qn about Barsisa, The Worshipper

U

Ummu Sufyaan

is in need of dua
Messages
7,926
Reaction score
1,403
Gender
Female
Religion
Islam
:sl:
i would like to know from which scholar and book this story has been derived from? any ideas?
 
:sl:

At least, there are two versions of story about Barsisa. The difference is in the beginning of these stories. But if version that you mean is the version which Barsisa became 'tabib' who cured disease, this was narrated by Ibn Abbas r.a.
 
what about bashira the christian monk? did he really see the mark of prophethood on rasulullah?
 
aadil77 said:
JazakhAllah khair, but do we have any hadith confirming this story? what was the original source for it?
Click to expand...
Wa iyakum.

There is long hadith about this story that narrated by Jumhur Ulama Sirah, and clasified as Sahih (authentic) by Imam Tirmidzi.
 
To Ummu Sufyaan.

Sorry if this thread has been derailed.
Okay, now we back to story about Barsisa, a worshipper who died as kafir.
 
:sl:
Okay, now we back to story about Barsisa, a worshipper who died as kafir.
Click to expand...
yes, what is the exact source of this story? what book has it been taken from, and who is the author of that book?
 
ardianto said:
:sl:

At least, there are two versions of story about Barsisa. The difference is in the beginning of these stories. But if version that you mean is the version which Barsisa became 'tabib' who cured disease, this was narrated by Ibn Abbas r.a.
Click to expand...
I found third version of this story and I guess I will find fourth, fifth, ..... versions.
 
Ummu Sufyaan said:
:sl:

yes, what is the exact source of this story? what book has it been taken from, and who is the author of that book?
Click to expand...
There are few versions of this story and maybe (or must be) these stories were written in more than one book by more than one author.

But my current conclusion, the original version of story of Barsisa the worshipper is a story from Bani Israil during pre-Islam periode, or even from period before the birth of Christ.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top