Khutba: in English......?

[azc]

https://www.tafseer-raheemi.com/engl...0%2C6947966684

Is English Khutbah Permissible? - Tafseer Raheemi ...

[keiv]

I've personally never been to a khutba where it was given in Arabic and these were all given by Arabic speakers. Anytime they said something in Arabic (e.g Hadith), it was always translated afterwards, but the lectures themselves have been in English. Not sure how common it is in other states/cities, but I'd imagine it's pretty common here in the US

[azc]

I've personally never been to a khutba where it was given in Arabic and these were all given by Arabic speakers. Anytime they said something in Arabic (e.g Hadith), it was always translated afterwards, but the lectures themselves have been in English. Not sure how common it is in other states/cities, but I'd imagine it's pretty common here in the US

I think lecture and khutba are two different things. According to hadith khutba should be shorter than (Friday) salah

[azc]

‘Ammaar ibn Yaasir (may Allaah be pleased with him), who said: I heard the Messenger of Allaah (may Allaah raise his rank and grant him peace) saying:

إن طول صلاة الرجل وقصر خطبته مئنة من فقهه، فأطيلوا الصلاة واقصروا الخطبة، وإن من البيان لسحرًا

“Verily the long prayer of a man along with his short khutbah is a sign of his religious understanding, so prolong the prayers and shorten the khutbahs, as some kinds of speech are magical.”

(Ahmad, Muslim, and ad-Daarimee)

Ibn Mas’ood – may Allaah be pleased with him – said said:

You people are living in a time wherein prayers are made long, khutbahs (sermons) are short, there are many scholars, but few orators. A time will come upon the people when the prayer will be short, the khutbah will be long, a time of many orators but few scholars…

(Tabarani)

It was also collected by Imaam Maalik in his Muwatta’, with a similar wording:

…And the people shall encounter a time when the scholars of fiqh are few, but the reciters are many, the letters of the Qur’aan will be memorized, but the rulings will be lost, many shall be asked questions (about Islaam), few will be able to benefit anyone, they shall prolong khutbahs (sermons), and shorten the prayers. Their whims will become evident even before their actions.

…He (Ibn Mas’ood) – may Allaah be pleased with him – also narrated from the Prophet (may Allaah raise his rank and grant him peace) that he said:

إن قصر الخطبة وطول الصلاة مئنة من فقه الرجل، فأطيلوا الصلاة، واقصروا الخطبة، فإن من البيان سحرًا، وإنه سيأتي بعدكم قوم يطيلون الخطب ويقصرون الصلاة

“Verily, a short khutbah and a long prayer is a sign of a man’s fiqh (religious understanding), so lengthen the prayer and shorten the khutbah, as surely some types of speech are magical. People will come after you who prolong the khutbahs and shorten the prayers”
(al-Bazzaar)

Hey there! Looks like you're enjoying the discussion, but you're not signed up for an account.

When you create an account, you can participate in the discussions and share your thoughts. You also get notifications, here and via email, whenever new posts are made. And you can like posts and make new friends.
Sign Up

[keiv]

I think lecture and khutba are two different things. According to hadith khutba should be shorter than (Friday) salah

I think I'm confused about which one is the lecture and which one is the khutbah. When the imam walks in, the adhan is called and he does his speech (English). After he is done, the adhan is called again and we perform the salah (Arabic). I guess I always thought lecture and khutbah were the same thing.

[azc]

I think I'm confused about which one is the lecture and which one is the khutbah. When the imam walks in, the adhan is called and he does his speech (English). After he is done, the adhan is called again and we perform the salah (Arabic). I guess I always thought lecture and khutbah were the same thing.

DIFFERENCES BETWEEN A FRIDAY DHIKR (KHUTBAH) AND A LECTURE

The Friday Khutbah and Other Lectures

1 The Friday Khutbah is a condition for the validity of Jumuáh Salaat. Without the Khutbah, Jumuáh Salaat is not valid.

Not conditional for any Salaat.

2 Valid only on Fridays

Permissible on any day.

3 Can only be performed after Zawaal on Friday.

No time restraint.

4 Its recital to only one or two persons is not permissible according to the Hanafi Mazhab. At least three people excluding the Imaam have to be present.
According to the Shafi Mazhab at least 40 persons have to be present.

Any number of persons.

5 While the Khutbah is in progress, it is not permissible to speak, read, etc.

Permissible but inappropriate without dire necessity.

6 Consists of two Khutbahs divided by a short interval between the first and second Khutbas.

A single lecture.

7 The two Khutbahs have to be separated by a short interval (during which the Imaam has to sit on the Mimbar).

No such practice necessary for any lecture.

8 A single Tahmeed, Tasbeeh or Tahleel will suffice to discharge the obligation (However, this is against the Sunnah.

A single Tahmeed, Tahleel or Tasbeeh is not a lecture.

9 Allah Taála has decreed the Jumuáh Khutbah Fardh.

A lecture is not Fardh.

10 Those who do not listen to or attend the Friday Khutbah are Faasiq (flagrant sinners) in term of the Shariáh.

Not so in the case of other lectures.

11 If the Friday Khutbah is delivered before Zawaal, it will have to be repeated.

Not so in the case of other lectures.

12 Performed in big towns or cities. Not permissible in small places or little villages.

It Can be held anywhere.

13 Not permissible to recite it after the Jumuáh Salaat.

Permissible before or after any Salaat.

14 Azaan has to be called in the presence of the Imaam while he is seated on the Mimbar just before the Khutbah.

Not so in the case of any lecture.

15 The Friday Khutbah is compulsorily followed by Salaat.

No Salaat has been ordained after or before a lecture.

16 The Friday Khutbah is representative of two Rakaats of Salaat.

Does not represent any Salaat.

17 To be performed in a state of Tahaarat (i.e. being free from the impurities of Janaabat) and having Wudhu.

Not the case with other lectures.

18 The Friday Khutbah recited in the presence of only a female audience is not permissible.

It is permissible.

19 Rasulullah (Sallallaahu Alayhi Wasallam) had a Mimbar especially erected for the purpose of the Jumuáh Khutbah.

Mimbar not necessary for other lectures.

20 The Jumuáh Khutbah is among the Shaãir (salient features) of Islam.

Not among the Shaãir of Islam.

21 Has to be delivered in a standing position.

Can be delivered in a sitting position.

22 Consists of Fardh and Sunnat factors.

Do not consist of Fardh and Sunnat factors.

23 The Friday Khutbah is a Zikr.

Not a Zikr.

24 Must be rendered in Arabic.

Can be delivered in any language.

[azc]

Plz see this link:

https://islamreigns.wordpress.com/ta...0%2C4338115036

Difference between Bayaan and Khutbah | islamreigns Posts about Difference between Bayaan and Khutbah written by islamreigns...

[Scimitar]

I'll just quietly, plug this here:

Friday Sermons in English for reverts