Taqdeer/Fate Concept in Islam

  • Thread starter Thread starter yasirslm
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 15
  • Views Views 6K
yasirslm

yasirslm

Esteemed Member
Messages
179
Reaction score
7
Gender
Male
Religion
Islam
Dear Brothers/Sisters

:sl:


I am a little bit confused about the concept of Human Taqdeer/Fate as whenever some incident happens to a person like car accident and he dies, people say it was written in his Taqdeer/Fate.

Some people say that Human Taqdeer/Fate is predefined and human acts(Good/Bad) play a major role over Human Taqdeer/Fate.


Expert opinion is required in light of references.

Thanks and Regards.
 
I'm no expert but this hadith will guide you to some extent.And Inshallah some knowledgeable person will explain the matter to you Inshallah.

Narrated Anas bin Malik: The Prophet said,

"Allah has appointed an angel in the womb, and the angel says, 'O Lord! A drop of discharge (i.e. of semen), O Lord! a clot, O Lord! a piece of flesh.' And then, if Allah wishes to complete the child's creation, the angel will say. 'O Lord! A male or a female? O Lord! wretched or blessed (in religion)? What will his livelihood be? What will his age be?' The angel writes all this while the child is in the womb of its mother."
Bukhari / Book 4 / Volume 55 / Hadith 550
 
Let me give you an example which might help you understand.

People say that Allaah has destined them to go to hell as Allaah writes down everything when we are in our Mother's womb.

However, Allaah only writes down what we will do in the future. He does not "make it up" and write it down as He goes along. He KNOWS what will happen, so that is written down when you are in your Mother's womb.

Makes sense?

Wa Allaahu Aalim
 
Last edited:
Haafizah said:
Let me give you an example which might help you understand.

People say that Allaah has destined them to go to hell as Allaah writes down everything when we are in our Mother's womb.

However, Allaah only writes down what we will do in the future. He does not "make it up" and write it down as He goes along. He KNOWS what will happen, so that is written down when you are in your Mother's womb.

Makes sense?

Wa Allaahu Aalim
Click to expand...

sister, make sure your 100% sure about what you write. I think this is a common misunderstanding among muslims.

try and find any reliable source to back your argument up. the concept of Qadr can never be fully understood or quantified as you are trying to do - this is why the scholars tell us not to spend time probing into it - rather understand its fundamentals, and accept them
 
Haafizah said:
I am 100% sure sister,
Click to expand...

Tango was a brother a few minutes before :skeleton:


tango92 said:
this is why the scholars tell us not to spend time probing into it - rather understand its fundamentals, and accept them
Click to expand...

I read a hadith from a very authentic source in which Muhammad SAW went offended on Sahaba's when they were discussing this matter.The hadith raise the same point as to not try to explore this matter in deep.If anyone can post the basic concept and the hadith i'm talking about,it will be of great help.I'll try to find it myself Inshallah :statisfie
 
:sl:


Does Human Taqdeer changes as he performs good deeds(Praying to God).
 
Your taqdeer is written when you are born. it is written that you will decide to do more good deeds, bad deeds etc .

I thought I already explained this !
 
Haafizah said:
Your taqdeer is written when you are born. it is written that you will decide to do more good deeds, bad deeds etc .

I thought I already explained this !
Click to expand...

:sl:

Dear Sis,

You explained only what is Taqdeer...anywayz thanks


How is you Health now.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top