[m4rouf]

I used to be told at my madrasa that it isn't permitted to leave any hair showing although I'd like to know if this is accurate or not. They were sometimes a bit excessive at my madrasa - they'd send you to the principal who would pull your hair if you left your hat at home!

 

[Caplets]

السلام عليكم


Question

Could you give the scholars or mazhab names that their opinion stated that man also obligatory to cover their head.



Praise be to Allaah.

We do not know of anyone among the scholars who said that covering the head is obligatory for men, but a number of scholars have said that it is mustahabb, and they describe baring one’s head in front of people as being one of the things that undermine a man's status and character, especially if the man is elderly or is a scholar; if one of these people uncovers his head, that is worse than if anyone else does it.

The correct view is that it is not one of the things that undermine a man's status and character in all eras and in all environments, rather the ruling on that varies according to people’s customs.

Al-Shaatibee (may Allaah have mercy on him) divided people’s customs into two categories:

1 – Those concerning which there is shar’ee evidence as to whether it is good or bad. In this case reference is to be made to sharee’ah, and what is customary among the people is of no importance.

For example, uncovering the ‘awrah is reprehensible according to sharee’ah, even though many people are accustomed to doing that.
Removing impurity is something that is good and is enjoined by sharee’ah, although many people do not pay attention to impurity on their clothes and do not protect themselves from that.

2 – Things which are customary among people and there is no shar’ee evidence to prohibit it or enjoin it.

Such things are of two types:

(a) Established customs that do not change, such as the desire for food and drink.

(b) Customs that change, such as whether an action is regarded as good or bad, which varies from one society to another.

Al-Shaatibiee described this type by saying, “Such as uncovering the head, which varies from one place to another; in the lands of the east (i.e. Egypt and lands to the east) it is reprehensible for people of prominent status, and in the lands of the west (i.e., North Africa and Islamic Spain) it is not reprehensible. The shar’ee ruling varies accordingly; for people in the east it is to be regarded as undermining a man’s status and character, whereas for the people in the west it is not. (Al-Muwaafaqaat, 2/284)

The point is that covering the head for men is one of the issues concerning which reference should be made to what is customary among the people. A man should do what is customary in the society in which he lives, so long as that does not go against sharee’ah, and so that he will not stand out by being different from them in his clothing etc in the manner that is forbidden in sharee’ah...."

"...3 – Shaykh Ibn ‘Uthaymeen (may Allaah have mercy on him) said:

It was narrated that Ibn ‘Umar said to his freed slave Naafi’: “Do you go and meet people bareheaded?” He said: “No.” He said: “Allaah has more right that you should be modest before Him.” This indicates that it is better to cover the head, but if we apply the words of Allaah - (interpretation of the meaning): “O Children of Aadam! Take your adornment (by wearing your clean clothes) while praying” [al-A’raaf 7:31] – to this issue, we will see that covering the head is better among people who regard covering the head as a kind of adornment. But if we are among people who do not regard that as a kind of adornment, we do not say that covering it is better or that leaving it bare is better. It is proven that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) used to pray in a turban, and the turban is a head covering. End quote. (Al-Sharh al-Mumti’, 2/166)


And Allaah knows best...."

------------

Sources:

https://islamqa.info/en/answers/22758/is-covering-the-head-a-shari-obligation

https://islamqa.info/en/answers/68815/praying-in-half-sleeves-and-bare-headed

 

[m4rouf]

Wow, thank you for the detailed response - that’s very insightful and helpful!
i want to avoid bidah as much as I can by trying to verify the things I was taught as a kid, so thanks a lot for helping with this .