What is the fate of a murdered non muslim? Is their life compensated?

Quote:

Originally Posted by samirbrazendale

Asalaamualaykum Dear Lupus From Ummah Forum.

You have asked the same question on UF on the 28/04/17 and had many responses.

You leave me no choice but to simply repeat myself as it seems you have repeated the question.

https://www.islamicboard.com/ Originally Posted by Lupus https://www.islamicboard.com/
I was wondering, someone told me this about a murdered person

I already told you, the life which is taken before it's time, via murder - is compensated by Allah in the afterlife, according to the way the non believer lived their life - they are also (according to some scholars) given a type of test which will determine their status in the afterlife - ie: hell fire or heaven. So again - here you find Mercy of Allah is prevalent, and Allah says in the Qur'an that HE does not judge any soul unfairly - and HE is the best judge of what is fair and what is not.

Is this true?

Asalaamualaykum

It is false based on you the very pretext that the argument is built upon.

No person passes away "before" their time. By saying just part itself is already an indication of the lack of understanding regarding the sifath of Allah SWT. By saying a life is taken "before" its time you are insinuating that Allah SWT designated a time - then via some miracle that life got taken before the designated point. This cannot be true as Allah SWT designates when a person will be a born and when a person will pass away....and that WILL HAPPEN AS HE HAS ORDAINED. So a life cannot go before its time as that what we perceive is taken before its time IS actually that designated time which Allah SWT has appointed in the first place.

You friend needs to read and understand the entire Asmanul Husnah and inshAllah educate themselves about the complete sifath of Allah SWT.

Wasalaam.

https://www.islamicboard.com/ Originally Posted by Lupus https://www.islamicboard.com/
I was wondering, someone told me this about a murdered person

I already told you, the life which is taken before it's time, via murder - is compensated by Allah in the afterlife, according to the way the non believer lived their life - they are also (according to some scholars) given a type of test which will determine their status in the afterlife - ie: hell fire or heaven. So again - here you find Mercy of Allah is prevalent, and Allah says in the Qur'an that HE does not judge any soul unfairly - and HE is the best judge of what is fair and what is not.

Is this true?

Asalaamualaykum

It is false based on you the very pretext that the argument is built upon.

No person passes away "before" their time. By saying just part itself is already an indication of the lack of understanding regarding the sifath of Allah SWT. By saying a life is taken "before" its time you are insinuating that Allah SWT designated a time - then via some miracle that life got taken before the designated point. This cannot be true as Allah SWT designates when a person will be a born and when a person will pass away....and that WILL HAPPEN AS HE HAS ORDAINED. So a life cannot go before its time as that what we perceive is taken before its time IS actually that designated time which Allah SWT has appointed in the first place.

You friend needs to read and understand the entire Asmanul Husnah and inshAllah educate themselves about the complete sifath of Allah SWT.

Wasalaam.

@Scimitar, here is a refutation of your claim.