External Influences

  • Thread starter Thread starter aamirsaab
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 43
  • Views Views 7K
aamirsaab

aamirsaab

On vacation.
Messages
4,459
Reaction score
1,229
Gender
Male
Religion
Islam
:sl:
Just a quick question: Do aethiests accept external influences? I.e. chance, coincidence, luck etc.
 
Since the term atheist only refers to a persons beliefs concerning God I don't think it would make any sense to try assess, as a group, their beliefs on a different subject.
 
Greetings,

I use words like 'luck', 'coincidence' and 'chance' all the time, but I don't believe that they are forces that exist independently of human minds. They are concepts that we have invented in order to help explain to each other our attitudes towards certain events.

Peace
 
:sl:
czgibson said:
Greetings,

I use words like 'luck', 'coincidence' and 'chance' all the time, but I don't believe that they are forces that exist independently of human minds. They are concepts that we have invented in order to help explain to each other our attitudes towards certain events.

Peace
Click to expand...

That's exactly the answer I wanted to hear. I'll wait for a few more responses until I unveil my master plan. Tee hee hee.

Azy said:
Since the term atheist only refers to a persons beliefs concerning God I don't think it would make any sense to try assess, as a group, their beliefs on a different subject.
Click to expand...
Perhaps but I am interested if there are any atheists that don't believe in external influences. As I said though, I will await for a few more responses to reveal all.
 
Last edited:
I don't quite understand the question? In what sense is chance, coincidence, luck and "external influence"? External to what, reality, my life, poker?

Do I believe that chance, coincidence, luck exist? Yes I do in on the basis that it is a description of the gaussian/chaotic nature of the universe and our uncertain view of it.

Thanks.
 
Gator said:
I don't quite understand the question? In what sense is chance, coincidence, luck and "external influence"? External to what, reality, my life, poker?

Do I believe that chance, coincidence, luck exist? Yes I do in on the basis that it is a description of the gaussian/chaotic nature of the universe and our uncertain view of it.

Thanks.
Click to expand...

External in this context means that you have no control over it. i.e. ''ohhh I'm so lucky, I found a pound coin.''

Basically I want to know if aethiests accept there are things outside of their control. My initial assumption is yes, but this is an investigation and I need results! :p
 
Not really. I think it's random.
I'm highly disorganised and chaotic, my life is therefore full of muckups and disasters. I have noone to blame for this but myself.
If something happened that was unavoidable but not influenced by me then it would merely be a part of a chain of events.

A man passes a freind in the street and smiles. His mate smiles back. A passerby sees the mate smiling and, due to her being paranoid, thinks the bloke is checking her out. She moves to the opposite side of the pavement. this causes a mother with a pram to have to swerve cos she is texting as she pushes and dosnt spot the woman till the last second. The pram crashes into a lamppost, a driver sees it and rubbernecks to look. thus he slows down, the bus behind him slows down and just misses the green traffic light changing.
A bomb goes off next to the bus killing the person who in five years from now might have bumped into me knocking me into the path of a car spraining my ankle.

Is the Guy who smiled at his mate, part of my fate?
 
czgibson said:
Greetings,

I use words like 'luck', 'coincidence' and 'chance' all the time, but I don't believe that they are forces that exist independently of human minds. They are concepts that we have invented in order to help explain to each other our attitudes towards certain events.

Peace
Click to expand...


I don't think anyone, save an ontological realist, would try to claim probability theorems are pre-existing, metaphysical entities, however that dosen't mean chance is simply a human construction(as English is an artificial construction to describe real thoughts), perhapse the mathematical system used to describe the likelehood that X will happen is a human construction, however like physics equations it is describing a real phenomena, not like a rainbow perhapse, bu8t probability theory does describe the likelehood a given event will "happen" more or less.
 
:sl:
Simple answers folks! We can get technical after!

Still awaiting a few more. Like ranma's and whatsthepoint.
 
wth1257 said:
I don't think anyone, save an ontological realist, would try to claim probability theorems are pre-existing, metaphysical entities, however that dosen't mean chance is simply a human construction(as English is an artificial construction to describe real thoughts), perhapse the mathematical system used to describe the likelehood that X will happen is a human construction, however like physics equations it is describing a real phenomena, not like a rainbow perhapse, bu8t probability theory does describe the likelehood a given event will "happen" more or less.
Click to expand...


Gahhrgh! I Need to drink less beer and study theology more!
 
Yes, there are many things beyond my control. In fact, i'd say most events that take place on earth, nevermind the universe at large, are beyond my control. But I'm humble like that. heh.
 
aamirsaab said:
:sl:
Just a quick question: Do aethiests accept external influences? I.e. chance, coincidence, luck etc.
Click to expand...

depends on the atheists. atheism deals only with the existence of god/s.


i myself accept that we are influenced by things outside ourselves.

chance:yes. things happen and chance is just the statical happening.
coincidence: yes same as above.
luck: yes, not as a magical thing but as the same as above.

I find a 100 bill in the grass. "my lucky day!!!"
did some magical being or influence cause it intentionaly for my benefit, no.
 
Last edited:
Gator said:
I am tingly with anticipation! Hurry up 1/2 and WTP! Should we PM them?
Click to expand...
Pming them is fine. I'd really like their answers on this topic. It's not particularly important but for my own benefit - I'm very curious! :p.

ranma1/2 said:
depends on the atheists. atheism deals only with the existence of god/s.


i myself accept that we are influenced by things outside ourselves.

chance:yes. things happen and chance is just the statical happening.
coincidence: yes same as above.
luck: yes, not as a magical thing but as the same as above.

I find a 100 bill in the grass. "my lucky day!!!"
did some magical being or influence cause it intentionaly for my benefit, no.
Click to expand...
Ok just to clarify this I'm simply asking do you believe that there are things that happen but are out of your control. A simple yes or no will do for now. We'll get to the technical/fun stuff very soon.

Oh and for the benefit of any late comers to this thread: My assumption is that aethiests do believe in external forces. I simply wish to confirm this (at least on some level). Upon confirmation (or not) I'll start getting technical.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top