جوري
Soldier Through It!
- Messages
- 27,759
- Reaction score
- 6,095
- Gender
- Female
- Religion
- Islam

I have detached myself from the unusual things I've found insane in my culture and yet also seems to be prevelant in many other ones from Greeks to Romanians and very rampant amongst Muslims.
How Islamic is this whole concept of 'Evil eye'?
Yes people can envy you, they can even desire what you've gone but what of this verse:
At-Tauba (The Repentance)[9:51]


Qul lan yuseebana illa ma kataba Allahu lana huwa mawlana waAAala Allahi falyatawakkali almuminoona
9:51 Say: "Nothing will happen to us except what Allah has decreed for us: He is our protector": and on Allah let the Believers put their trust.
isn't belief in 'evil eye' a form of shirk? Also it seems 99% of the population is suffering from the 'evil eye' could it be that it is just life, sins, circumstance, tests from God- any number of things- who in our midst is not touched by calamity? I'd like to know.. I haven't encountered one person who isn't suffering something major.. so why is evil eye always the foregone conclusions?
It is becoming a peeve of mine and I don't wish to be insensitive but whenever I see it written I feel like I am going to flip my lid.. I really want to understand better these platitudinal conclusions, so we cast schizophrenia as evil eye, and a stain on a new dress as the evil eye, and failure as evil eye and inability to land a job as evil eye, and fluctuations in iman as evil eye.. aren't we just deflecting from our own shortcomings or being impatient with tests we maybe undergoing or sins we maybe expiating for enduring?

isn't belief in 'evil eye' a form of shirk? Also it seems 99% of the population is suffering from the 'evil eye' could it be that it is just life, sins, circumstance, tests from God- any number of things- who in our midst is not touched by calamity? I'd like to know.. I haven't encountered one person who isn't suffering something major.. so why is evil eye always the foregone conclusions?
It is becoming a peeve of mine and I don't wish to be insensitive but whenever I see it written I feel like I am going to flip my lid.. I really want to understand better these platitudinal conclusions, so we cast schizophrenia as evil eye, and a stain on a new dress as the evil eye, and failure as evil eye and inability to land a job as evil eye, and fluctuations in iman as evil eye.. aren't we just deflecting from our own shortcomings or being impatient with tests we maybe undergoing or sins we maybe expiating for enduring?
