Wikipedia false imformation.

  • Thread starter Thread starter Hashim_507
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 12
  • Views Views 3K
H

Hashim_507

IB Veteran
Messages
529
Reaction score
33
Gender
Male
Religion
Islam
Wikipedia does not give a good information about Islam. The non-muslims wrote many articles thats misleading. Do not trust those information unless its not wikipedia website. I have read many of the article and it was not good information.
 
Wikipedia is an excellant source for any information, IMO. I haven't been wronged by it yet.
Why not take advantage of the ability to edit articles if you don't like what you see?
 
buriedaway_4536 said:
Wikipedia is an excellant source for any information, IMO. I haven't been wronged by it yet.
Why not take advantage of the ability to edit articles if you don't like what you see?
Click to expand...

If anyone can edit them then i don't think it is so reliable. :mmokay:

Peace be upon those who follow guidance..
 
In Name of Allah, The Most Gracious, The Most Merciful

:salamext:

Someone asked about Wiki on Askimam.org:

"I would like to know if the contents on Wikipedia about all Islam in general can be considered correct. Are you aware of any scholars in Islam that participate and assist in validation of the content. The url i is: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam

In the name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful

Assalaamu `alaykum waRahmatullahi Wabarakatoh

Wikkipedia is indeed an information portal, but the material from wikkipedia cannot be completely relied one since it is open to editing by anyone. Therefore no Guarantee can be given about the information being authentic or not.

Besides that, after skimming through the main Islam article, following points were worth pointing out.

1. The majority of references for the main article on Islam are Christian Sources and Authors.
2. It also refers to Javed Ghamdi to whom Ulema have taken apprehension due to his views which are contradictory to main stream Ulema.
3. It shows the falsity of Shias as acceptable and thus makes Shias as a valid sect under Islam.
4. It also differentiates AhlSunnah from Sufism, whereas Sufism(Tazkiyatun Nafs) is the former.

Thus we recommend not taking Wikkipedia as an authentic source. There are many authentic Islamic websites available. We should rather use them.

Views of Computer Dept.

Madrassah In’aamiyyah"

http://www.askimam.org/fatwa/fatwa.php?askid=ea46a043c5ffcf8dcc5f769d0e4fccd6

So, we should not rely on wiki for Islamic information. but I don't know about the other subjects.

wasalam
-SI-
 
3. It shows the falsity of Shias as acceptable and thus makes Shias as a valid sect under Islam
Click to expand...
So does LI as do all "Muslim" governments

Wa-Salaam Alaikum
 
Last edited:
Wikipedia is obvioulsy not 100% true all the time, but from my experience it generally has good information and resources. There are many, many "Islamic" websites out there which are also misleading and disseminating falsehood as well. Therefore, one should use it mostly for reference, and verify its claims through cross reference with Islamic resources online.
 
NoName55 said:
So does LI as do all "Muslim" governments

Wa-Salaam Alaikum
Click to expand...

:salamext:


I think its just a good chance of giving dawah to them. And many ignorant shi'as dont know about their beliefs either, so we cant class them as disbelievers.
 
I wouldn't use Wikipedia for research paper source material or anything like that, but overall it does have useful information. They need to find a way to prohibit editing by just anybody though.
 
Keltoi said:
I wouldn't use Wikipedia for research paper source material or anything like that, but overall it does have useful information. They need to find a way to prohibit editing by just anybody though.
Click to expand...
But that's the gimick!
Vandals are punished. And if there is flase info, there's always someone out there to set the record straight. I know I like to add/correct. :)
 
buriedaway_4536 said:
But that's the gimick!
Vandals are punished. And if there is flase info, there's always someone out there to set the record straight. I know I like to add/correct. :)
Click to expand...
There are more than a thousand admins and recent change Patrols to chase away vandals and undo false edits

wa-salaam
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top