xboxisdead
IB Expert
- Messages
- 1,195
- Reaction score
- 27
- Gender
- Male
- Religion
- Islam
salaam
You need to stay away from the MRA and red pill Garbage - you could make an entire skit of men cheating against there wife. The entire thing is just pure propaganda.
This is not an example of an Islamic society so is it necessary to post it here?
I understand brother, but we need to be careful not to give a standard where boys and young men feel that they cannot express their distress or emotion in fear of being under shaming tactic attack on them or give them the illusion that they have it easier or or or...this is very dangerous formula that will in future bite the entire community hard. Be careful if you do this..the number of boys wanting to become girls will increase..the amount of transsexual will go in fold and the amount of hormonal therapy will become rampant because then they believe the only way they can express themselves is if they are female. Is that standard you wish to give? Second of all just because you can make an entire skit of men cheating on their wives by all mean does not devalue this skit in anyway. This thinking again gives the illusion that no matter what a boy faces a girl could face worse and thus his issues is irrelevant compared to hers.
This will...generate...a poisonous..formula and an oppressive one towards men in ways you cannot fathom. Last I checked, Allah (Subhanahu Wa Talaa) HATES PEOPLE WHO OPPRESSES. Do not...do not...do not.....make this mistake. Because ones young men and boys realize they cannot in anyway..express their feelings because a girl can go through worse therefore his feelings is irrelevant and you compare yourself to girl's issues thus your issues is insignificant compared to her issues will make the boy a nice..well pot that will explode in either violence, drugs, gangs, and mass shootings. Your approach on this matter is wrongly done. Instead of shaming tactics and throwing red pill...instead say.. "Yes. It is true. There is oppression going on here to towards men as well in family court and family law and marriage in the West. This is wrong. This haraam. A wife should not be nagging to her husband. A wife should make his life easy, nor she should cheat on him." from there you should start saying we need to go back to the proper Islamic way and from there post ahadeth and videos of how a wife and husband should act and and and and..and say Alahmdolillah we are Muslimeen and that Islam have given justice to everyone and so on.
Make it so..that when young men and boys come here and read this...they feel.."I have a place to talk. I have a place to express myself. I have a place to remove the toxic from my body and I know someone out there will listen to me and hear me and help me solve my problem and not somehow make me feel like my issue is light and insignificant." and especially not because I am born boy therefore I have it easy and all my problems does not compare to the opposite gender. Because if you go that route..then men and boys should be tortured and burned alive with pain because hey after all...women have it hard carrying you for nine month and going through pain delivering your baby..the pain of burning and torturing cannot compare to the pain of the mother. Is that how you want to start comparing things? I am not saying men don't cheat or say talaq left and right without thinking and I am not saying men don't beat their wives, nor am I saying there are no emotionally abusive husbands out there. But I am also hoping you are not saying that if these situations occur to men where they are physically abused or emotionally abused that you should take it lightly because women and wives go through this as well.
No it wont - transgender people have always existed for 1000s of years - different cultures have handled them differently. Just because the LGBTQ community promote it it does not mean that this is the normative culture - normative culture still is man and women - talk to real people and don't just watch weird media outlets.
The skit is propaganda and has no basis in reality. No relationship breaks or works like this.
- - - Updated - - -
For starters men and women do not have the same roles in Islam. Men need to be men and women need to be women and collaborate with one another and not run for the "oppressive marathon" - life is a test and so is marriage - so you have to deal with it through Hope, Thankfulness and fortitude.
- - - Updated - - -
If your going through psychological/ emotional issues then you should talk about it to relevant people. Not go on some alt right/MRA red pill weird part of the net.
Of course! Because it is happening in Muslim community in the West in Canada. Now..if I am living in Middle East where they follow proper Islamic law...I will not even think twice about it. But alas..I only make 18K a year imsadimsad I cannot move to Middle East and live there. So I am living here in West where it is happening in broad mass. How do I know? Well....I will tell you the truth...I am not lying...
one day I went to the mosque and met a sheikh he was sitting on the floor chatting with other men...and I expressed this very stress issue to him ..live person to person and not some binary 0's and 1's in post form. He smiled and other men sitting in the meeting was listening to me and nodded in agreement and the shiekh even laughed a little with what I said. After I finished..he said yes this is exactly happens in Muslim community too in the BC (that is where I live) and he told me a horror story of many hundreds. He said there was this brother who had a disagreement with this wife and you know how wives are...the man can't take it anymore..so he decided to leave the house to calm down and relax before something serious happens...so he left. The wife decided to plot a scheme to take his house and kids..so what she did...she got this man (I don't know how he knows him) and made him come to her house and make act (inappropriate) when the husband entered the house to cause a fume. So the husband naturally did a normal reaction start fighting with the guy (the plot the wife wanted to happen)...she got the police at her husband..have him arrested..said he did domestic violence to her and to her kid and this proofs because of his aggression to this man..he went to prison. Now he lost his house and access to his daughter and he is kicked. I interrupted the man when he said he have a daughter...I said to him, "Oh! A daughter! Now that is even ten times worse! Because she can say he molested his daughter and this comes out really bad!" and then I let him continue his story. He said this is one of the hundred horror stories he hears in Muslim community in Canada, in BC. I live in Surrey.
So point is...it is necessary to post this here...because I want a place for Muslim men to know that this skit is not just happening to non-Muslim men..but to Muslim men too. To any men, period. I am living in Canada. What is happening here is going to affect me. I cannot leave to Middle East because it is in constant war and there is no good place to work and get good education and live there. I do not have also the financial mean to move there.
You need to stay away from the MRA and red pill Garbage - you could make an entire skit of men cheating against there wife. The entire thing is just pure propaganda.
The skit is propaganda and has no basis in reality. No relationship breaks or works like this.
This definitely happens in the Middle East. In Palestine, I had a family member whose wife left him for someone she met on facebook and she didn't want anything to do with the kids. The free mixing and cheating that goes on there is overwhelming. It wouldn't surprise me if this happened elsewhere in the Middle East.
You're living under a rock if you think this is not reality. Men and women cheat on each other all the time. I don't think anyone is disputing that, nor should they. The reality of the post is that there are times (probably more often than not) where the man is the one who loses everything, as depicted in the graphic above, for essentially doing nothing wrong.
This is not an example of an Islamic society so is it necessary to post it here?
salaam
You need to stay away from the MRA and red pill Garbage - you could make an entire skit of men cheating against there wife. The entire thing is just pure propaganda.
I would say that the MRA/redpill/Manosphere etc is half right. The sexual nature of both men and women is such that it sometimes leads to immorality if followed. While contemporary Western society (rightly, for the most part) reviles men who follow their basest impulses, it simultaneously either makes excuses for women when they do it, or outright denies that they do. The Manosphere may have turned into a crazy, self-reinforcing, self-radicalizing echo chamber by now, but I do think it has stumbled on some truths that have been part forgotten, part suppressed.
I would say that the MRA/redpill/Manosphere etc is half right. The sexual nature of both men and women is such that it sometimes leads to immorality if followed. While contemporary Western society (rightly, for the most part) reviles men who follow their basest impulses, it simultaneously either makes excuses for women when they do it, or outright denies that they do. The Manosphere may have turned into a crazy, self-reinforcing, self-radicalizing echo chamber by now, but I do think it has stumbled on some truths that have been part forgotten, part suppressed.
You're living under a rock if you think this is not reality. Men and women cheat on each other all the time. I don't think anyone is disputing that, nor should they. The reality of the post is that there are times (probably more often than not) where the man is the one who loses everything, as depicted in the graphic above, for essentially doing nothing wrong.
Its an extreme reaction to extreme feminism. Furthermore the west has no practical decorum of how men and women should act with each other, especially if they take the feminist view of sex and gender. The Christians even though they may have been extreme pre 1960s at least had an Idea of how men and women were meant to act, Today the rules keep changing purely on what secular Liberalism deems to be appropriate - right now its feminism and the MRA/red pillers are just reacting to it with no solutions whatsoever. I dont think they will find a solution with any secular philosophy.
- - - Updated - - -
No man is that perfect as the skit portrays and neither is any women. Men and women need to work together collaboratively otherwise the human race is screwed. I honestly blame the secular capitalist paradigm for this. If a humans worth is only financial and both men and women have exactly the same worth (even though there are glaring differences) then we have something seriously wrong and dangerous. This is where the feminist/MRA/red pillers are just crazy reactionaries within this paradigm.
Islam acknowledges differences and similarities orientates us to a higher Goal (being a Godly person) and not just worrying about the horizontal (money and wealth). The solution is in not competing with each other for worldly gain (men and women) but collaboratively working together (Islam). Marriage and finding a family is very important here.
Yes, but for me I feel that my role as a man, husband and father is worthless. Very hard to convince me in particular to build family. Unless you want to redefine family to suit the new standard and it could be two women or a single mom or a woman and a dog as family then that is different. You can also define a family, a mother and her mother and her grandmother no man in the house and they are raising children on their own and you define that as a family. You could also say that a single mother on her own, having children, going outside and working and taking care of the affair on her own as a family and thus you open a door where there will be single mothers on purpose who wish to be strong, independent women who can have it all...as a family.
By the way? No way said men are perfect. We are just saying this a major problem effecting men and there is no real solution to the problem as you clearly showed in your reply here.
what are you looking for exactly, are you married? is this with personal experience or MRA stuff?
Yes there is, Its to reach for a higher goal together with a women with similar Goals rater then relying on secular liberal feminists or MRA types which only end up creating a full on war with the sexes/gender.
I support feminism because feminism is the disease that will kill the West, putting an end to this degenerate culture. All Islam has to do is to resist feminism, and it will win.
Al-hamdolillah I am not married! It is a great blessing! It is not MRA stuff it is how I see men and husbands and fathers and what they have to go through...it is not very appealing to be honest. There is no glory and pleasure in any of these roles and the pain is just no worth it. We are even working on stripping husband's right that Allah (Subhanahu Wa Talaa) have given him...and make him no different than any person in marriage. So really. He is burden with responsibilities and expectations only and no benefit behind it. Now marriage and husband and father is nothing but....burden. Excess and unnecessary responsibility and expectations and be a man and be tough and be and be...and that is it. You are pretty much..like a stake meat where people just put their teeth on you and bite you until you are left as nothing but bones and thrown in the dumpster for the flies and maggots to eat you. You find endless lectures about mother's right and mom's value and Janna under her feet and it comes strong and powerful..but not much about husband's value like that of a mother and it doesn't come as strong as mother's right and in fact it comes out that now as oppressive to women and blah blah blah.
Too much eak! Too much..bleagh...not worth it. Children will go their mothers anyways..and in the end if a divorce happen she can brain wash them to hate their fathers and no one really cares..bleacgh...yuck. Not interested. At the end of all that..some smart mouth person will say..well mothers go so much...as a man you have to accept your hardship it doesn't come close to what mothers do...so another guilt trip of reasons why we should step on men's heads and treat them like garbage.....pfft. Honestly...my biggest fantasy THAT ALL men don't get married and have children and just focus on themselves...focus on their happiness...focus on their success and doing good and forming friends and empowering themselves. If they must have gets there are millions and millions of children without family..they can sponsor them and they live under his same roof.
Those men in my opinion are heroes in my eyes...because there is no self centered desire to spread his DNA. That he is willing to sacrifice his lineage to help a stranger...to give a better life to a stranger...that he is not following his carnal desires to have sex with woman...that he is willing to not have a female in his life and sacrifice his life for this poor child who does not feel the world love him
I think..that is not a bad idea! I don't see a banner out there that says "Husbands! They do so much to maintain families! Husbands! They withstand abuse from their wives to keep a unity together!" Or some chant and music about husbands (because I doubt there will be for fathers). But you hear them all the time about wives and mothers. So it is....not appealing. Not alluring. Nothing attractive.
You suppose to sacrifice and work hard and have responsibilities to be a man! You must take it like a man! You have to be strong! blah blah blah...aaagh...I nearly feel like I am about to vomit in a bag.
I am surprised we are reinventing our wheels when the answer is already in Qura'an in Sunnah as it is. The reason you even typed that sentence is because we are moving astray. You want to work together with women...like you said? Qura'an. Sunni.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.