No body cares about ur opinion!

  • Thread starter Thread starter Danish
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 23
  • Views Views 4K
D

Danish

IB Veteran
Messages
665
Reaction score
73
Gender
Male
Religion
Islam
:sl:
I donna where exactly this thread should go, but i posted it here, fell free to have hours of fun when moving it to appropraite forum

Well, some ppl post their opinion when answering a question regarding islam/quran/shariah. Well my point is if u r NOT scholar then no body cares about ur opinion, no seriously no body does. Plz don't say "I dont think Islam would do that" or words of same effect if u r muslim. We r not the maker of the rules bro and sis, and so don't answer if u don't have knowledge

Since ur opinion don't matter please try to post Quranic verses/authentic ahadiths as much as possible when answering questions, so we get full-time reward

jazakallah khair
 
:sl:
So what do ya want us to post here?
Click to expand...
nofink really, just saying post authentic sources when backing ur point, cos some muslim don't do that and think they create can their own law....not talking about any1 specific, just a general overview

one more post count eh Ibn Syed ;) nice one :)
 
:sl:
and no body cares about ur no of posts either. :) u know what I mean. Some bros post just for increasing their no of posts, with only smileys and oneliners.
I don't think there is any award for highest poster or is there? :p if yes, do tell me. :D
:w: :brother:
 
Assalamu alaikum

May I please remind everyone of the following from our rules
8. Off-topic freeposts in multiple threads is very annoying please refrain from posting such comments.
Click to expand...
By all means increase your post count, but as you can see freeposts are not allowed. Those who regularly do this have been alerted by pm, Barakallahu feekum
 
:sl:

i would say the contrary, if people want to disagree with a fatwa openly, let them do it, why? so we can show them the apropriate daleel, links ayats whatever, its all part of the learning process, restricting mistakes just makes us learn less.
 
:sl:
I think both sides in this thread are correct. People should remember that when they make a statement without evidence it is only their opinion, but they should still post it so we can clarify the matter for them.

:w:
 
:sl:
i would say the contrary, if people want to disagree with a fatwa openly, let them do it, why? so we can show them the apropriate daleel, links ayats whatever, its all part of the learning process, restricting mistakes just makes us learn less.
Click to expand...
no, we don't have the right to give our opinion against the rules of Allah (SWT) and Muhammed (PHUB)... e.g. there r some homosexual muslims who think homosexuality is allowed because they THINK there is nothing wrong with it, even tho its explicitly mentioned in Quran that its not allowed

u see, if everyone interprets Islam on their opinion then we will have couple of thousand versions of Islam
 
Assalamu 'alaikum
Ansar Al-'Adl said:
:sl:
I think both sides in this thread are correct. People should remember that when they make a statement without evidence it is only their opinion, but they should still post it so we can clarify the matter for them.

:w:
Click to expand...
ditto
 
:sl:

As muslims we should always have this ayah in our mind when a decree has been made by Allah and His Messenger.

And it behoves not a believing man and a believing woman that they should have any choice in their matter when Allah and His Apostle have decided a matter; and whoever disobeys Allah and His Apostle, he surely strays off a manifest straying.

However if one wants to say anything they can politely ask, but to state an opinion as if it were a fact without daleel then this should not happen.
 
Salaam Danish,

Plz don't say "I dont think Islam would do that" or words of same effect if u r muslim. We r not the maker of the rules bro and sis, and so don't answer if u don't have knowledge

Since ur opinion don't matter
Click to expand...
Sometimes normal people can see something in the religion which scholars overlook. And also, scholars are not the makers of rules either, my friend. Only Allah makes rules. Scholars give opinions, and we are not necessarily under obligation to follow them. My sheikh has never been able to explain to me why Islam and why not Christianity, yet I can so easily cream him in that field. Remember what i said about wisdom? Knowledge is not enough, you need to have intelligence, experience and wisdom. That makes a scholar. And believe me, there are very few scholars around in today's world.

Regards
 
Interesting Sheikh Haroon, anywho anyone on this forum can give their opinion , and if it has traits of falseness within it, it's the job of the person who sees it to ratify it
 
There are people saying since we are in the west the rules of Islam change. That things Allah has forbidden are ok here. People have posted they see no problem with drinking etc. These posts may confuse the new muslim who reads them and sees some muslims say this is ok and some say it isn't. I know when i first became muslim i was confused by all the women here who only wore hijab when going to the mosque. There are alot of people out there who are looking for answers to their questions and they shouldnt be misguided by people who they themselves are misguided. Its best to leave the giving of advice to those people who know what they are talking about. Unless the person wants an opinion not a lesson.

Volume 1, Book 3, Number 100:
Narrated 'Abdullah bin 'Amr bin Al' As:

I heard Allah's Apostle saying, "Allah does not take away the knowledge, by taking it away from (the hearts of) the people, but takes it away by the death of the religious learned men till when none of the (religious learned men) remains, people will take as their leaders ignorant persons who when consulted will give their verdict without knowledge. So they will go astray and will lead the people astray."
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top