PDA

View Full Version : Logical Proof that Islam is the only true religion



HabibUrrehman
07-19-2019, 10:17 PM
Those who believe that the truth is relative and that all beliefs are correct deem that it is not possible to say that a person’s beliefs are wrong, because religion to them is a purely individual belief. The falsehood of this statement is quite apparent and we do not need to delve into great detail to prove it. If one religion believes that Jesus was a false prophet, another maintains he is God, and yet another that he was a human specially chosen to be a prophet, how can they all be true? Jesus PBUH, must inevitably be one of the three things mentioned above, and all three statements cannot be correct. Therefore, as only one of these statements can be correct, whichever is established as true determines that the others must then be considered as false.


This does not, however, mean that a person does not have the right to believe as they wish, as this is a right that God has invested to all humans. But at the same time, it does not mean that one must take the other extreme and say that they are all correct, and that one does not have the right to form a judgment about them. Also, giving a person the right to believe what he wishes does not necessitate that they have right to openly practice or publicize these beliefs, for laws implemented in society always look at the effects of actions at the greater societal level and whether those actions are advantageous or harmful to the society at large.


From what I discussed above, we can unequivocally come to the conclusion that all the religions found today in the world are either all false, or that there exists one among them which is the comprehensive Truth; for although various religions do contain similarities, they also have fundamental differences.


If we were to say that no religion in the world today is correct, then this would entail believing that God is unjust because He left us to wander about on earth in sin and transgression without showing us the right way to do things, and this is impossible for a Just God. Therefore the only logical conclusion is that there is One True Religion, which contains guidance in all spheres of life, religious, moral, societal, and individual.


How do we know what this one true religion is? It is upon each and every human to investigate this matter. Humans were created to fulfill a great purpose, not just to eat, sleep and go about finding their daily sustenance and satiate their desires. In order to fulfill this purpose, one must try to find what their purpose is, and this can only be done by investigation. If one believes that there is a God, and that God must not have left humans to wander in misguidance, then they must search for the religion and way of life which God revealed. Furthermore, this religion would not be hidden or hard for humans to find or understand, for that would defeat the purpose of guidance. Also, the religion must contain the same message throughout time, since we mentioned that everything returns to one absolute truth. Also, this religion cannot contain any falsities or contradictions, for falseness or contradiction in one matter of the religion proves the falsity of the religion as a whole, since we would then doubt the integrity of its texts.


There is no other religion which fulfills the conditions mentioned above except for religion of Islam, the religion which is accordance to human nature, the religion which has been preached by all prophets since the dawn of man. Other religions found today, such as Christianity and Judaism, are the remnants of the religion brought by the prophets in their time, which was Islam. However, over time, they have been altered and lost, and what is left today of these religions is a mix of truth and falsehood. The only religion which has been preserved and preaches the same message brought by all prophets is the religion of Islam, the one true religion, which rules all sphere’s of humans’ lives, religious, political, societal, and individual, and it is upon all humans to investigate this religion, to ascertain its truth, and to follow it.
Reply

Login/Register to hide ads. Scroll down for more posts
Physicist
07-21-2019, 08:29 PM
Let's start from the fact, that actually all religions are a part of Creation and were created by Allah for a reason.

As we are aiming for a logical proof here, I will abstain from citing Qur'an other than to illustrate properties of Islam.

Putting aside details about creation of religions, however, we can see, that various religions, starting from paganism, are like grades in the school, teaching mankind.
Also, religions focusing on various stages of personal development.
Paganism may be exciting for children, however, Hindu eventually embracing concept of supreme God with multiple names. Buddhism thought people observation, many great things were introduced by early religions. But more than any of them, Islam brought forward adult stage of a responsible man, who don't need any shepherds on his way to Allah.

One may think, that 1400 years is too long a period considering speeding up development of mankind and that perhaps mankind would benefit from a new, more modern religion.

It will not.
1.There is the sequence of major abrahamic religions, every next confirms previous.
Islam clearly states that Prophet Muhammad is the last Prophet.
So, any candidate for the next religion, will have to oppose itself to Islam, making it more difficult for mankind to come to consensus at the end.

2. Majority of fundamental things considering personal and social issues were already voiced out and such a new religion will have to duplicate what was said. As it will oppose itself to Islam it will be blamed for plagiate and mere adaptations for modern circumstances which could be done in the boundaries of Islam.

3. There is no need for new prophets anymore.
Prophecy is about seing the future when there is not enough knowledge for. It is kind of expensive, it could be necessary on early stages of manknd's development, when humans had no knowledge, like children who had to be guided by parents.
Now, we are entering epoch of the knowledge, we need no extra prophets, we are able to learn ourselves, to become like prophets, but guided by knowledge instead of expensive divine revelations.
Reply

Saira Khan
07-21-2019, 09:46 PM
Originally Posted by HabibUrrehman
If we were to say that no religion in the world today is correct, then this would entail believing that God is unjust because He left us to wander about on earth in sin and transgression without showing us the right way to do things, and this is impossible for a Just God. Therefore the only logical conclusion is that there is One True Religion, which contains guidance in all spheres of life, religious, moral, societal, and individual.
السلام علیکم ورحمتہ اللہ

This is a very good article composed in a good manner. I just want to add:
"We believe in all the messengers of Allah SWT, we believe in all the Books revealed by Allah SWT on His messengers". Even if we say that all the religions of the world are true (excluding the man made corruptions in those religions), but still they will be considered just the "Parts" of the greatest reality. Islam is the totality of all the parts. The totality of the greatest reality, so after having the "Totality" in your hands, maneuvering around the parts is meaningless, absurd and just a folly.

stay blessed, JazakaAllah.
Reply

Hey there! Looks like you're enjoying the discussion, but you're not signed up for an account.

When you create an account, you can participate in the discussions and share your thoughts. You also get notifications, here and via email, whenever new posts are made. And you can like posts and make new friends.
Sign Up

Similar Threads

  1. Replies: 13
    Last Post: 05-31-2016, 02:46 PM
  2. Replies: 11
    Last Post: 01-30-2012, 02:18 PM
  3. Replies: 410
    Last Post: 04-11-2010, 04:31 AM
  4. Replies: 3
    Last Post: 05-27-2008, 02:12 AM
  5. Replies: 16
    Last Post: 12-16-2006, 05:17 PM

IslamicBoard

Experience a richer experience on our mobile app!