format_quote Originally Posted by
Slaveofthelord
if you follow hanafi then you cant switch to a shafi when it suits you..
In principle, this is true. One cannot pick and choose whichever is more suitable for himself based on convenience. Each school of thought is based on a set methodology to derive the rulings from the Qur'an and Sunnah. Once we follow a method, we have to be consistent.
In case of Asr, the Hanafi school itself has two different rulings; one that of Imam Abu Hanifah :rh: and the other that of his two main students, Imam Abu Yusuf :rh: and Imam Muhammad :rh:.
Mufti Ismail Moosa says:
You have two options in this case:
1) You either follow the view of Imam Abu Hanifa (may Allah be pleased with him) and strictly adhere to that ruling. In this case, you perform your own prayer in Asr time. Praying Asr in Shafi time will not be valid,
2) You follow the view of the two students of Imam Abu Hanifa, Imam Abu Yusuf and Imam Muhammad (may Allah be pleased with them all). In this case, the time of Asr for you will always be according to Shafi time. If ever you delay Dhuhr until that time, the Dhuhr prayer will be Qadha.
Both the above views are valid in the Hanafi Madhab, but you can only choose and practice on one.
If you follow the first view, you can join the Asr jamaat with the intention of Nafl prayers. Thus, you will pray Asr once the time of Asr sets in. Likewise, you cannot be the Imam and you cannot pray alone in this time.
If you follow the second view, you may join the Asr prayer and would not have to repeat the prayer later, you can lead the prayer, and you may also pray Asr individually in Shafi time.
Source:
http://islamqa.org/hanafi/fatwaa-dot-com/79986