Re: Please help remove images and falsehood from the page about prophet muhammad(saw)
Why should Wikipedia remove images of Muhammad? Wikipedia is not subject to Islamic law.
And as snakelegs pointed out, Muhammad was often portrayed in Islamic art anyway. Why don't you urge Muslims to destroy all these paintings, while you're at it.
Re: Please help remove images and falsehood from the page about prophet muhammad(saw)
Brother you cant go destroying all the paintings, carpets, canvas etc that his images were made or painted on.
Besides none of those pictures are alike because none of them lived in his time to know what he looked like.
All you can do with wikipedia is let them know its not right in Islam to make depictions of the profit and if they could kindly take it down since its insulting.
There are more important things in your life and within you to worry about.
Re: Please help remove images and falsehood from the page about prophet muhammad(saw)
Wikipedia should honor the petition because the imagery is insulting to a large number of the earths population, Are you saying that all non-Islamic organizations have the right to insult Islam?
And excuse me for asking, But why on earth do you care either way? Your an athiest right? Your two posts in this thread are arrogant and if we were in a real life situation, Im sure I wouldnt take kindly to your tone of voice...
Re: Please help remove images and falsehood from the page about prophet muhammad(saw)
format_quote Originally Posted by Talib_Rayhan
Wikipedia should honor the petition because the imagery is insulting to a large number of the earths population,
So what?
Are you saying that all non-Islamic organizations have the right to insult Islam?
Of course! Just as Islamic organizations have the right to insult non-Islamic organizations if they so choose.
And excuse me for asking, But why on earth do you care either way? Your an athiest right?
Atheists don't care about things?
Your two posts in this thread are arrogant and if we were in a real life situation, Im sure I wouldnt take kindly to your tone of voice...
I actually think if we were talking in real life, you wouldn't get the impression that I'm being arrogant at all. I think I write more forcefully than I talk, which sometimes gives the impression of arrogance where none is intended.
Re: Please help remove images and falsehood from the page about prophet muhammad(saw)
format_quote Originally Posted by Qingu
Why should Wikipedia remove images of Muhammad? Wikipedia is not subject to Islamic law.
And as snakelegs pointed out, Muhammad was often portrayed in Islamic art anyway. Why don't you urge Muslims to destroy all these paintings, while you're at it.
IT is not Islamic art, its PERSIAN! nothing, nothing to do with Islam, get your facts str8 !
Bloody persians can't even draw, they got the description all wrong.. first the buraq and now this, its just nasty, im starting to hate them...
Last edited by DAWUD_adnan; 12-22-2007 at 05:09 AM.
Re: Please help remove images and falsehood from the page about prophet muhammad(saw)
Greetings,
format_quote Originally Posted by Isambard
When unable to reply, resort to an ad hominem. Nice tactic
It's a tactic that's gaining popularity all the time, it seems. It's a real shame that there are so many people here who genuinely haven't got a clue how to discuss things productively. Still, there are a lot of kids on the forum - they're still learning, so perhaps we ought to give them a break.
Re: Please help remove images and falsehood from the page about prophet muhammad(saw)
I'm from Iran (or a Persian as called in the previous posts). I don't think offending another nation's history, art and literature, especially an Islamic nation, does any help. Us muslims have enough enemies in the world as it is, why turn on each other instead of being united and like brothers and sisters?
I am against paintings and portraits of the prophet also, but you must also think that the painter is not offending the prophet. Maybe it was his love for him that made him express his love to the prophet by drawing a painting?
Hey there! Looks like you're enjoying the discussion, but you're not signed up for an account.
When you create an account, we remember exactly what you've read, so you always come right back where you left off. You also get notifications, here and via email, whenever new posts are made. And you can like posts and share your thoughts.
Sign Up
Bookmarks