I haven't spent much time with Yahya's work to really give you a learned opinion.
from the few I have browsed I believe his work should be aimed at a younger audience.
by that I mean it is written in easy enough language and he doesn't get into too much scientific detail. That isn't to say what his writing is untrue.. but it isn't very technical and at times more emotional than factual...
in fact can be comparable to his nemesis dawkin only from the opposite end of the spectrum. Here is a man who abuses the laurels that accompany his name to promote his own religion. Actually it should be more frowned upon since Yahya doesn't claim a doctorate, rather research outside of academia.
I think it is a privilege to have earned a high degree, but with it comes responsibility.. and I find many of these so-called scientists abusing their chair, for instance 'blacks are indeed inferior due to their genetics' according to Dr. Watson
http://entertainment.timesonline.co....cle2630748.ece
Not only untrue but an abomination to bank on an area of your studies to promote your own personal hateful agenda. Scientists/Doctors aren't above human error, but worst than committing error is furthering it for evil. I believe those people should be stripped of their title for doing so.
Best to write it as free lance, under the heading of personal opinion rather than putting it under the umbrella of science!
Allah knows best
:w: