animals and heaven or hell

  • Thread starter Thread starter rozeena
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 16
  • Views Views 3K
assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullah

naa sis they return to dust, but before they return to dust Allah pays due retribution to all of them, to the extent where the horned goat will have to pay for the damage he has done to the hornless goat
 
IbnAbdulHakim said:
assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullah

naa sis they return to dust, but before they return to dust Allah pays due retribution to all of them, to the extent where the horned goat will have to pay for the damage he has done to the hornless goat
Click to expand...

Salams,

^ so they are punished or rewarded for their deeds too :?:

w'salam
 
*~Sofia~* said:
Salams,

^ so they are punished or rewarded for their deeds too :?:

w'salam
Click to expand...

i wouldnt say that, i would just say all injustices every committed in the animal kingdome will be absolved.


So pure justice will be handed out, but no "extra reward" or "extra punishment" will be given like us humans have.


I hope that makes sense...
 
^^ ooohh rite, yeh i get it now.. jazakallah khair bro, didn't no that!

w'salam
 
^ animals were not created with souls, they are created mainly for us humans... lol
 
rozeena said:
where does der soul go?
Click to expand...
animals have no free-will, everything is instict etc, they have no souls, so if they feel pain etc Allah will retribute that, so no worries inshaALlah.

n will we jinn in heaven n hell?
Click to expand...

the jinn will go to heaven or hell, they go through tests like we do..
 
i read that they will all be turned to dust, but that first they will thank allah for not creating them human.
 
rozeena said:
n 1 last fing wud ve see da jinn in heaven/hell?
Click to expand...

yeah sis, we are visible to the jinns right now, but the jinns will be visible to us on the day of judgement and they will not be able to see us. Then during heaven/hell we will see each other, (someone correct me if im mistaken)


and barney, i believe that is in a narration, and could very well be correct :)
 
IbnAbdulHakim said:
yeah sis, we are visible to the jinns right now, but the jinns will be visible to us on the day of judgement and they will not be able to see us. Then during heaven/hell we will see each other, (someone correct me if im mistaken)


and barney, i believe that is in a narration, and could very well be correct :)
Click to expand...

reali. so we will see them geting judged bt they wont see us getting judged? thats amazing didnt knw dat. r jinns female n male? n hw can we stop dem from being by us wen we dnt want dem der?
 
Its the first time when i heard the animals don't have souls :hmm:
 
This is the amanah (Trust) that humans were given. The amanah was not given to angels, moutains, animals. It was given to two creations that we know of Bani Adam (Son of Adam) and Jinn. This is stated in the Qur'an

"Truly, We did offer Al-Amanah (the trust or moral responsibility or honesty and all the duties which Allah has ordained) to the heavens and the earth, and the mountains, but they declined to bear it and were afraid of it (i.e., afraid of Allah's torment). But man bore it. Verily, he was unjust (to himself) and ignorant (of its results)". (33:72)

So the animals refused to take that trust and we took it. The word amanah is very comprehensive term which can mean everything that deals with adherence to Islamic way of life. I read in the tafsir Ibn Kathir Amanah is that obey Allah and His Messenger and you will be given heaven and disobey Allah and His Messenger you are given the hell-fire. It was a weighty amanah and we accepted it and need to bear the responsibility. Animals don't really deserve the pleasure of paradise because they have not passed any tests...They were not given free-will we humans were.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top