A common mistake

[jameelash]

*A Common Mistake | Reciting Qur’ān Without Moving The Tongue And Pronouncing The Words*


Sh. Ibn al-‘Uthaymeen Raḥimahullāh *was asked:*

Is it permissible for me to recite Qur’ān

without pronouncing its word i.e

by just following it with *my sight and reading it in my heart,*

will I obtain the reward of recitation??


The Shaykh answered:

*“NO, there is NO REWARD* for this act,

meaning a person does not obtain the reward of recitation

except by pronouncing *Qur’ān word by word*
and the words cannot be pronounced *except by MOVING THE TONGUE,*

as for the one who only looks at the lines and letters on a

Mus-ḥaf(Qur'an) and recites them in his heart

*then indeed he is not a ‘reciter’..*

so the summary is that the one who does

not utter Qur’ān then there is *NO REWARD of recitation for him.”*

● [فتاوى نور على الدرب]


The Imām al-‘Allāmah Ibn Bāz Raḥimahullāh said on this issue:

“There is no prohibition in looking at Qur’ān without reciting it

to contemplate upon it and to understand it and ponder upon it

but such a person is *neither a 'reciter’ of Qur’ān*

nor

*he obtains the reward and virtue of recitation*

*EXCEPT BY PRONOUNCING EACH WORD*

even if he is not heard by the one who is around him,

as the Messenger of Allāh ﷺ said:

*'Whoever recites a letter from Qur’ān,*

*there is a reward for him and the reward of ten the likes of it’*

(narrated by at-Tirmidhee and ad-Dārimee with an authentic chain)


so a person is not a 'reciter’ *UNLESS HE UTTERS* the words of Qur’ān as has been

mentioned in the writings of the people of knowledge and with Allāh lies the success.”




● [من الموقع الرسمي للإمام ابن باز]
Copied

 

[greenhill]

So the words must form in our mouths.. That's the distinction I get. That clears it up for me, then. JK for the post.


eace:

 

[ZeeshanParvez]

Subhaan Allaah. Beautiful thread. The true scholars of our Ummah have said the truth.


Ibn al-Haajib the Maaliki Faqiih from 570 - 646 H said in the book of prayer:

وَلَا يَجُوزُ إسْرَارٌ مِنْ غَيْرِ حَرَكَةِ لِسَانٍ ; لِأَنَّهُ إذَا لَمْ يُحَرِّكْ لِسَانَهُ لَمْ يَقْرَأْ وَإِنَّمَا فَكَّرَ

[Paraphrase] Silently [reciting] without movement of the tongue is not permitted because when he has not moved his tongue he has not recited. He has only contemplated [when he does not move the tongue].

Jazaak Allaah khairaa. May Allaah guide those who claim scholars like Ibn Uthaymiin were not qualified or refer to them with inappropriate words.