Aethiests - Read Quran?

Have you read the Quran and How did it feel?

  • Total voters
    0
IbnAbdulHakim

IbnAbdulHakim

IB Addict
Messages
16,476
Reaction score
2,628
Gender
Male
Religion
Islam
Peace,


I hope your all well.


My question is quite simple, Have you read the Quran in its pure arabic form and if you have please let us know how it felt.

I mean read it properly, with ablution.
 
i can't imagine that there are very many atheists running around out there that could read the qur'an in arabic.
i wish i could - that would be cool.
 
Going to be as difficult poll to find somebody to vote honestly on. Although we do have several Atheist members I do not believe any of them read Arabic.
 
Good Ques but I don't think many would have read it in Arabic, properly AND with wudhu...I'm sure many may have read the meaning of it..maybe you should rephrase the ques...
 
IbnAbdulHakim said:
Peace,


I hope your all well.


My question is quite simple, Have you read the Quran in its pure arabic form and if you have please let us know how it felt.

I mean read it properly, with ablution.
Click to expand...

Why would an athiest read Quran in the first place?

Secondly, if you really want to do something good, then just do it.

There're a plenty of good things in Quran. You can read all those good things no matter what language you read it in. But the problem is that those who read Quran only talk about good things. They don't do those good things like all others including the athiests. Whenever, a move for development or betterment is initiated, the Quran readers oppose the move by proving it not as 100% according to Quran. Therefore, a change for good can never take place in societies where these people are strong.
 
Very old poll....
It doesnt matter whether an Athiest reads the Quran or not... what matters is whether they had an OPEN MIND when reading the Qu'ran, be it a translation or the Qur'an in Arabic itself.... people are just as moved when reading a translation of the Qur'an in any language. This is generally the excuse.... if it WAS in Arabic, maybe i would have been affected....:)
 
I have read the Qu'ran several times.. But not in arabic. Just in French and English. But I am trying to learn Arabic and hope to one day read it in Arabic!

Now I have heard the Qu'ran being RECITED in Arabic.. And I felt nothing. It reminded me of a Jew reciting the 10 Commandments in the Bible!

Since I do not know arabic I did not vote.
 
thirdwatch512 said:
I have read the Qu'ran several times.. But not in arabic. Just in French and English. But I am trying to learn Arabic and hope to one day read it in Arabic!

Now I have heard the Qu'ran being RECITED in Arabic.. And I felt nothing. It reminded me of a Jew reciting the 10 Commandments in the Bible!

Since I do not know arabic I did not vote.
Click to expand...

Nice honest answer... just means the veil is still covering your heart, thats all :D
 
thirdwatch512 said:
Lol maybe you are right! We never know lol
Click to expand...

That is saddening brother Thirdwatch512, Listen to it again with the translation next to it,

Just out of curiosity whose recitation was it? It is best in my opinion to listen to someone with a melodious voice and then move onto the heart rendering powerful recitations after that,

Peace be upon those who follow guidance.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top