Why Jesus and not Muhammad(pbut)

**Tony** · 07-09-2009

Following a discussion with my Christian neighbour I would like to know if there is any explanation as to why Jesus is coming back rather than Muhammad (pbuh). The guy talks for 80 pc of the time and usually contradicts himself, when he does listen he then replies and usually contradicts further, however he raised a good point that I had no answer for. If Muhammad (pbuh) was the last prophet, why is it Jesus (pbuh) that will return ? Whilst I am sure there is a good reason for it I dont know what it is. So please before this thread descends into a mind numbing and tedious debate that actually serves no purpose, would the members of this forum please allow my question to be answered first, thanks in advance

**JOHNJOHN** · 04-17-2011

Hi Hamza81

For you Jesus is still alive, I was looking for all the verses about Jesus in the Quran and I have find one, could you please explain me :

Surah 19. Mary

31. "And He hath made me blessed wheresoever I be, and hath enjoined on me Prayer and Charity as long as I live

If jesus is alive then he is giving charity ? the question he si giving charity to who ?

**Ghazalah** · 04-17-2011

Originally Posted by JOHNJOHN

"And He hath made me blessed wheresoever I be, and hath enjoined on me Prayer and Charity as long as I live

If jesus is alive then he is giving charity ? the question he si giving charity to who ?

Vast majority of Mufasireen have said Isa (AS) is referring to when he is alive in this World.

**JOHNJOHN** · 04-17-2011

Originally Posted by Ghazalah

Vast majority of Mufasireen have said Isa (AS) is referring to when he is alive in this World.

Hi Ghazalah,

You are saying that there are 2 words.

- here until jesus die in this world

- Hereafter

Where is jesus in this world or in another world ?

Read again the verse and tell me where do you see its about his life on earh ?

**Ghazalah** · 04-17-2011

Let me rephrase... The ayah states "And He hath made me blessed wheresoever I be, and hath enjoined on me Prayer and Charity as long as I live" now many have asked the same question as you, and mufasireen have stated he is talking about his life on Earth, i.e. praying to Allah and giving Charity. Hope that makes sense.

**JOHNJOHN** · 04-17-2011

Originally Posted by Ghazalah

Let me rephrase... The ayah states "And He hath made me blessed wheresoever I be, and hath enjoined on me Prayer and Charity as long as I live" now many have asked the same question as you, and mufasireen have stated he is talking about his life on Earth, i.e. praying to Allah and giving Charity. Hope that makes sense.

Thank you I understand then he is in hereafter and his life in the world is finish no ?

But he is alive and on the day of resurrection he will be already alive and god does need to bring him to life no ?

I do not understand really, he is alive but his life in this world is finish but he will come back to finish his life ?

sorry but Is confusing

**Ghazalah** · 04-17-2011

Originally Posted by JOHNJOHN

But he is alive and on the day of resurrection he will be already alive and god does need to bring him to life no ?

Nope, he will come back soon inshAllah he will live for 40 years, then he shall die. His appearance back in this world is a major sign of Judgement day. So on the Day of Resurrection Allah SWT will bring him back to life.

Make sense now?

**JOHNJOHN** · 04-18-2011

Originally Posted by Ghazalah

Nope, he will come back soon inshAllah he will live for 40 years, then he shall die. His appearance back in this world is a major sign of Judgement day. So on the Day of Resurrection Allah SWT will bring him back to life.

Make sense now?

Hi Ghazalah,

- How do you know that he will live 40 years

- How do you know he will be a major sign of judgement day

Did you see it in the quran or somewhere ?