Re: Masjid Al Aqsa under attack right now!!!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
wiomuslims
Coming to Democracy,
Islam does encourage selecting people through majority of interest. However, it is considered only where the governance is Islamic. However, Islam believes in the concept of Khilafah, where there is one leader for all Muslims. He should be selected on based on the love of Allah and his intention to make Islam better only for the sake of Allah. Hence, we do not consider other political system appropriate. Though we have to believe in such system if we are staying in any such country. When the khilafah is being transferred to other leader, even here the things which are considered are his love for religion for the sake of Allah. It should not be transferred based on heritage of children, relatives or friends.
Common people cannot vote for khalifa. Only scholars are allowed to, because they know who will be able to control the state. Try not to give wrong knowledge to people who want to learn about islam. Plus i didnt even read your whole posts. Open the mushaf and READ.
Defensive j*had doesnt need islamic governance or imam, offensive does. If someone is attacking your house, are you gonna search for imam or defend yourself?
And one last sincere advice, Read about life of prophet. Be careful akhi while making assumptions about his doings.
I am fed up of justifying all of it. So this will be my last post on this thread, in sha Allah, unless it is a necessity to involve in discussion.
Quote:
Hence, we do not consider other political system appropriate. Though we have to believe in such system if we are staying in any such country.
Correct your aqeedah!
Say, " Allah is most knowing of how long they remained. He has [knowledge of] the unseen [aspects] of the heavens and the earth. How Seeing is He and how Hearing! They have not besides Him any protector, and He shares not His legislation with anyone."(18:26)
Re: Masjid Al Aqsa under attack right now!!!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Yrvhere?
Common people cannot vote for khalifa. Only scholars are allowed to, because they know who will be able to control the state. Try not to give wrong knowledge to people who want to learn about islam. Plus i didnt even read your whole posts. Open the mushaf and READ.
Defensive j*had doesnt need islamic governance or imam, offensive does. If someone is attacking your house, are you gonna search for imam or defend yourself?
And one last sincere advice, Read about life of prophet. Be careful akhi while making assumptions about his doings.
I am fed up of justifying all of it. So this will be my last post on this thread, in sha Allah, unless it is a necessity to involve in discussion.
Correct your aqeedah!
Say, " Allah is most knowing of how long they remained. He has [knowledge of] the unseen [aspects] of the heavens and the earth. How Seeing is He and how Hearing! They have not besides Him any protector, and He shares not His legislation with anyone."(18:26)
:sl:
I do understand your emotions sister. It's typical these days. Once we made up mind based on our assumption. Then we don't care what other's are saying even if it has been the view of majority of scholars. And who told you only scholars are allowed to select the Khalifa? And do you know the ruling of selecting the Khalifah? In Islam, before taking any decision. An Amir is appointed, who is deemed fit to take the decision. Then based on the discussion and capabilities, the Khalifa is appointed. The decision of Amir can be against majority of people and it can be accordingly to the people. The people have to accept it any cost. Unless the decision goes against the tenants of Islam.
And I never spoke about defensive J*had. I discussed about the ruling of J*had in general. And you saying that you didn't read the complete post itself is a sign that you are not here to understand. I guess, you might have made up mind that anyone who talks sense doesn't understand Islam.
And coming to Aqeedah.. hope this Mufti is not a fool in your eyes:
https://daruliftaa.com/miscellaneous...d-in-the-west/
Re: Masjid Al Aqsa under attack right now!!!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
wiomuslims
And coming to Aqeedah.. hope this Mufti is not a fool in your eyes:
I am showing you the ayah of Quran and you giving me this F A T A W A. In the hadith, it never mentioned that you have to obey the ruler who goes against QURAN AND SUNNAH.
https://www.islamicboard.com/general...ml#post3040971
Akhi, we shouldnt speak without knowledge. Abu bakr (ra) wasnt selected by the voting of people. Only best people were there when the meeting was held. So there are other ways as well through which khalifa is chosen. I havent made any assumptions nor am i speaking from my desires. And okay you were telling about jih-d in general but i was talking about defensive one throughout the thread. And yes, prophet did say during the conquest of makkah that he did not want any bloodshed. But what about the battles before? Have we forgotten that? There were a great number of gazwaat and sariya that took place. And in most of them, muslims were victorious. This is the reason quraish of makkah didnt do anything during the conquest because they knew muslims are greater in number and they are gonna win so they left their authority. This is what i wanted to say. In these times, if you go any government and say" Leave this authority for I am going to be khalifa here and establish Allah's laws" How would they react? They are gonna fight you because they know you dont have any power and you dont have any army of soldiers with you. Hence, I am saying study the seerah properly. So yeah, this was necessary to tell. Wont reply further in sha Allah. But as you are a muslim and a brother in islam, its my obligation to tell you that study the seerah carefully and read about the system of khilafah as well. And read the Quran as well. YOU NEED TO UNDERSTAND QURAN .ALL THE BEST AKHI.
_____________________
But one last thing for all the muslims, we will be victorious soon, biiznillah. Khil"fah will be revived and we will lead the world, soon in sha Allah. Allah has promised victory. May we live till that time to see our beloved deen victorious :)
