Mashallah this qari can imitate over 75 worldy-renowned Qari's including the Imam's of the Hramain, Sheikh Abu Bakr Shatry, Sheikh Mishary Rashid el-Efasy, Sheikh Abdullah Basfar and more. He is from the descendants of Imam Abu Hanifah and has had the oppurtunity to lead Salaat-ul-Taraweeh in many Masaajid's of Madinah.
Inshallah I will post his recitation on this thread from events and from his CD's
Last edited by Al-Hanbali; 09-15-2006 at 07:02 PM.
***** قال ابن أبي مليكة : أدركت ثلاثين من أصحاب النبي - صلى الله عليه وسلم - كلهم يخاف النفاق على نفسه
Ibn Abī Mulaykah said: "I encountered thirty Companions of the Prophet, every one of them fearing hypocrisy for himself." [Muslim]
Mashallah this qari can imitate over 75 worldy-renowned Qari's including the Imam's of the Hramain, Sheikh Abu Bakr Shatry, Sheikh Mishary Rashid el-Efasy, Sheikh Abdullah Basfar and more. He is from the descendants of Imam Abu Hanifah and has had the oppurtunity to lead Salaat-ul-Taraweeh in many Masaajid's of Madinah.
Inshallah I will post his recitation on this thread from events and from his CD's
[/pie]
its great that u didnt mention Shaikh Saod Ash Shuraim's name
not all
they all r great imams ,one has too work really hard to copy them. i dont want to hurt anyones feeling here but i dont know why people like saad numani.
And when he tries to copy great reciters :grumbling(anyways thats my personal opinion)
am jus trying to get away from da nasheeds.....and get into the habit listening to recitations only...inshalah.....its more relaxing, soothing.....keeps my mind from problems.......
All i hope is for my mums happiness.Shes my light.Shes my dunya.Her tears are my weakness.Her sadness breaks my heart.She is my mirror.A mirror that keeps me alive.Without her am nothing.shes my saaya.How can i leave her.I pray to Allah(swt) to keep me with her forever inshAllah.
am jus trying to get away from da nasheeds.....and get into the habit listening to recitations only...inshalah.....its more relaxing, soothing.....keeps my mind from problems.......
sis why saad nomani when orignal reciters are available , once i showed u one Shaikh Shuraim's clip , u tell me can he recites like him ur answer will be noway, ok wait for few min i am gonna post Shaikh Sudais clip in imams thread watch the clip and tell me .
not all
they all r great imams ,one has too work really hard to copy them. i dont want to hurt anyones feeling here but i dont know why people like saad numani.
And when he tries to copy great reciters :grumbling(anyways thats my personal opinion)
I know what you mean, my brother thinks the same....
And when he does one aayah Sheikh Sudais and one aayah Sheikh Shuraim, although quite amazing, is that even allowed?
He came where I live and I think he's going to lead taraweeh this year in one of our local Masjid...
sis why saad nomani when orignal reciters are available , once i showed u one Shaikh Shuraim's clip , u tell me can he recites like him ur answer will be noway, ok wait for few min i am gonna post Shaikh Sudais clip in imams thread watch the clip and tell me .
Ya Allah.........come on sheikh shuraim overall his simply the best...have got his collections of CD...alhamdulilah downloaded it......i was referring to all the recitors...
plus at the end there all imams, shud be happy and glad...his copying him or following his footsteps.....
All i hope is for my mums happiness.Shes my light.Shes my dunya.Her tears are my weakness.Her sadness breaks my heart.She is my mirror.A mirror that keeps me alive.Without her am nothing.shes my saaya.How can i leave her.I pray to Allah(swt) to keep me with her forever inshAllah.
Ya Allah.........come on sheikh shuraim overall his simply the best...have got his collections of CD...alhamdulilah downloaded it......i was referring to all the recitors...
plus at the end there all imams, shud be happy and glad...his copying him or following his footsteps.....
anywaz is it allowed to imitate while leading prayers ???
well..wallahi i dunno...am new to this all...listening to recitors.....that why am not joining imams haramain thread....i'll be lost.....
All i hope is for my mums happiness.Shes my light.Shes my dunya.Her tears are my weakness.Her sadness breaks my heart.She is my mirror.A mirror that keeps me alive.Without her am nothing.shes my saaya.How can i leave her.I pray to Allah(swt) to keep me with her forever inshAllah.
All i hope is for my mums happiness.Shes my light.Shes my dunya.Her tears are my weakness.Her sadness breaks my heart.She is my mirror.A mirror that keeps me alive.Without her am nothing.shes my saaya.How can i leave her.I pray to Allah(swt) to keep me with her forever inshAllah.
not all
they all r great imams ,one has too work really hard to copy them. i dont want to hurt anyones feeling here but i dont know why people like saad numani.
And when he tries to copy great reciters :grumbling(anyways thats my personal opinion)
lol hey even i would like to copy those great recitors only difference is numani can DO IT lol
-
My tears testify that i have a heart
yet i feel me and shaytan never part
-
no bro i am not saying that saad nomai is doing shirk or something ( as i dont know that he imitates while leading salah or not).
What i am saying that i was listening to Dr.Israr Ahmeds lecture Hakekat O Iqasam Shirk and Dr.Israr was telling about types of shirk and the thing u mentioned in ur post
(zAK -i read its not allowed while leading prayers.
coz tht diverts ur mind frm Allah swt to the person u r tryin to imitate.
u lose ur khushoo) Allahu A'lam
according to Dr.Israr Ahmed its a form of Shirk.maybe i have made some mistake in understanding the lecture , correct me if i am wrong.
u can download the lectures from here .its also available in english on the same site.
I understand your point, but remember that he is a Madani. While Madani's are not free of error, we should be careful of showing negative feelings towards them as they live in a place where our beloved Nabi (Salallahu Alayhi Wasallam) and many of his companions (Radiallahu Anhum) lay. Not like I'm saying we should negative feelings to other Muslims, so I hope you get me.
Secondly, is he a sheikh? Or no..? Either way, I'm sure he knows whether it is allowed or not to imitate in salah. It could be a difference of opinion, and he might not be on the wrong. Either that, or he is using the fact that you should recite in a beautiful tone, therefore it is okay. http://islamqa.com/index.php?ref=261...ur%E2%80%99aan
To be honest with you, I never heard it was not permissable to imitate during salah. Especially considering that my brother tends to imitate Sheikh Jabir (Rahimahullah)...
Give him the benefit of the doubt.
"...You are my Walî in this world and in the Hereafter. Cause me to die as a Muslim, and join me with the righteous." [Surah Yusuf 101]
I understand your point, but remember that he is a Madani. While Madani's are not free of error, we should be careful of showing negative feelings towards them as they live in a place where our beloved Nabi (Salallahu Alayhi Wasallam) and many of his companions (Radiallahu Anhum) lay. Not like I'm saying we should negative feelings to other Muslims, so I hope you get me.
Secondly, is he a sheikh? Or no..? Either way, I'm sure he knows whether it is allowed or not to imitate in salah. It could be a difference of opinion, and he might not be on the wrong. Either that, or he is using the fact that you should recite in a beautiful tone, therefore it is okay. http://islamqa.com/index.php?ref=261...ur%E2%80%99aan
To be honest with you, I never heard it was not permissable to imitate during salah. Especially considering that my brother tends to imitate Sheikh Jabir (Rahimahullah)...
Give him the benefit of the doubt.
i belive he is a pakistani living in pakistan bro MST told me once (when i was in pakistan i asked about Saad Nomaani in few madrsa's they dont know him , they were like who is Saad Nomani, i played his imitation in front of few qari's and they were..... anywaz this is another story).
As for islamqa answers . this is about beautiful reciation not imitation.
imitation in salah , there is noway u can imitate someone without thinking about his voice ,for example if u are imitating SAS no matter what u do SAS will be present somewhere in ur mind .
i have heard somewhere and also i remember one sister also posted this on Li
not sure if it is a hadith or not.
it was somthing like
( pray like you can see Allah ( or in front Allah) ,if you cant see him remember Allah is watching you).
is it possible while imitating
if yes then from tommorow ill start imitating SS in fajar SST in zuhar and Asar ( dont know how but ill do it in takbeer) , SAS in Maghrib and SMS in Isha
Ah, okay, I read in a few places that he is from Madeenah while originally his parents are Pakistani, and just believed it. I should have confirmed. Apologies.
Regarding imitation, I guess that is up to the imaam. If his mind wanders off and looses concentration, than obviously he shouldn't imitate. I'll ask relatives who tend to imitate, about it, and I'll ask a sheikh if there is room to imitate inshaAllah.
I can't remember who said that: pray like you can see Allah ( or in front Allah) ,if you cant see him remember Allah is watching you. But I do remember reading it.
"...You are my Walî in this world and in the Hereafter. Cause me to die as a Muslim, and join me with the righteous." [Surah Yusuf 101]
Hey there! Looks like you're enjoying the discussion, but you're not signed up for an account.
When you create an account, we remember exactly what you've read, so you always come right back where you left off. You also get notifications, here and via email, whenever new posts are made. And you can like posts and share your thoughts. Sign Up
[pie][/pie]
:grumbling(anyways thats my personal opinion)
lol hey even i would like to copy those great recitors
Hide
Looks like you're enjoying the discussion, but you're not signed up for an account.
Posting Permissions
Bookmarks