format_quote Originally Posted by
Dahir
Do you not speak English!!!???
I do, but I'm afraid you really ought to read your own posts and consider their implications before asking such stupid questions. It's not my fault if you choose to string yourself up with your own arguments.
Kidnap of Civillian = Crime
Kidnap of Soldier = POW/"Fair Game," casualty of combat, etc., NOT a crime!!
If a state of war or armed conflict exists between two nations (even when the status of one
as a nation is disputed, such as in assorted seperatist conflicts) that difference exists. As you claim that there is no Palestinian nation,
no Palestinian armed forces and indeed that Palestine does not exist at all, a state of war cannot exist. BY YOUR OWN LOGIC, likewise no form of legitimate "combat" can exist, therefore there can be no distinction between kidnapping a soldier or a civilian. Such a kidnapping MUST be a purely criminal act, as there is nothing else it can be (assuming kidnapping itself is considered criminal).
Okay, Trumble, you seem to not understand the rules of society
You can have all the "rules" you like; none have any relevance unless they are applied. Do the Israelis comply with them? Do Hamas and Islamic Jihaad? If so, then what is everybody complaining about?
What's next, Trumble, you're going to tell me that the D-Day assault was a crime commited by the allies because they killed German soldiers.
Now you are just being silly. The distinction is obvious; Germany existed, the German occupation of Northern France existed and a state of war existed.
What's next, your'e going to tell me that the capture of Saddam Hussein was a crime commited by the US and UK?
Again, no. The state of Iraq clearly existed, and still does. In any event the capture of a suspected
criminal is not a crime - Saddam is NOT a "prisoner of war".
Note: I did not refer to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict as a war.
You implied that the Israelis did
Gaza and West Bank do NOT even have an army to defend themselves, how can it be a war or "retaliation?"
and I referred to it in that context.
format_quote Originally Posted by
islam-truth
:sl:
Your wrong, just cause someone is firing rockets doesn't make them a extrimist
When those rockets are targetted at civilians, it does in my book.
yes it is religious you mess with one group of muslims then your messing with the ummah.
This would be the same ummah that has, to all intents and purposes, treated the Palestinian people like dirt for most of the last 60 years, would it?