Explenation thread for bans

IbnAbdulHakim

IbnAbdulHakim

IB Addict
Messages
16,476
Reaction score
2,628
Gender
Male
Religion
Islam
I think it would be a great idea for people to find out why members are being banned.
 
salaam,

me too :) .... might make us to be a bit more cautious and careful inshAllah. :)

wassalam
 
is that you being nosey? im joking...dont give me evils through the monitor...cos 1. i wont be able to see them and 2. i would laugh if you told me you were giving me EVILs
 
Well, perhaps a description of which rules were broken. I think posting personal/private messages is a breach in respect and judgement. To be told someone was colluding in a negative way through PM in a manner that was deprimental to the forum is much more sincere that actually posting the text.

It's just a question of respecting peoples right to privacy no matter what they may have done.
 
root said:
Well, perhaps a description of which rules were broken. I think posting personal/private messages is a breach in respect and judgement. To be told someone was colluding in a negative way through PM in a manner that was deprimental to the forum is much more sincere that actually posting the text.

It's just a question of respecting peoples right to privacy no matter what they may have done.
Click to expand...

SHOW HIS PM's LOLLLLL ;D
 
root said:
Well, perhaps a description of which rules were broken. I think posting personal/private messages is a breach in respect and judgement. To be told someone was colluding in a negative way through PM in a manner that was deprimental to the forum is much more sincere that actually posting the text.

It's just a question of respecting peoples right to privacy no matter what they may have done.
Click to expand...
Sorry I disagree. It is clearly stated that PM's can be monitored. Furthermore, if you read some PM's of people who were banned, you can see that they were planning something quite disrespectful and rude to say the least. The ban prevented them from doing so.

We are judged by our intentions and the PM’s proved that their intentions were not as they appeared to be at all.
 
Sorry I disagree. It is clearly stated that PM's can be monitored.
Click to expand...

I agree, can you also show me where it says they will be posted on a public forum

Furthermore, if you read some PM's of people who were banned, you can see that they were planning something quite disrespectful and rude to say the least. The ban prevented them from doing so.
Click to expand...

Agreed, and that is presumably why a forum requires moderators to ensure issues like this are spotted and dealt with.

We are judged by our intentions and the PM’s proved that their intentions were not as they appeared to be at all.
Click to expand...

Are we not judged on our actions then? I simply fail to see how public display of wrong doing is required, if that was so why can't we all access each others PM's to ensure intentions are honourable
 
are youre intentions alright? are you doing it for Allah...when you looking deep deep down inside do you have the right.....and so forth...my intentions are good....BAD intentions only hurt you....
 
Salaamz

hummmmmm..........it all happens 4 da gud of da forum! :D so now stop bein nosey bro!! lolzzzzzzz!! ;D nah jokin!! ;)

take care
w/salaam :)
 
root said:
I agree, can you also show me where it says they will be posted on a public forum



Agreed, and that is presumably why a forum requires moderators to ensure issues like this are spotted and dealt with.



Are we not judged on our actions then? I simply fail to see how public display of wrong doing is required, if that was so why can't we all access each others PM's to ensure intentions are honourable
Click to expand...
It was posted on a public forum to insure that people knew why they were banned. It is like (hypothetically) when someone commits a crime, people need to know what crime they have committed to form an opinion. If we were left in the blue without knowing why they were banned and without evidence, we may doubt the mods intentions for banning them. Posting the PM's cleared the doubts from people’s minds (in most cases I presume).
We can’t all access each other's PM's because we are considered the people, not the authority, the mods here are the authority and they have the right to do so as they stated. No one is forced to join this forum, they do so by choice and having done so need to abide by the rules.
 
No I meant about zuhair. I think he may have been one of the people who were banned already.
 
root said:
Can't be arsed.

Have expressed my opinion and switched my PM system off accordingly.
Click to expand...

Theres no need to remove it as only a small minority are thinking your way. YOu dont like it, then please dont use it. Its simple, and you dont have to make a big deal out of it.
 
:sl:
We considered making an explanation thread, but for now we have settled with the idea of posting a link in the banned user's signature which links to the post explaining their ban. The recent bannings have been the result of one banned member's 14 attempts to return to the forum, and a few attempts by another.

:w:
 
Åhmed;265845 said:
Theres no need to remove it as only a small minority are thinking your way. YOu dont like it, then please dont use it. Its simple, and you dont have to make a big deal out of it.
Click to expand...

agreed imam ;)
 
Ansar Al-'Adl said:
:sl:
We considered making an explanation thread, but for now we have settled with the idea of posting a link in the banned user's signature which links to the post explaining their ban. The recent bannings have been the result of one banned member's 14 attempts to return to the forum, and a few attempts by another.

:w:
Click to expand...

i guess i don't understand what you mean by "posting a link in the banned user's signature" cuz i just clicked on zuhair and there was no link to an explanation.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top