format_quote Originally Posted by
azc
if two people summoned in the court. A claims that B has borrowed certain amount and now he isn't returning the money. B in defence says that A is lying.
Who will be asked to show the evidence first...?
This is not acceptable at all. If this logic that something isn't mentioned in adilla e shariah is halal, will open the gate of deviation,
if someone asks you to show the evidence that celebrating the birth of prophet s.a.w is prohibited...?
Since it's not mentioned in scriptures, so by your logic is halal...?
First, A needs to provide proof that money was borrowed in the first place, Then if that is established, B needs to provide proof that the money was given back to A.
In our case, you need to establish that everything is forbidden except that which is mentioned in the Quran or Sunnah in the first place. So that i may be able to proceed in researching for a daleen of allowing it.
By your logic, EVERYTHING in this would can be considered haram that isnt strictly mentioned in Quran or Sunnah. Like i mentioned before, Computers, mobiles, Satellites, Power Stations, Cars, Airplanes, Cranes, Concrete buildings, Currencies other than gold or silver coins, mattresses .... EVERYTHING becomes haram brother. Is this the deen that you follow?
"Since it's not mentioned in scriptures, so by your logic is halal...?" Not quite ... If there isnt anything mentioned about it, or if it does not go against any teachings of islam then yes it should be Halal.
Example: Porn is not mentioned in Quran or Sunnah. However, we know its haram because it goes against the command of Allah that says do not look at other people's awrah. On the other hand Building Space ships are also not mentioned in Quran or Sunnah but is there anything that goes against it in Quran or Sunnah? no .... similarly, is there anythign that goes against fashion shows that are modest and follow islamic teachings in that it doesnt allow free mixing or exposure of awrah?
You assumption that Mawlid is forbidden just because its not mentioned in Sunnah. That is wrong. It is claimed to be forbidden on the bases that its bidah, and that is an innovated Eid other than what the Prophet has told us we were given (Small and Big Eid). That is why its prohibited, not because it wasnt mentioned. And allah knows best.