did not command? yes, can I do something Allah did not cause? No. Can I do something Allah did not will? no. Whatever I do, I can NEVER outwill Allah.
If I kill a man, I did it, not Allah, but Allah willed it, so did Allah cause it? yes, Do it? No. For to say Allah did it, is to attribute an action YOU did to Allah SWT. pls correct me if I am wrong.
May Allah forgive me if I said anything wrong. Ameen.