format_quote Originally Posted by
Misbah-Abd
The religion is advice and I am giving him advice that he shouldn't concern himself with questions that won't give the answers he is looking for. One of the problems with asking too many questions is that it can lead to weak iman or even abandoning the religion altogether when all one had to do is keep focused on what he is suppose to do and not indulge his shaytan. The religion has been perfected and the scholars for 1400 years have gave us the answers to questions that were relevant to help the Muslim get to where he wants to go. The 21st century Muslim just has to learn it and obey. And Allah Knows Best.
No, you should ask questions about stuff. Islam encourages people to go out...ask questions and seek knowledge....If you do not ask questions...you will believe every bearded man in your path and follow him leading to shirk!! Islam is knowledge...Islam is science...asking questions and getting the answer to them will not lead to a weaker imaan...on the contrary...it will confirm what you know already...the puzzle pieces will fall into place and it will contribute to a stronger imaan.
The scholars who have been giving answers for 1400 years you are talking of, were not born with that knowledge. they obtained it by asking questions...a lot of questions.
The explanation about the verse in the Quran 5:101-102 is not about seeking for knowledge...it is about asking questions about stuff which may harm you if you knew the answer. In Hadeeth you can find the example about someone asking who his mother was and Muhammed (sas) did not answer him because the answer would be an embarassment to her because of premarital sex etc. So, answering his question would harm him.
In another hadeeth someone asked about whether hadj was required every year...And Muhammed (sas) did not answer that one either, because if he did...Hadj might have been obligatory to us every year.
So, no...the verse is not about genuinely investigating stuff...it is about asking questions which you actually don't want to know the answer of or to ask questions to mock Islam, or to ask too many questions during the time of the Quran to be revealed...because like the example with the hadj issue...if people asked questions during that time, the answers would cause things being obligatory or forbidden for us when otherwise it was free.