Stories Regarding Allah (swt) Prophets[PBUH] or Angels

[itsme01]

:sl:

refer to this thread
http://www.islamicboard.com/islamic-...angel-you.html

According to me this is not right. As such a thing never took place, and coming up with stories about which we have no knowledge (when it contains Allah, Angels, or Prophets) I say is Haram.

(nurul3eyen - nothing personal - hope you understand that)

:w:

[itsme01]

bump

[songinwind]

:sl:

refer to this thread
http://www.islamicboard.com/islamic-...angel-you.html

According to me this is not right. As such a thing never took place, and coming up with stories about which we have no knowledge (when it contains Allah, Angels, or Prophets) I say is Haram.

(nurul3eyen - nothing personal - hope you understand that)

:w:

Brother..I went and looked at this,,,and its a "Poem", which I too am a writter of poetry..and u raised a intresting things here...is this allowed or not, according to islam??
Than , not to disrespect u in any way....You made some statements>>According to me this is not right,,and I say is Haram. <<<<
Brother only ONE has this right....:Allah"..so we need to read, and see what ALLAH says about his...not we or I...:) peace to you..

[itsme01]

Brother..I went and looked at this,,,and its a "Poem", which I too am a writter of poetry..and u raised a intresting things here...is this allowed or not, according to islam??
Than , not to disrespect u in any way....You made some statements>>According to me this is not right,,and I say is Haram. <<<<
Brother only ONE has this right....:Allah"..so we need to read, and see what ALLAH says about his...not we or I...:) peace to you..

agreed.

However - the point remains: Because it is very clear that since we have no knowledge of Allah and Angels and Jinns (except whats given to us in Ahdiths and Quran) - coming up with "fictional" events in which either "Allah [swt]" or Angels or Prophets speak is wrong.


I cannot recall it: but there is a Verse that says something about Poets (and how they tell lies) and compares to the Truth (i.e. Quran).

So basically, what I am saying is that these "poems" are lies (no offence) - which is a sin.

-- songinwind dont take it personal, and i hope you understand what i mean above.


Jazak'Allah Khair