need your opinions

salam alaikum

well I was trying my hand at making an e-card today and its an Eid E-card in flash...

its just a test thingie but anyways....

The thing that I need your opinion on is that is it approriate for me to use the music I have in the card?

I wanted to give it a "festive touch" and remembered the hadith of the Prophet "Let them sing, every nation has its eid and this is ours"
So I guess just for festivity would this music be alowed?

Please keep in mind I have not had the chance to add a preloader to the flash file so on slower connections it may take a little time to load...but its not that big about 280 KB
Thanks

Music is harram. period.

How bout qur'an???

You dont have to have music.

SaLaMz

On Eid you are allowed Music and furthermore all forms of Music are not prohibited in Islam

I have never heard that on eid music is allowed

So on eid wine is allowed??????????

If it is prophibited for a reason then why is it that on eid we can do it???

Tht makes no sense to me.

Plz explain

SaLaMz

I don't think its a good idea to put music. Maybe if you post something like recititations or nasheeds then they will be a whole lot better insha'Allah.


Barakallahu Feekum.

Well bro there is the Hadith regarding where the girls were singing in the presence of the Prophet(sa) and Abu Bakr (ra) came in and said "the instruments of the satan in the Prophets presence?" And the Prophet (sa) stopped him and said, "Every nation has its eid and this is ours"

I will try and get the correct references for this hadith for u in case u havent heard this before but its a very famou one bro...

akulion said:

Well bro there is the Hadith regarding where the girls were singing in the presence of the Prophet(sa) and Abu Bakr (ra) came in and said "the instruments of the satan in the Prophets presence?" And the Prophet (sa) stopped him and said, "Every nation has its eid and this is ours"

I will try and get the correct references for this hadith for u in case u havent heard this before but its a very famou one bro...

Click to expand...

Ok thanxs for the proof

And one more thing:

Im a woman!!!!!!lol

SaLaMz

Ok I dug up the proper ruling regarding this music issue on Eid

Fiqh-us-Sunnah
Fiqh 2.153

Playing, amusements, singing, and eating on the days of 'id

Recreation, amusements, and singing, if they stay within the moral bounds, are permissible on the days of 'id.

Anas reports: "When the Prophet came to Medinah they had two days of sport and amusement. The Prophet said: "Allah, the Exalted, has exchanged these days for two days better than them: the day of breaking the fast and the day of sacrifice." This is related by an-Nasa'i and Ibn Hibban with a sahih chain.
'Aishah says: "The Abyssinians were preforming in the mosque on the day of 'id. I looked over the Prophet's shoulders and he lowered them a little so I could see them until I was satisfied and left." This is related by Ahmad, al-Bukhari, and Muslim.

Ahmad, al-Bukhari, and Muslim also record that she said: "Abu Bakr entered upon us on the day of 'id and there were some slave girls who were recounting [in song the battle of] Bu'ath in which many of the brave of the tribes of Aus and Khazraj were killed. Abu Bakr said: 'Slaves of Allah, you play the pipes of the Satan!' He said it three times. The Prophet said to him: 'O Abu Bakr, every people have a festival and this is our festival."' In al-Bukhari's version, 'Aishah said: "The Messenger of Allah, entered the house and I had two girls who were singing about the battle of Bu'ath. The Prophet lied down on the bed and turned his face to the other direction. Abu Bakr entered and spoke harshly to me, 'Musical instruments of the Satan in the presence of the Messenger of Allah!' The Messenger of Allah turned his face to him and said: 'Leave them.' When Abu Bakr became inattentive I signaled to the girls to leave. It was the day of 'id and the Africans were performing with their shields and spears. Either I asked him or the Prophet asked if I would like to watch them [I don't recall now]. I replied in the affirmative. At this the Prophet made me stand behind him and my cheek was against his. He was saying: 'Carry on, O tribe of Arfadah,' until I tired. The Prophet asked: 'Is that enough for you?' I replied: "yes," so he said: 'Leave [then].'"

Ibn Hajar writes in Fath al-Bari, "Ibn as-Siraj related from Abu az-Zinad on the authority of 'Urwah from 'Aishah that the Prophet said that day: 'Let the Jews of Medinah know that our religion is spacious [and has room for relaxation] and I have been sent with an easy and straight forward religion. "'

Ahmad and Muslim record from Nubaishah that the Prophet sallallahu alehi wasallam said: "The days of tashriq (i.e., the days in which the 'id is celebrated) are days of eating and drinking [non alcoholic drinks] and of remembering Allah, the Exalted."


--------------------------------------------------------

So keeping that in mind can you please give me some opinions?

Because to be honest I really like that music its so festive perfect for eid

ps: lol sorry sis jihad I hardly ever check genders...i always call everyone bro...so sorry i said bro - sis

LOL

Well it depends...if ur going for a westernized approach, then urrrmmmmmm. The board wont allow western music, e.g. love songs, songs with rubbish lyrics.

but nasheeds are a must!!!!!

I love Eids

I always stay up all night and days!!

So much fun

Yes I guess thats Spanish / Italian 'fiesta' type of Music....

Does anyone know of any festive nasheeds which I could use instead?

O.k but you dont possibly mean the ones they play today....do you???

I mean its crazy....and ummmm..inappropriate

SaLaMz

Well:

Zain Bikha, Sami Yusuf, yusuf Islam (miss out 786) all have festive nasheeds

• The majority of Muslim scholars prohibit music and musical instruments. It is mentioned in Sahîh al-Bukhâri that Abû Mâlik al-Ash`arî said: “I heard the Prophet (peace be upon him) say: “There will be a group of my people who will legalize for themselves adultery, pure silk, intoxicants, and stringed instruments."

• The Prophet (peace be upon him) said: “I was ordered to avoid two foolish and vile sounds; a sound of a musical tunes and Satan’s musical instruments, and cries made on account of a calamity.” [Sunan al-Tirmidhî]

• The only exception to this ruling is the duff, a tambourine without bells, which only women are allowed to use among themselves as an accompaniment to their singing at weddings and on other festive occasions. This was permitted by the Prophet (peace be upon him).

source:www.islamtoday.com

MashAllah i mean maybe the hadith that the brother just gave was
Abragatod(Changed or has no meaning or does not count)

Just as the one about asma about her covering her body
and the only thing that she can show is the face and hands.

That hadith was abragatoed because the verse about the woman covering
Everything was sent down.

Maybe the same goes for the one the brother just gave.
Allah knowz best.

SaLaMz

we don't know that sister.....Allah knows, but we should look at the ra'wee (chain of narrators)

the article I gave you is a direct Quote from Fiqh (Islamic Law)

So I dont know how the rulings of Islamonline.com can over rule Fiqh since Fiqh is something that which under an Islamic state would be the Law

Hmmmm....interesting......

looks like we're gonna have to do a bit of research on the 2 ahadeeth

Music is a very controversial issue in Islam over which the scholars are not all in agreement. It has already been discussed here but as Ansar said, this forum is not for prolonged fiqh discussions.

Ansar said:

As mentioned in the forum rules, this forum is not for prolonged fiqh discussions. Music is a controversial topic within Islam and there are differences of opinion amongst Muslims that I wouldn't expect to disappear. Everyone has to follow what they believe is most in accordance with the Qur'an and Sunnah, as understood by the early pious generation of Muslims. We do not simply follow what is in accordance with our desires.

Before I close this thread, I would like to re-iterate what I have said previously about the consensus of Muslim scholars on this issue. Scholars would agree that profane music or music that incites one to do evil (as is most prominent in the western music industry) or music that promotes immorality - all these are haraam. Scholars would also agree that simple vocal songs (nasheeds) calling one to Allah swt or reminding one of the truth, that these are permissable. Between these two categories there is a large grey area. So let every individual focus on what will benefit them in the afterlife.

For more information:
http://www.islamicboard.com/showpost...&postcount=194

Click to expand...

For what it's worth, I agree that instruments are haraam. This book analyses the Qur'an and ahadith and includes a section on Exceptions to the Rule of Prohibition as Indicated by the Authentic Sunnah



P.S. Zain Bhikha's Eid Nasheed is good. I forgot what it's called. :brother:

also the prophet (s.a.w) said that all women had to have the face covered infront of men at all times their are onky allowed to show they face to their husbands and their family members like brothers father uncle

i totally agree that music like madonna michela jackson and all those are totally haram

but my question is is the music in the e-card suitable for EID

since on Eid we are allowed to be festive and celebrate as long as we stay within bounds of decency

And i dont believe anyone viewing that e-card will throw a wild party with that e-card playing in the background lol