/* */

PDA

View Full Version : Hindu-Christian Clashes in India



The_Prince
12-27-2007, 01:44 PM
Hindu extremists burned down the house of a prominent Christian politician in eastern India Thursday, officials said, as violence by gangs from both sides continued despite a curfew imposed after two days of attacks against Christians by Hindu hard-liners.A mob of Hindus torched the house of Radhakant Nayak, a member of the Indian parliament's upper house and a Christian leader in the area, Nayak told the CNN-IBN news channel.

In apparent retaliation for earlier attacks on churches, a group of Christians burned down several Hindu homes in the village of Brahmangaon. Angry Hindus then burned down the village police station, complaining of a lack of protection, a local police official said, speaking on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to speak to the media.

Bahugrahi Mahapatra, a senior government official in the area confirmed there had been "disturbances" in the village, but could not provide details because he had not reached the scene.

India is overwhelmingly Hindu but officially secular. Religious minorities, such as Christians, who account for 2.5 percent of the country's 1.1. billion people, and Muslims, who make up 14 percent, often coexist peacefully. Some have risen to the highest levels of government and business.

But throughout India's history, both communities have faced repeated attacks from hard-line Hindus, with violence against Christians often directed at foreign missionaries and converts from Hinduism.

Earlier, police had said they had deployed hundreds of armed officers to the area, restoring calm after hard-line Hindus marred Christmas celebrations, ransacking and burning eight village churches in Orissa state, a corner of the country with a history of violence against Christians. One person was killed in that violence.

However, Nayak said there was no evidence that forces were on the ground.

"The state government has been saying they have sent forces, but on the ground we are hearing there is no force. The situation is still tense," he told the TV channel.

Six village churches — most nothing more than mud-and-thatch houses — were torched on Christmas Day, and two more were attacked Wednesday along with 10 houses belonging to Christians, said Mahapatra.

There were conflicting reports of what sparked the attacks on the churches in the rural district of Kandhamal, about 840 miles southeast of New Delhi. Each side blamed the other.

The Hindu hard-liners said Christians had attempted to attack one of their leaders, 80-year-old Laxmanananda Saraswati of the Vishwa Hindu Parishad group, who leads an anti-conversion movement.

But the New Delhi-based Catholic Bishops Conference of India said the fighting began Monday when Hindu extremists objected to a show marking Christmas Eve, believing it was designed to encourage Hindus at the bottom of the religion's rigid caste hierarchy to convert to Christianity.

Orissa has one of the worst histories of anti-Christian violence. An Australian missionary and his two sons, aged 8 and 10, were burned to death in their car in Orissa following a Bible study class in 1999.

Orissa is the only Indian state that has a law requiring people to obtain police permission before they change their religion. The law was intended to counter missionary work.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20071227/...uU2qjNC5b9xg8F
Reply

Login/Register to hide ads. Scroll down for more posts
north_malaysian
12-27-2007, 10:44 PM
Are those Hindus belong to RSS?
Reply

snakelegs
12-27-2007, 11:03 PM
i don't know if they're RSS or not.
many hindus are angry and concerned (legitimately, in my opinion) at the christian missionaries who come in and give people tv's and stuff .... they literally buy converts. with some, it is more than a religious issue. they feel that people are being turned against their own culture by adopting a foreign religion.
i think some states may have either already passed laws prohibiting conversions. in india, lower castes or outcasts frequently try to escape the caste system by adopting other relgions, including budhism and islam.
i think hindutva is largely a brahmin movement and wants to preserve the caste system - not have outcastes simply leave.
christianity has been in india, esp in the south for a long, long time.
Reply

The_Prince
12-27-2007, 11:55 PM
format_quote Originally Posted by snakelegs
i don't know if they're RSS or not.
many hindus are angry and concerned (legitimately, in my opinion) at the christian missionaries who come in and give people tv's and stuff .... they literally buy converts. with some, it is more than a religious issue. they feel that people are being turned against their own culture by adopting a foreign religion.
i think some states may have either already passed laws prohibiting conversions. in india, lower castes or outcasts frequently try to escape the caste system by adopting other relgions, including budhism and islam.
i think hindutva is largely a brahmin movement and wants to preserve the caste system - not have outcastes simply leave.
christianity has been in india, esp in the south for a long, long time.
dont forget christians in north east india have been killing hindus for 13 years now to create a seperate christian state......
Reply

Welcome, Guest!
Hey there! Looks like you're enjoying the discussion, but you're not signed up for an account.

When you create an account, you can participate in the discussions and share your thoughts. You also get notifications, here and via email, whenever new posts are made. And you can like posts and make new friends.
Sign Up
NoName55
12-28-2007, 08:38 AM
format_quote Originally Posted by The_Prince
dont forget christians in north east india have been killing hindus for 13 years now to create a seperate christian state......
hahaha. yoo iz funny!
Reply

NoName55
12-28-2007, 08:44 AM
format_quote Originally Posted by snakelegs
i don't know if they're RSS or not.
many hindus are angry and concerned (legitimately, in my opinion) at the christian missionaries who come in and give people tv's and stuff .... they literally buy converts. with some, it is more than a religious issue. they feel that people are being turned against their own culture by adopting a foreign religion.
i think some states may have either already passed laws prohibiting conversions. in india, lower castes or outcasts frequently try to escape the caste system by adopting other relgions, including budhism and islam.
i think hindutva is largely a brahmin movement and wants to preserve the caste system - not have outcastes simply leave.
christianity has been in india, esp in the south for a long, long time.
hindus are angry and concerned (legitimately, in my opinion) at the christian missionaries who come in and give people tv's and stuff .... they literally buy converts.
I am shocked, so it is preferable to have an oppressed illiterate and untouchable hindu to an educated, fed and clothed Christian?
Reply

Abdul-Raouf
12-28-2007, 11:15 AM
VHP - Vishva Hindu Parishad ... its a hindu org... members from this group attacked the churches...

But i dono the reason..y ....at first..the christians attacked the hindu leader...?

format_quote Originally Posted by The_Prince

Orissa is the only Indian state that has a law requiring people to obtain police permission before they change their religion. The law was intended to counter missionary work.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20071227/...uU2qjNC5b9xg8F

^^ Thats because the missionary people .... attract the poor .. with money, land, education....to convert them.

Many poor people... fall into their trap....Atlast most of them are betrayed....these missionary people fail to keep their promise...

Thus these poor people... are put in a bad situation..they couldn complain the police...becos its just a private promise....

and later some of them get angry and start attacking the missionary people...

and finally leads to violence... between communities...
Reply

north_malaysian
12-28-2007, 12:37 PM
format_quote Originally Posted by Abdul-Raouf
and finally leads to violence... between communities...
Do the Hindus have conflicts with other religious groups beside Muslims and Christians?
Reply

The_Prince
12-28-2007, 12:50 PM
format_quote Originally Posted by NoName55
hahaha. yoo iz funny!
whats so funny about saying a fact that christian terrorists in north east india have been killing hindus for 13 years now to create a seperate christian state? ^o)

http://www.stephen-knapp.com/thirtee...in_tripura.htm
Reply

north_malaysian
12-28-2007, 01:06 PM
format_quote Originally Posted by The_Prince
whats so funny about saying a fact that christian terrorists in north east india have been killing hindus for 13 years now to create a seperate christian state? ^o)

http://www.stephen-knapp.com/thirtee...in_tripura.htm
I dont think they want to create a christian state... because Christians dont support a theocratic type country.

Maybe they want independent Tripura country... thus it's more to nationalistic rather than religious..
Reply

Sarada
12-28-2007, 01:09 PM
format_quote Originally Posted by The_Prince
whats so funny about saying a fact that christian terrorists in north east india have been killing hindus for 13 years now to create a seperate christian state? ^o)

http://www.stephen-knapp.com/thirtee...in_tripura.htm
There is nothing funny about it at all. Christians should stop proselytising. Period. Any religion that is worth following will gain sincere devotees by merely setting an example.

Here is my summary of the history of Christian tyranny in North East India.

The article below is a summary You can read the complete article at:

http://www.christianaggression.org/i...&type=articles


Christian Conversions and Terrorism in North-East India
Posted March 10, 2006
Reproduced courtesy, �Akhil Bharatiya Vanavasi Kalyan Ashram, 50 Golden Years�, A Shree Multimedia Vision Ltd. Presentation.


North-East India is a term that usually refers to the seven states of Assam, Nagaland, Manipur, Tripura, Meghalaya, Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh. Sikkim and the Darjeeling district of West Bengal belong to it geographically but are not normally included though often associated with the North East India Christian Council. An intense movement of conversion towards Christianity has taken place over the years; indeed, in several of these states, entire populations have been converted. The percentage of the Christian population in these states in 1991 is as follows:

Arunachal Pradesh: 10.29%
Assam: 03.32
Manipur: 34.12
Meghalaya: 64.58
Mizoram: 85.73
Nagaland: 87.47
Tripura: 01.69

It is true that Christian missionaries have brought education and civic amenities into this region. However, as in many parts of the world, Christianity has wiped out a whole way of life, erasing centuries of tradition, customs and wisdom. It has caused people to hold their own religion in contempt and look westwards to an alien culture. It has disrupted society by pitting the Christian converts against mainstream Hindu India.

This creation of a class-conflict has insulated the tribals from Indian society, and made them a tool in the hands of Christian missionaries. Missionaries in India have often been a divisive force, which used the tribals for advocating a breaking-up of the country.

Today, as in the past, Christian terrorists feel emboldened to use the gun to force Jesus down the throats of unwilling tribals. For example, in 1857, the Christian Missionaries of Chhota Nagpur offered to the British 10,000 armed converted Kols, in addition, Dr. Mason offered a battalion of converted Karens to put down the 1857 Indian War of Independence. The fear of segregating Indian Christians and training and using them for the purposes of political or religious blackmail on behalf of foreign interests in moments of crisis is not without foundation.
Some of the methods used by the missionaries to convert and thus alienate innocent tribals and their impact are as follows:

1) British Connivance:

After the British administration entered North East India, Catholic and Baptist missionaries were encouraged to come and proselytize, and were given protection under the British Raj. According to an early evangelist Kemolhu, there was forceful opposition to Christianity in those early days and the evangelists had no place to lodge in nor did they have a place to preach the gospel. The village headman (Gaon Budha) appointed by the British government gave them shelter since they belonged to the government and no one could object to their stay.|( In and around 1822, David Scott Esq., )

Christian missionaries virtually held a license during British Raj to trade in human souls and to proselytize by force, fraud, inducement and deceit.

The Commissioner of Koch Behar first conceived the idea of Christianizing the Garo tribe of Assam. He wrote to Bayley, Secretary to the Government,: “I am satisfied that nothing permanently good can be obtained by other means (than sending a missionary) and that, if we do not interfere on behalf of the poor Garo, they will soon become Hindu or half-Hindu.” Secretary Bayley sent a most encouraging letter in reply closing with the words: “I do not think the favourable opportunity for making this interesting experiment should be lost .”


2) Theological Deceit:


Missionaries have spread the belief that the tribals of North East India had no religion. In fact, for most people of this region, belief in Supreme Being is a distinctive feature. He is the Creator and Sustainer of humans and the whole universe and is believed to be loving and benevolent (as against the jealous Christian God). They also believe in many secondary deities. The tribals also believe in the existence of malevolent spirits. They believe in the immortality of the soul and life after death. All religious rites are performed by functionaries like the Lyngdoh (Khasis), Putir (Ao), Puitham (Mizo), Kamal nokma (Garo) and so on. Pioneer Christian missionaries like JH Lorrain adopted the term �Pathian� used by the Mizos for their supreme Spirit to indicate the Christian God. Jesus was presented as �Christus Victor� or Jesus Christ the Conqueror (of all evil spirits).The belief of the Ao Naga people in life after death was linked to the life, death and resurrection of Jesus. To this day, missionaries use theological deceit for conversion. They have been guilty of substituting the names of Ram and Krishna in the popular baar-geets of legendary Assamese Saint Sanardeva with the name of Jesus. When the local Vaishnava Sabha reacted angrily, they had to eat crow and withdraw the offending stanzas.

3) Deceit By Other Means:

Economic conversions are carried out by placing “miracle boxes” in local churches. The gullible villager writes out a request for a loan, a pucca house, or perhaps, fees for the son‘s schooling. A few weeks later, the miracle happens. And the whole family converts, making others in the village follow suit. Another example, small children have been invited for a day’s outing. The missionaries remove the spark plugs from the bus, so that it can not start. They are told to pray to their local deities to ask them for help. Nothing happens. After a short time, the children are asked to pray to Jesus for help. The missionaries surreptitiously reinstall the spark plugs, and “miraculously” their prayers to Jesus have been answered.

4) Education:

The introduction of Western education was the main missionary approach to convert the Naga into Christianity. After independence, the Roman Catholics also gained entry into Nagaland hitherto denied by the Protestant British. The key to their success was their educational policy. Father Thomas Menamparambil writes: The boarding houses in Shillong, Gauhati and Dibrugarh have played an important role in the evangelization of the region. They formed lay leaders and well-instructed religious teachers. Every year, a good number from among the senior students were baptized. It was precisely these youngsters that helped plant the church in the Garo Hills, in Nagaland, Manipur and to some extent in Mizoram. The experience of the Baptists in the Orphan school in Nowgong was to repeat itself again and again in dozens of our institutions to our own day. (This approach of sending children to boarding schools has been condemned by the Government of Canada, and Canadian Aboriginals have been granted compensation for the damage done in these schools.)


5) Imposition of Roman Script:

The first thing that missionaries did when beginning work among a new tribe was to reduce its language to writing. This the missionaries did to enable people to read the Bible. At first, for the Khasi and Garo languages, the Bengali / Assamese script was used but was later given up in favor of Roman. From 1970, the Church openly championed the use of the Roman script for the language of the tribals of Tripura and Boros of Assam.,,,. The imposition of the Roman script has on occasion been at gunpoint.

On August 21, 2000, terrorists of the Church backed National Democratic Front of Bodoland gunned down Shri Bineshwar Brahma, president of the Bodo Sahitya Sabha. His only crime was that he favored the use of Devanagari script for the Bodo language. It is significant that English is an official language in Arunachal Pradesh, Assam, Meghalaya, Mizoram, Nagaland and Tripura.


6) Self Alienation:

The tribals after conversion to Christianity were urged to abstain from their indigenous festivals because now these festivals and rituals are seen as evil. Hence we see the Christian Khasis of Meghalaya do not take part in the Sad Suk Mynstem festival or the Nongkrem festival. Those converted to Christianity in Arunachal Pradesh have distanced themselves or are made to do so, from festivals like the Solung or Mopin. The Christian Garos remain cut off from the Wangla festival dance. This phenomenon continues throughout the tribal populations. They remain aloof from their traditional dances, chose western names for their children, start wearing western clothes, sing western music and so on. This then causes major rifts within the community, and a breakdown of traditional values. (It is part of the colonial “Divide and Conquer” doctrine which worked so well to “keep the natives in their place” and make them incapable of ruling themselves in post colonial times.)


7) Circumventing Laws:

Missionary activities were very marginal, or almost nil, until 1962 in Arunachal Pradesh. However, these anti-national and divisive forces, in different names and forms, have been working through various agencies in Assam-Arunachal Pradesh border. Gradually and stealthily, they gained entry into Arunachal Pradesh with the help of the few local Arunachali students who had studied in Christian Missionary schools in Assam and Meghalaya and got converted there. By 1970, almost 8% of the people along the Assam -Arunachal border had got converted to Christianity. However, they could not very actively engage in proselytizing in Arunachal in a big way due to the Innerline Permit Restrictions on entry for non-Arunachalis imposed by the government. But a sizeable number of simple people of Arunachal had been lured away into Christian fold, in many causes, through material temptations including offer of money, and by threats. The Church has also engaged a number of local people as paid agents to carry on pro-Christian propaganda through various means, fair and foul.

8) Harassment and Ostracism:

Many reports have come of how Church congregations use harassment, ostracism and other forms of force to increase their flock. Non-converted portions of a family land into disputes with neo-Christian portions over funeral customs, ownership of land and other matters and this result in clashes between groups which newspapers promptly label as anti-Christian acts, whereas these are often clashes between converted and non-converted tribals.





9) Extortion:

The National Socialist Council of Nagaland (NSCN), a terrorist organization has two main factions. Both the factions are headed by Christians and get financial support from World Council of Churches, a missionary organization. China provides arms and ammunitions to both the factions. The NSCN has its offices in New York, Geneva and Hague which display boards with legend Peoples Republic of Nagaland. It has twice raised its demand for an independent nation in the United Nations. The NSCN has its own government which collects money from the local people. One third of the salaries of the government servants is taken away as Nagaland Tax before disbursement. Most of the banks in Nagaland have closed down because of the huge sums extracted by this outfit. The letterheads and stamps of this unofficial government read Nagaland for Christ.

Most of the terrorist organizations in the entire region follow this pattern. The Church in the North-East is also known to be associated with smuggling across the borders and circulation of fake currency notes. In December 1998, Bedang Tamjen, a JemiNaga missionary was arrested for making fake currency notes.


10) Conversion at Gun Point:

The Baptist Church in Tripura was set up by missionaries from New Zealand 60 years ago .It won only a few thousand converts until 1980 when a mass scale ethnic riot was engineered by the Church in which systematic ethnic cleansing of Hindu and Buddhist tribals was initiated. Thousands of women were raped and kidnapped and forced to convert to Christianity.

The terrorists receive military aid from extremist Christian groups in Australia and New Zealand. They also have ongoing exchanges with Islamic terrorist and ISI who push in arms from the Bangladeshi border.

In Tripura, the tribals constitute 30 percent of the State population, and 10 percent of this group had been converted to Christianity by 1991. These Christianized tribals are trying to convert the Hindu tribals forcibly to Christianity often getting the help of the National Liberation Front of Tripura (NLFT), a Christian terror group founded in December 1989. About 90 percent of the top ranking NLFT cadres are Christians. NLFT has further links with the Inter Services Intelligences Agency (ISI), Pakistan�s external intelligence agency and its counter part in Bangladesh, the Directorate General of Field Intelligence (DGFI).
During 1997-98, NLFT leaders are reported to have visited Pakistan to receive training and arms from the ISI. The ISI had allegedly arranged the passport and visas for the NLFT leaders. According to Tripura Police, the NLFT has also linkages with the Nagaland-based National Socialist Council of Nagaland- Isak�Muivah (NSCN-IM), the Manipur based Kanglei Yawol Kanna Lup (KYKL) and the National Democratic Front of Bodoland (NDFB), which is active in Assam. Since its inception the NLFT has been engaged in an armed struggle to carve out a separate Christian nation Tripura. The forcible conversions are accompanied by murders of Hindu priests in the area, forcible bans on Hindu festivities, abductions and killings.

The backing of the Baptist church right from the beginning has enabled this organization to spread its base. Due to its terrorist activities, the organization was banned by the government in 1997 but it continued its operations from across the Bangladesh border. The priests of the Baptist church supply arms and ammunitions to these terrorist rebels.

Nagmanlal Halam, the secretary of the Noapara Baptist Church in Tripura was arrested by CRPF in April 2000 on charges of aiding insurgents and possessing a large quantity of explosives including 60 gelatin sticks, 5Kg of potassium, 2Kg of sulfur and other ingredients for making powerful bombs. Two junior members of the same church, who had been arrested earlier, tipped the police off about the explosives which were meant for terrorist organization like the NLFT. Mr. Halam confessed to buying and supplying explosives to the NLFT.

Another church official, Jatna Koloi, who was also arrested, admitted that he received training in guerrilla warfare at an NLFT base (8). It is now apparent that the pattern of forced conversions at gunpoint are irrefutably linked to the Baptist Church in Tripura. The NLFT is accused of forcing Tripura�s indigenous tribes to become Christians and give up Hindu forms of worship in areas under their control.

For decades Tripuras indigenous tribal population has been dragged out of their homes and forced to convert to Christianity under threat of violence. Whenever any of the tribals organize Hindu festivals or rituals, the terrorist groups attack to desecrate and kill the participants. There have been incidents of issuing a ban on the Hindu festivals of Durga Pooja and Saraswati Pooja. The NLFT manifesto says that they want to expand what they describe as the kingdom of God and Christ in Tripura. The hill tribe Jamatiya worship in the month of March their traditional god Gadiya, who is supposed to be an incarnation of Lord Shiva. The terrorists have issued an order that the Gadiya be prayed on the Christmas day instead.

Hundreds of the RSS volunteers were attacked, threatened and blackmailed. Several of them were murdered and a number of them were kidnapped and held hostage by the Christian terrorists.

In August 2000, Swami Shantikali Maharaj, the famous Hindu sage known for his social services was killed by the terrorists. In December 2000, Lavkumar Jamatiya, the priest of the Jamatiya tribe was killed, two Hindu temples and one Buddhist temple were destroyed and order was issued to end all non Christian methods of praying.

In the year 2001, there were 826 terrorist attacks in Tripura in which 405 persons were killed and 481 cases of kidnapping by the rebels. The case of Jamatiya tribals provides a telling example. These tribals have strong spiritual leaders and a network of social service organizations headed by their religious leaders. These indigenous sects are neither exclusive nor expansionist. The Baptist Church has always failed miserably in its conversion efforts with regard to this well-knit community.

Hence, it is no wonder that the NLFT has made Jamatiya institutions and their religious leaders the targets of their attacks. In the August of 2000, religious leaders of the Jamatiya community like Jaulushmoni Jamatiya and Shanit Kumar Tripura were killed by the NLFT, and Jamatiya families were uprooted from their homelands and made refugees. The death threats issued by the NLFT to the inmates of these institutions have already forced the closure of 11 Jamatiya institutions like schools and orphanages, set up by the slain religious leaders in various parts of Tripura.

Shorn of its mask of love and compassion, the true color of Christianity is evident in all its nakedness in the North East. Fortunately, the tribals are realizing that their Christianization has led to loss of identity and self-alienation. They are slowly reviving their ancient traditions and customs. Our tribal brethren need our active support to overthrow the yoke of Christianity. Are we going to respond to their call?






FAIR USE NOTICE: Many of the stories on this site contain copyrighted material whose use has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making this material available in its efforts to advance the understanding of different issues related to this site. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material as provided for in Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107 of the US Copyright Law. If you wish to use such copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Note: The views expressed on this site are those of the respective authors and not necessarily those of this website. This website holds the Christian faith in high regard and is in no way anti-Christian. Rather this website is opposed to the aggression practiced under in the name of Ch
Reply

The_Prince
12-28-2007, 01:13 PM
format_quote Originally Posted by north_malaysian
I dont think they want to create a christian state... because Christians dont support a theocratic type country.

Maybe they want independent Tripura country... thus it's more to nationalistic rather than religious..
well maybe the western christians you have talked to have said that, but indian christians, and south asian christians are very different than western ones, and yes even african christians are very different than western ones. western christians are pretty much racist, they think their the face and image of christianity, for instance when third world christians commit so much crime and terrorism they brush it off................

these christians in north east are forcing ppl to convert, aboloshing hindu practices, etc etc, thats not national, thats religous. also movements can combine both religion and nationalism together, hence this is both, they want their own tripura state seperate from india, but they also want it to be christian, with christian ways, and no other none christian ways, hence the forced conversions, killing of hindus, banning hindu festivities etc etc.
Reply

Sarada
12-28-2007, 01:34 PM
format_quote Originally Posted by The_Prince
well maybe the western christians you have talked to have said that, but indian christians, and south asian christians are very different than western ones, and yes even african christians are very different than western ones. western christians are pretty much racist, they think their the face and image of christianity, for instance when third world christians commit so much crime and terrorism they brush it off................

these christians in north east are forcing ppl to convert, aboloshing hindu practices, etc etc, thats not national, thats religous. also movements can combine both religion and nationalism together, hence this is both, they want their own tripura state seperate from india, but they also want it to be christian, with christian ways, and no other none christian ways, hence the forced conversions, killing of hindus, banning hindu festivities etc etc.
I agree with you, Prince, most devout Christians would like to live in a Christian State. Look at Italy, most South American countries, even here in Canada, where I live, it is supposed to be secular, but we many Christians would say that we live in Christian country.
Reply

Amadeus85
12-28-2007, 02:04 PM
format_quote Originally Posted by Sarada
I agree with you, Prince, most devout Christians would like to live in a Christian State. Look at Italy, most South American countries, even here in Canada, where I live, it is supposed to be secular, but we many Christians would say that we live in Christian country.
It is difference between a country with christian fundaments and culture (like Canada or Italy i believe) and a theocratic christian country like they were some in middle ages. Besides, I dont believe that all christian organizations in India really convert for money. Ok maybe some, but Im sure not all. Of course I am against violence, but I must say that hindus have right to defend their countrie's identity and culture against foreign influences (be it islam or christianity). But they should do it with education and propaganda not with violence.
Reply

snakelegs
12-28-2007, 07:19 PM
format_quote Originally Posted by NoName55
I am shocked, so it is preferable to have an oppressed illiterate and untouchable hindu to an educated, fed and clothed Christian?
no, of course not. but i find their anger at missionaries buying converts quite understandable, nonethelesss. as i said, it is more than religion - people feel that the christians are turning people away from their own culture. i can understand why people resent foreign missionaries and their $. the modern american missionaries are sort of a new breed, armed with limitless amounts of money to buy souls. i can also see passing laws outlawing proselytizing - but most definitely not outlawing conversion.
but i think the real reasons often have to do more with not wanting to allow the lower caste and outcastes to escape hinduism.
the question you have raised in a very difficult one. i think if my children were hungry, i would probably welcome anybody who would give them food.
thank god, i have never been in that position. many are less fortunate.
Reply

Sarada
12-29-2007, 04:40 AM
[QUOTE I must say that hindus have right to defend their countrie's identity and culture against foreign influences (be it islam or christianity). But they should do it with education and propaganda not with violence.[/QUOTE]

I agree with you 100%. I posted that lengthy article to explain why Hindus might be a little upset. But violence is not the answer, on many different levels.
Reply

Sarada
12-29-2007, 04:59 AM
format_quote Originally Posted by snakelegs
but i think the real reasons often have to do more with not wanting to allow the lower caste and outcastes to escape hinduism.
Christian missionaries have been bent on destroying indigeneous cultures for centuries. Their proselytising and making people feel ashamed of their own "backward" cultures are very effective psychological and spiritual tools to divide and conquer. Destroying family and community relationships has resulted in the sad state of affairs our own indigenous people find themselves in right here in North America. What they are doing is taking advantage of impoverished people to satisfy their own long term goals.

Missionaries are wolves in sheep's clothing. Their so-called humanitarian work comes at a very high price.

Unfortunately, it is also the naive andnwell meaning ordinary missionaries on the ground that are also being duped.

Let everyone believe as they choose, as long as they do not try to convert others by using undue influence, trickery, bribes or other nefarious means, that is their right. Those who wish to convert should be able to do so with an informed mind, not under pressure, or duress.
Reply

glo
12-29-2007, 05:20 AM
format_quote Originally Posted by Sarada
Let everyone believe as they choose, as long as they do not try to convert others by using undue influence, trickery, bribes or other nefarious means, that is their right. Those who wish to convert should be able to do so with an informed mind, not under pressure, or duress.
Well said, Sarada.
I strongly agree.

I am ashamed to think that such methods are employed by some missionaries ... :(

peace
Reply

north_malaysian
12-30-2007, 02:58 AM
so... can this conflict be solved?
Reply

Pygoscelis
12-30-2007, 04:14 AM
I have mixed feelings towards missionaries. On the one hand, from a believer's perspective, they act out of compassion. They see souls destined for hellfire and seek to save them. That's giving of them. Makes me kind of wonder about the other religious people who seem quite ok with us heathens burning forever in hellfire.

On the other hand, and from a secular perspective, they are arrogant, exploitive and try to brainwash the unfornate and desperate. They are the lowest of the low.

Standard brainwashing technique is to break your victim down into feeling desperate and dehumanized and then to lift them back up in conjunction with your message. This is almost exactly how missionaries behave.

So I have difficulty judging them. They are at the same time noble and dastardly.
Reply

guyabano
12-30-2007, 12:55 PM
format_quote Originally Posted by The_Prince
whats so funny about saying a fact that christian terrorists in north east india have been killing hindus for 13 years now to create a seperate christian state? ^o)

I like this one. This fits into your agenda, isn't it ?
Reply

The_Prince
12-30-2007, 02:54 PM
format_quote Originally Posted by guyabano
I like this one. This fits into your agenda, isn't it ?
what would you like me to call them? dandy smiling all loving christians? plz plz tell me what would you like me to call these christians????

and my agenda? what would that be? incase your abit thick or something the topic is hindu christian clashes, hence the comments i made are relevent to the subject on this thread, so maybe you need brain surgery?

but you prove what ive said on another thread, that you westerners are trying to silence the Muslim voice. i have seen you on many threads always talking Islamic terrorists bla bla bla, but when i bring up christian terrorists, with the links and everything, what do you do? instead of responding to the issue, you spin it and say oh look, this muslim has an agenda!

so its ok for you to 24-7 speak against Muslims and Muslims shooting and blowing some things up, but when Muslims speak against Christians doing the exact same thing it all of a sudden becomes some evil agenda? as i said folks, theyre trying to silence the Muslim voice, whenever we expose their crimes they will spin it by not responding, no, they will spin it and try to attack you.....your pathetic at best, seriously.
Reply

north_malaysian
12-30-2007, 02:58 PM
I think the world reserved the term "terrorists" to Muslims only....

If it involved other religious groups they would call them extremists, fighters, guerillas, rebels, seccessionist, anything but "terrorists".
Reply

Hawa
12-31-2007, 11:33 AM
I must say that hindus have right to defend their countrie's identity and culture against foreign influences (be it islam or christianity). But they should do it with education and propaganda not with violence.

Defend themselves against ideologies? There is no culture on earth worth preserving let alone through violent means.


To those who've hijacked this thread, those arguments are getting really old. No one is furthering any notable cause so why not quit the bickering, agree to disagree and get on with life. It's all incredibly childish.
Reply

NoName55
12-31-2007, 01:21 PM
format_quote Originally Posted by The_Prince
whats so funny about saying a fact that christian terrorists in north east india have been killing hindus for 13 years now to create a seperate christian state? ^o)

http://www.stephen-knapp.com/thirtee...in_tripura.htm
Reading through this dumb thread, it became obvious to me that you are very ignorant of Islam, following logic of this idiotic thread, it would seem that it is o k for Hindus to use any means to stop people from escaping oppression and starvation but it is not allowed for Christians to fight back.

about you having Christmas dinner with a Christian friend (whose food is haram for us as is taking part in their festivals) is quite a revelation.

Regarding your rantings about Jewish media:
Suffice it to say that; Jewish behavior, attitude and actions towards us are product of their history determined by their desire to survive (among other things) and it is being reinforced by the foul behavior of big mouthed, ignorant and illiterate moolas who don't know how to control their tongues

just when one thinks this site cannot be dragged down anymore in to the gutter, someone like you comes along and proves the opposite.

Note: to clarify that this post is not in support of any kafar trolls: I despise guyabano types as much as I loathe fake moolahs (and hindus).
Reply

Amadeus85
12-31-2007, 01:22 PM
The topic is about hindu- christian clashes , not about paying taxes right?
Reply

NoName55
12-31-2007, 01:26 PM
....
Reply

chacha_jalebi
12-31-2007, 04:00 PM
elo ello

my first action as a mod :shade:

all the off topic and argument causing posts have been removed

lets not post stuff and try to get under each others skins, debate in a nice way and stay on topic . .
Reply

ricardo_sousa
12-31-2007, 04:01 PM
format_quote Originally Posted by chacha_jalebi
lets not post stuff and try to get under each others skins, debate in a nice way and stay on topic . .
I understand the taxes comments being deleted... but why you delete my opinion about this topic?
Reply

MTAFFI
12-31-2007, 04:49 PM
format_quote Originally Posted by The_Prince
what would you like me to call them? dandy smiling all loving christians? plz plz tell me what would you like me to call these christians????

and my agenda? what would that be? incase your abit thick or something the topic is hindu christian clashes, hence the comments i made are relevent to the subject on this thread, so maybe you need brain surgery?

but you prove what ive said on another thread, that you westerners are trying to silence the Muslim voice. i have seen you on many threads always talking Islamic terrorists bla bla bla, but when i bring up christian terrorists, with the links and everything, what do you do? instead of responding to the issue, you spin it and say oh look, this muslim has an agenda!

so its ok for you to 24-7 speak against Muslims and Muslims shooting and blowing some things up, but when Muslims speak against Christians doing the exact same thing it all of a sudden becomes some evil agenda? as i said folks, theyre trying to silence the Muslim voice, whenever we expose their crimes they will spin it by not responding, no, they will spin it and try to attack you.....your pathetic at best, seriously.
I would say you could call the Christian Terrorists, or extremists, or fanatics or whatever you want, to me it is no more than a term to describe an individual or group of individuals and does not represent all Christians. Just the same as muslim terrorist. I love Islam and Muslims, good people and a great religion. I also love christians and hindus and buddhists and taoists and atheists and even the agnostics. In every group I am sure you can find the backwards violence plagued groups, it just seems as though it is more middle easterners that we see blowing themselves into flesh stew than anyone else, often while saying "Allah is the only God and Muhammad (pbuh) was his messenger", you dont see these Christians or really anyone else doing this... I guess it is what separates the two, but what most people dont realize is that the middle east is decades, maybe more behind the rest of the world, the leaders are rish and powerful while the people are left poor and stupid. What a sad story.

Anyways, may Allah guide these groups in India to peace with one another. It is sad to see that once again religion is behind violence and a general lack of respect for human life. Ironic isnt it? :(
Reply

chacha_jalebi
12-31-2007, 05:01 PM
format_quote Originally Posted by ricardo_sousa
I understand the taxes comments being deleted... but why you delete my opinion about this topic?
aaa the powers of being a mod

well as you said bro, the ones i deleted where regarding some tax thing and the only other one i deleted of yours was about religion being a ideology . . . and the topic was hindu - christians clashes, so... :D

and bro if you have any other questions regarding deleting of threads, just pm the moderator who did it
Reply

AFDAL
01-01-2008, 05:04 PM
dont forget christians in north east india have been killing hindus for 13 years now to create a seperate christian state......

It makes me laugh when you say that in north east hindus are killed by christian. I my is a Muslim from Northeast - the main problem in northeast is that - Northeast was never a part of of India , and all of northeast wants to get rid of these Hindus - north indians. When ever you see than the majority of the peoples those who get killed by the resistance movement are the north indian hindus or the bangla hindus or the peoples who support the hindus barbaric rule.
Reply

AFDAL
01-02-2008, 12:09 AM
In India, a new breed of missionary stirs passions
By Scott Baldauf, The Christian Science Monitor
JHABUA, INDIA — Biju Verghese believes the end of the world is coming. This faith makes his work urgent: Convert as many Indians to Christianity as possible. Or, as he puts it, "reach the unreached at any cost."
Students pray at the Catholic Mission School in Jhabua. Churches like this one often focus their efforts on schools and hospitals. By Scott Baldauf, CSM

Verghese is a new breed of missionary, tied not to the mainline Protestant or Catholic churches that came with European colonizers but to expansionist evangelical movements in the U.S., Britain, and Australia. These newer Christians are now the most active here, swiftly winning over Indians like Verghese who in turn devote themselves to expanding the church's reach, village by village.
Aside from an attraction to the Christian message, some converts welcome the chance to free themselves from a low-caste status within Hinduism. Some may adopt Christianity by simply adding it to their existing beliefs. To others, conversions are a positive statement that you can choose your religious identity rather than have it fixed at birth.
But the success of recent Christian missionaries and their methods of quick conversions have brought tensions with other religions, including some Christians who fear that certain evangelicals are contributing to a volatile — and at times violent — religious atmosphere. The new missionaries put an emphasis on speed, compelled sometimes by church quotas and a belief in the approach of the world's end.
"Aggressive and unprincipled missionary work that exploits the distress and ignorance of marginalized groups ... can constitute a catalyst to localized violence, particularly when they are brought into confrontation with other" creeds, says Ajai Sahni, executive director of the Institute of Conflict Management in New Delhi.
Nationwide, India has a growing reputation for intolerance toward its religious minorities. The U.S. Committee on International Religious Freedom listed India with 10 other nations of "particular concern" — a legacy of the months-long riots in Gujarat state, when nearly 1,000 Muslims were murdered by their Hindu neighbors.
Colonial legacy
Religions on the Indian subcontinent have jostled with each other for millenniums. Invaders spread Hinduism and Islam through conquest, followed by British Christians who hoped to create "brown Englishmen." The Christian zeal for conversions ebbed in India after a nearly successful Indian rebellion in 1857 and a theological trend toward good works, such as improving education and healthcare.
Some evangelical Christian groups in India are continuing in that tradition. The Evangelical Hospital Association, for instance, has taken over the management of many of the hospitals of Northern India that were built by mainstream Christian churches during the British colonial period. Graham Staines, an evangelical missionary, was famous for his work with lepers in the state of Orissa, before he was murdered in 1999 by Hindu mobs. His wife, Gladys Staines, this week accepted India's highest award for public service, for continuing this work.
Yet many of today's missionaries are returning to practices of proselytizing that were long ago abandoned by the mainline missionaries because they were seen as offensive.
"The church [during British rule] sought actively to communicate the values of the Renaissance with its Christian message," says Sahni. "And while conversion was a significant fact of the British period, the schools and other institutions set up by the missionaries were not primarily driven by the objective of conversion."
In recent years, however, conversion activity has grown more intense, driven by the evangelical Christians funded from abroad, and Hindu nationalists. Both are targeting the same groups: impoverished Dalits, formerly known as "untouchables," and adivasis, or tribal citizens, who have long practiced a religion predating Hinduism.
Nationwide, adivasis number nearly 67 million, or 8% of the nation's population. But here in the district of Jhabua, they are more than 80% of the population. Adivasis are also among India's poorest citizens, earning perhaps $4 per capita per month.
Amid Jhabua's rolling hills and low huts of mud stand Christian churches built 100 years ago.
But the conversion work that some call "aggressive" takes place outside the traditional places of worship. Evangelical and Pentacostal missionaries go village to village, holding prayer meetings in homes or preaching outdoors to all the villagers together.
Speaking in tongues, miracles
These events often mix emotional messages of personal salvation, speaking in tongues, shaking in trances, and miraculous healings. Some people come for the spectacle; others take advantage of free food. After these performances, whole families, neighborhoods, and even villages are sometimes converted. The missionary leaders move on to the next village, leaving behind money — but sometimes little other support — for new church constructions and pastor salaries.
Verghese is pastor of the Beersheba Church of God in Jhabua. He shows a recent video CD, produced by Indian Evangelical Team (IET) leader P.G. Varghis, which makes it clear that conversion, not development, is the priority.
For Verghese and others who believe the Apocalypse could come at any moment, there is little time to carry out the kind of slow, development-oriented missionary work that mainstream churches focus on.
In the video, Varghis proudly mentions that the IET's 1,775 missionaries "planted" 2,000 churches in India in just five years, and planned to reach a goal of 7,777 churches by the year 2010.
In recent years, North India has been a key region of focus by informal networks of Christian evangelical groups in the West, with some churches drawing up quotas for new churches built, gospel literature handed out, and new missionaries trained.
"Christians are being killed," Varghis admitted in the video, "But we are dedicated to build North India for Christ."
A call for dollars
The video, which is narrated in English and is apparently aimed at a Western audience, makes an emotional appeal for funds, noting that it costs $3,000 to $6,000 to build a church, a cost that is far beyond the means of the mainly tribal population that IET hopes to convert.
The differing approaches also came to light during recent tsunami relief efforts. A host of small Christian groups headed to India, Indonesia, and Sri Lanka to distribute humanitarian aid along with Christian literature. Many faith-based aid groups, from the International Committee of the Red Cross to the American Jewish Foundation, avoid handing out such religious materials because of the potential to offend those who are of different faiths.
After the tsunami, the U.S. National Council of Churches issued a statement warning against the practice by "New Missionaries" of mixing evangelism and aid. "Often lacking sophistication about the lure of gifts and money, and wanting to be generous with their resources, they easily fall prey to the charge of using unethical means to evangelize. This creates a backlash," the February statement read.
"You get this guy out of Texas who has no idea of the local culture, he is out to win souls, and he comes with a lot of money," says Bob Alter, former Presbyterian pastor born and raised in the Indian mountain town of Mussoorie, and former superintendent of a missionary institution, the Woodstock School.
The problem with these newer churches, Alter says, is the tone of their message. "You have Baptists using the Diwali festival [the Hindu festival of lights], but they come to 'spread the light to those in darkness.' That is mighty offensive stuff, when you're out to tear down another religion."

http://www.usatoday.com/news/world/2...csm-missionari es_x.htm
Reply

The_Prince
01-02-2008, 01:53 PM
format_quote Originally Posted by AFDAL
It makes me laugh when you say that in north east hindus are killed by christian. I my is a Muslim from Northeast - the main problem in northeast is that - Northeast was never a part of of India , and all of northeast wants to get rid of these Hindus - north indians. When ever you see than the majority of the peoples those who get killed by the resistance movement are the north indian hindus or the bangla hindus or the peoples who support the hindus barbaric rule.
hey i don't care if the Hindus are barbaric monsters eating Christian babies in north east India, im not trying to sound mean when i say that, i am simply using the double standards of Christians. when Muslims in Palestine, chechnya, kashmir etc etc fight against evil oppressors the Christians call them Terrorists, evil-doers, backward Barbaric Muslims, nooo we Christians are good peace loving ppl we dont fightttttttttt......so I am going to use the same standard they use, what so when Christians fight evil people its now 'resistence"????????? sorry not in my book. a spade for a spade
Reply

ricardo_sousa
01-02-2008, 01:59 PM
The_Prince, your problem is resuming the world and its people to religion. You have born 200 years late.
Reply

AFDAL
01-02-2008, 04:34 PM
format_quote Originally Posted by The_Prince
hey i don't care if the Hindus are barbaric monsters eating Christian babies in north east India, im not trying to sound mean when i say that, i am simply using the double standards of Christians. when Muslims in Palestine, chechnya, kashmir etc etc fight against evil oppressors the Christians call them Terrorists, evil-doers, backward Barbaric Muslims, nooo we Christians are good peace loving ppl we dont fightttttttttt......so I am going to use the same standard they use, what so when Christians fight evil people its now 'resistence"????????? sorry not in my book. a spade for a spade

The thing in Assam / N.E. is that before 1947 - the Muslims of these part have being resisting the Hindu Brahmin India Barbaric act - and till now we are resisting - but not through arms. The Christian fanatic who are fighting are just some groups of money hungry peoples and they are the creation of the Brahmins. But now the cat is biting the dog.
Reply

NoName55
01-02-2008, 04:56 PM
format_quote Originally Posted by AFDAL
... now the cat is biting the dog.
that is what cats do when cornered [probably because they don't want the dogs to eat them nor do they want to become dogs (not that it is possible for a cat to become a dog)] so the only remaining option when in a corner is to try to scratch out dog's eyes.
Reply

ricardo_sousa
01-02-2008, 04:58 PM
let me see if I understand what´s going on: the Hindus created the Christian groups to mess with the Muslins?
Reply

AFDAL
01-02-2008, 09:36 PM
format_quote Originally Posted by ricardo_sousa
let me see if I understand what´s going on: the Hindus created the Christian groups to mess with the Muslins?

Look at this article - you can find some truth - http://www.milligazette.com/Archives...3112200433.htm
Reply

AFDAL
01-02-2008, 09:42 PM
format_quote Originally Posted by ricardo_sousa
let me see if I understand what´s going on: the Hindus created the Christian groups to mess with the Muslins?
Give a look at these


http://www.internal-displacement.org...9?OpenDocument
Reply

ricardo_sousa
01-03-2008, 10:55 AM
So the Muslins numbers are growing in the Assam state because of the immigration from Bangladesh and, I am quoting one of the texts, "due to their high birth rate, which is again due to their socio-economic backwardness."

The Hindus are afraid of these growth and join forces, helping the Christian groups, minorities? and now the Christians are beginning to be a treat to the Hindus... That´s what I understand.
Reply

north_malaysian
01-03-2008, 11:14 AM
How could the Hindus, Muslims, Christians and Jews co-exist in Kerala peacefully, but not elsewhere?
Reply

Umm Yoosuf
01-03-2008, 01:40 PM
Thread closed.

Threads over 3 days old are considered expired and are subject to closure without notice. threads that are seen to be more valuable or requiring more time may be extended beyond this time.
Reply

Hey there! Looks like you're enjoying the discussion, but you're not signed up for an account.

When you create an account, you can participate in the discussions and share your thoughts. You also get notifications, here and via email, whenever new posts are made. And you can like posts and make new friends.
Sign Up

Similar Threads

  1. Replies: 18
    Last Post: 05-08-2011, 04:23 PM
  2. Replies: 0
    Last Post: 04-10-2010, 01:58 AM
  3. Replies: 34
    Last Post: 04-04-2010, 03:49 AM
  4. Replies: 22
    Last Post: 05-03-2009, 05:54 PM
  5. Replies: 2
    Last Post: 08-13-2006, 09:06 PM
British Wholesales - Certified Wholesale Linen & Towels | Holiday in the Maldives

IslamicBoard

Experience a richer experience on our mobile app!